The Dining Room at the Molly Pitcher Inn

I was pleasantly surprised. The view was lovely, piano music. The tuna tostado was delicious fresh tuna avocado pickled onions, filet mignon was cooked as ordered and creamy mashed potatoes and a nice horseradish sauce. The steak needed a sauce. The grilled orange old fashioned was good but I didn't like my martini I think it was either the vermouth or olive juice or the combo. Overall a good experience I would recommend and return.

Loved the seafood pot pie and the chocolate mousse cake! The noise level made us have to lean over the table and talk loudly to the people we were with.

Asparagus quiche and salad were very good and apple crumble was tasty. All a good size portion for lunch. Staff was friendly and helpful. A lovely experience.

Had a wonderful anniversary dinner! Staff is so friendly and attentive; decor and view is really nice; short ribs were excellent and my husband raved over the seafood chowder. Menu prices are very reasonable, especially for the quality. We were treated to champagne and dessert because it was our anniversary. Had such a nice night. Highly recommend!

It was a beautiful day, so we sat outside to enjoy our brunch! I had the chorizo and egg sandwich on a baguette with fresh avocado!! It was delicious!! My picky daughter had the lobster roll, and she was very happy! It came with a salad and a pesto vinaigrette dressing, it was delightful! Debbie our server was on top of everything! She made the experience even better!!

The Molly Pitcher Inn is a wonderful place to dine. They are consistent, it's a lovely setting, complete with a view of the Navesink River. It's cozy, food is great as is the service and attention to detail. Highly recommend.

I meet friends for lunch at the Molly quite frequently because the service is excellent and the atmosphere is very nice. They don't mind that we stay for a long time to catch up and are very accommodating. The only wish I had is that there were some gluten free options (other than salad) on the menu for one of my friends.

The day was beautiful, food was good and great day to be dining outside. However, a group of VERY LOUD men disrupted the lunch meeting. Restaurant was great. Humans were inconsiderate of other diners.

We had table outside with beautiful view of the water food was excellent so was service our waiter was so accommodating and professional definitely come back again

Enjoyed our delicious lunch our waitress Sue was excellent. Everyone worked well together. Recommended Molly Picture Inn for lunch to our family and friends. Impressed how clean restaurant was, Looking forward to lunch here again soon.

We were Married @ the Molly Pitcher 10 years ago this week . We came to celebrate @ Molly due to the wonderful time we have always had there . We were disappointed that we made a Reservation with Patrick early in the week to be able to sit by window. When we Arrived the young Hostess did not honor she said she saw that on Reservation but was too busy. What is the point of a Resservation if not honored . They did come over after people left & asked if we wanted to move but by the the moment passed. The waiter & waitress were excellent & the waitress came over with a drink on the house for our Anniversary so I'd like to thank you fot that . It was a very nice gesture . Food , service was excellent .

Our server Debbie went above and beyond to accommodate my allergies and craving for a crab cake! We had a fantastic experience and will be back. Highly recommend.

View & atmosphere was fantastic. Food was excellent. The only negative is they were short of staff for service

Ambiance was phenomenal! Very pretty place and large Windows to see on the outside marina. Generous spacing for the tables. Food was lackluster at best as I recall it being much better years back. The Caesar salad have the sprinkle parmesan from a can rather than fresh shaved Parmesan as I would expect from a place like this. I had a quinoa salad and it was probably the worst salad I've ever ordered anywhere. It was with arugula which was an odd combination and the salmon that came atop was literally possibly 2 oz. A tiny square which I have never seen served anywhere whether on a salad or otherwise. My just called for apples and walnuts and there were a few slices of Apple on one side of the plate and no walnuts. I will not be returning anytime soon. I can understand if the food wasn't phenomenal but it should at least be better than it was.

Food was fantastic and prices were very reasonable. I started off with the best French Onion Soup. Entree was Braised Short Ribs over Risotto. It was delicious. Everyone else loved their dishes. Definitely coming back.