Their cakes are magnificent! Not only do they create beautiful cakes and cupcakes, but the taste and texture is out of this world. It was a bit challenging to finalize my order this past August 2025 for my bridal shower, but they did a fantastic job with my main cake and the multiple cupcakes ordered. They also put it together fast as we encountered a few hiccups and almost canceled the bridal shower, but The Cupcake Magician delivered and saved the day for sure! The lemon cake with raspberry was our main cake and I can't describe how spectacular it was in every way possible! Thank you! I highly recommend them! If having any doubts, just don't anymore... place your order!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Sara
Super friendly and helpful team! Such a fun selection of flavors, it was hard to narrow down! Thanks for the best birthday cupcakes :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lori Ruggiero
We were in town for a wake/Funeral and stopped into this cute little shop. The cupcakes were amazing and the staff were so helpful and welcoming. we went and told everyone at the funeral about this place. If you aren’t in the area, please stop in, you definitely will not be disappointed. I wish it was closer. We live in North Jersey, but next time we are in the area, we are definitely making a pitstop at cupcake magician.
Melissa O'Sullivan
Cupcakes are delicious! The flavors are unique and the cupcakes are always fresh. The service is also wonderful. Highly recommend Cupcake Magician for all your cupcake and cake needs!!!
Alvine Rose Rackliff
When my husband and I were looking for bakeries for our wedding, we came across Cupcake magician. We loved all their flavors, and have enjoyed their cakes for years. We hired them for our wedding, our gender reveal for our baby, and now our son’s baptism. We will always go to this bakery because the cakes not only look great, but taste great as well! Their buttercream tastes like buttercream, And their Cakes are not overly sweet. They actually have flavor that does not taste artificial. We are very picky About our sweets, and Cupcake magician delivers! They are the only bakery that we will trust, and best of all, Our family and friends enjoy them so much that there is never any leftovers!
Ordered our engagement party cupcakes from here. They were not only stunning but absolutely delicious. Thank you so much for the incredible service and cupcakes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michele Rhee
Red velvet, cookies and cream, tiramisu, salted caramel, ice cream sundae—delicious and moist and perfect for my nephew’s birthday. Compliments and happiness all around!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies and Cream, Cupcake, Tiramisu
Richard Brown
Amazing cake and fantastic service. Ordered a custom birthday cake, and they absolutely delivered
Jesse
Holly was great. She really knows her cupcakes! Can't wait to come back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria Jonczyk
10/10 CUSTOM CAKE! I wanted to get a custom cake for my boyfriend’s surprise party. Cupcake Magician was incredibly helpful in assisting me through the entire process from choosing a cake to securing with a deposit. The pricing is reasonable and you definitely get what you pay for. The inspiration photo I sent was replicated almost exactly! Incredibly impressed with the entire experience. And the cannoli cake was DELICIOUS!! Will definitely be ordering again if I ever need another custom cake.
Holly was great. She really knows her cupcakes! Can't wait to come back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Princiotta
Ordered a cake and cupcakes for my daughters wedding shower ..Excellent taste and quality …Most enjoyable and the party loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kayla Bromley
Cakes and cupcakes absolutely delicious but that's about it. They have some serious communication and organization issues. My husband put in an order for a 30th birthday cake with a special design. Spoke with a lady on the phone and confirmed order. She asked for images to be sent to their email for the cake design which he sent. We were supposed to have a call with the cake designer to confirm everything and they never called. He assumed everything was good to go. He picked up the cake and it was their regular basic design not the special design requested. He spoke with someone on the phone again and said they were sorry but they couldn't offer a solution because the cake designer wasn't in and basically said that sucks but too bad for you. Husband was supposed to get a call that following Monday from the cake designer to discuss the issue and so they could offer us something for the mistake and NO ONE CALLED. Absolutely unorganized and terrible business and customer service. Such a bummer because it was a favorite bakery of my family. We'll never go back. So disappointed. I hope management sees this and fixes their issues. I'd hate for someone else be be absolutely devastated and disappointed on a very special birthday. This place really did ruin something that was super important to me.
Jacqueline Ortez
The best gluten free cupcake I have ever had! I tried the carrot cake and the chocolate one with cannoli cream. Sooooo good!
Erin Maloney
They made the best the cupcakes for my wedding!!! Loved them so much
Their cakes are magnificent! Not only do they create beautiful cakes and cupcakes, but the taste and texture is out of this world. It was a bit challenging to finalize my order this past August 2025 for my bridal shower, but they did a fantastic job with my main cake and the multiple cupcakes ordered. They also put it together fast as we encountered a few hiccups and almost canceled the bridal shower, but The Cupcake Magician delivered and saved the day for sure! The lemon cake with raspberry was our main cake and I can't describe how spectacular it was in every way possible! Thank you! I highly recommend them! If having any doubts, just don't anymore... place your order!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Super friendly and helpful team! Such a fun selection of flavors, it was hard to narrow down! Thanks for the best birthday cupcakes :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were in town for a wake/Funeral and stopped into this cute little shop. The cupcakes were amazing and the staff were so helpful and welcoming. we went and told everyone at the funeral about this place. If you aren’t in the area, please stop in, you definitely will not be disappointed. I wish it was closer. We live in North Jersey, but next time we are in the area, we are definitely making a pitstop at cupcake magician.
Cupcakes are delicious! The flavors are unique and the cupcakes are always fresh. The service is also wonderful. Highly recommend Cupcake Magician for all your cupcake and cake needs!!!
When my husband and I were looking for bakeries for our wedding, we came across Cupcake magician. We loved all their flavors, and have enjoyed their cakes for years. We hired them for our wedding, our gender reveal for our baby, and now our son’s baptism. We will always go to this bakery because the cakes not only look great, but taste great as well! Their buttercream tastes like buttercream, And their Cakes are not overly sweet. They actually have flavor that does not taste artificial. We are very picky About our sweets, and Cupcake magician delivers! They are the only bakery that we will trust, and best of all, Our family and friends enjoy them so much that there is never any leftovers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baby Shower, Wedding Cake, Cake, Tiramisu, Birthday Cake
Ordered our engagement party cupcakes from here. They were not only stunning but absolutely delicious. Thank you so much for the incredible service and cupcakes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Red velvet, cookies and cream, tiramisu, salted caramel, ice cream sundae—delicious and moist and perfect for my nephew’s birthday. Compliments and happiness all around!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies and Cream, Cupcake, Tiramisu
Amazing cake and fantastic service. Ordered a custom birthday cake, and they absolutely delivered
Holly was great. She really knows her cupcakes! Can't wait to come back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
10/10 CUSTOM CAKE! I wanted to get a custom cake for my boyfriend’s surprise party. Cupcake Magician was incredibly helpful in assisting me through the entire process from choosing a cake to securing with a deposit. The pricing is reasonable and you definitely get what you pay for. The inspiration photo I sent was replicated almost exactly! Incredibly impressed with the entire experience. And the cannoli cake was DELICIOUS!! Will definitely be ordering again if I ever need another custom cake.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake
Restaurantji Recommends
Holly was great. She really knows her cupcakes! Can't wait to come back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a cake and cupcakes for my daughters wedding shower ..Excellent taste and quality …Most enjoyable and the party loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cakes and cupcakes absolutely delicious but that's about it. They have some serious communication and organization issues. My husband put in an order for a 30th birthday cake with a special design. Spoke with a lady on the phone and confirmed order. She asked for images to be sent to their email for the cake design which he sent. We were supposed to have a call with the cake designer to confirm everything and they never called. He assumed everything was good to go. He picked up the cake and it was their regular basic design not the special design requested. He spoke with someone on the phone again and said they were sorry but they couldn't offer a solution because the cake designer wasn't in and basically said that sucks but too bad for you. Husband was supposed to get a call that following Monday from the cake designer to discuss the issue and so they could offer us something for the mistake and NO ONE CALLED. Absolutely unorganized and terrible business and customer service. Such a bummer because it was a favorite bakery of my family. We'll never go back. So disappointed. I hope management sees this and fixes their issues. I'd hate for someone else be be absolutely devastated and disappointed on a very special birthday. This place really did ruin something that was super important to me.
The best gluten free cupcake I have ever had! I tried the carrot cake and the chocolate one with cannoli cream. Sooooo good!
They made the best the cupcakes for my wedding!!! Loved them so much
Loading...