Gotham City Diner
Customers' Favorites
Menu
Benedict's
-
Avocado Benny $16.75
Avocado, baby spinach, bacon, & hollandaise sauce on garlic bread. Open-faced English muffins & poached egg sandwiches. Served with home fries.
-
Benny Classic $13.50
Canadian bacon & hollandaise sauce. Open-faced English muffins & poached egg sandwiches. Served with home fries.
-
Benny Florentine $13.95
Spinach & hollandaise sauce. Open-faced English muffins & poached egg sandwiches. Served with home fries.
-
Steak Benny $20.75
London broil & hollandaise sauce. Open-faced English muffins & poached egg sandwiches. Served with home fries.
-
Smoked Salmon Benny $18.50
Smoked salmon & hollandaise sauce. Open-faced English muffins & poached egg sandwiches. Served with home fries.
-
Santa Fe Benny $16.50
Chorizo hash & chipotle hollandaise sauce. Open-faced English muffins & poached egg sandwiches. Served with home fries.
-
Meat Lover's Benny $16.75
Bacon, sausage, ham, & hollandaise sauce. Open-faced English muffins & poached egg sandwiches. Served with home fries.
Egg Cellent
-
Two Eggs $7.50
Cooked the way you like them. Served with home fries & toast.
-
California Avocado Toast $13.95
Mashed avocado, sliced tomato, fried eggs, and bacon. Served on toasted multi-grain bread. Cooked the way you like them. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Huevos Rancheros $13.95
"Rancher's egg" sunny side up eggs. Served on corn tortillas, with beans, rice, guacamole, salsa, & crumbled feta cheese with sliced avocado on the side. Cooked the way you like them. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Chorizo Hash & Eggs $11.95
Cooked the way you like them. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Sliced Steak & Eggs $21.95
Cooked the way you like them. Served with home fries & toast.
3 Eggs Omelettes
-
Western Omelette $12.95
Peppers, onions, & ham. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Bob's Big Delight Omelette $16.50
Sausage, bacon, onions, Cheddar, Jack cheese, potato, & scallions. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Veggie Omelette $13.95
Tomatoes, onions, mushrooms, broccoli, & peppers. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Meat Lover's Omelette $15.50
Bacon, sausage, & ham. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Greek Omelette $12.95
Tomato, onions, & feta cheese. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Moderna Omelette $14.75
Portobello mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, & basil. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Downtown Omelette $15.25
Sausage, peppers, onions, tomatoes, & Cheddar cheese. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Turkey Lover's Omelette $15.75
Turkey bacon, turkey sausage, & roast turkey. Served with home fries & toast.
-
South of the Border Omelette $16.50
Chorizo, onions, peppers, scallions, pepper Jack, & Cheddar cheese. Topped with salsa verde. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Dinner Classic Omelette $12.75
Ham & American cheese. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Spanish Omelette $12.95
With our own creole sauce. Served with home fries & toast.
-
Broadway Omelette $15.75
Corned beef, pastrami, & Swiss cheese. Served with home fries & toast.
Create Your Own Omelette
-
Create Your Own Fluffy 3 Egg Omelette $7.70
Served with home fries & toast.
Pancakes, French Toast, and Belgian Waffles
-
Fluffy Buttermilk Pancakes $9.50
Made from scratch with our family recipe.
-
Short Stack Pancakes $7.95
Made from scratch with our family recipe.
-
Chocolate Chip Pancakes $10.75
Made from scratch with our family recipe.
-
Belgian Waffle $9.50
-
Blueberry Pancakes $11.95
Made from scratch with our family recipe.
-
Oreo Pancakes $10.75
Made from scratch with our family recipe.
-
Cinnamon French Toast $9.50
-
Bananas Foster Waffle $13.95
Caramelized bananas, pecans, brown sugar, & rum. Topped with whipped cream.
-
Apple Cinnamon Pancakes $10.75
Made from scratch with our family recipe.
-
City Slam $14.50
French toast with two eggs any style, ham, bacon, sausage, or Taylor ham.
-
Boston Cream French Toast $12.50
Topped with Bavarian cream & chocolate sauce.
-
Silver Dollar Pancakes $9.50
Made from scratch with our family recipe.
-
GCD Tower $16.75
Layers of French toast, bananas, strawberries, blueberries, waffle quarters, & English cream with a maple cinnamon glaze & walnuts. Topped with whipped cream.
-
S'Mores French Toast $12.50
Graham cracker crusted French toast with marshmallow & chocolate chips.
-
Belgian Waffle with Fresh Fruit Salad $11.95
-
Whole Wheat Pancakes $9.95
Made from scratch with our family recipe.
-
Belgian Waffle with Ice Cream (Two Scoops) $11.95
-
Banana Choco Nella Waffle $15.25
Layered Nutella, bananas, & two scoops of vanilla ice cream. Topped with whipped cream.
Breakfast Add-Ons
-
Bacon $4.40
-
Egg $1.65
-
Pork Sausage $4.40
-
Corned Beef Hash $4.95
-
Turkey Bacon $4.95
-
Turkey Sausage $4.95
-
Fresh Strawberries $2.75
-
Ham $4.40
-
Banana $2.75
-
Canadian Bacon $4.95
-
Taylor Ham $4.95
-
Chorizo Sausage $4.95
-
Blueberries $2.75
Breads, Muffins, & Pastries
-
Buttered Toast $2.75
-
Bagel $3.85
-
Assorted Muffins $3.85
-
Buttered Roll $2.75
-
Cinnamon Toast(3 pcs) $3.60
-
English Muffin Sandwich Size $3.85
-
Bagel for One $16.50
With cream cheese & lox (3 slices), lettuce, tomato, olives, & onion.
-
Bagel for Two $23.50
With two bagels, cream cheese & lox (6 slices), lettuce, tomato, olives, & onion.
Breakfast Sides
-
Bacon $6.05
-
Home Fries $5.25
-
Turkey Sausage $6.60
-
Pork Sausage $6.05
-
Chorizo Hash $7.15
-
Corned Beef Hash $7.15
-
Chorizo Sausage $6.60
-
Ham $6.05
-
Taylor Ham $7.15
-
Canadian Bacon $7.15
-
Turkey Bacon $6.60
-
Smoked Salmon $8.25
-
Cottage Cheese $5.25
Juices and Fruits
-
Orange Juice $4.00
-
Pineapple Juice $4.00
-
Apple Juice $4.00
-
Fresh Fruit Salad $6.85
-
Lemonade Juice $4.00
-
Yogurt Parfait $9.50
Choice of vanilla or plain yogurt with fresh berries & our homemade granola.
-
Honeydew (Quarter) $5.50
-
Grapefruit Juice $4.00
-
Tomato Juice $4.00
-
Cranberry Juice $4.00
-
Fresh Strawberries $6.60
-
Grapefruit (Half) $4.40
-
Cantaloupe (Half) $5.50
Cereals
-
Gotham Oatmeal $7.15
Walnuts, raisins, bananas, brown sugar, cinnamon, & a touch of maple syrup.
-
Hot Oatmeal Cereal $4.95
Appetizers
-
Chicken Fingers $12.75
Served with honey mustard & BBQ sauce (spicy buffalo style upon request). Served with bleu cheese dressing.
-
Gotham City Wings $11.50
Crispy fried tossed with choice of teriyaki, spicy buffalo, or Carolina dry rub.
-
Santa Fe Quesadilla $10.25
Served with salsa verde, chipotle sour cream, & guacamole.
-
Tex-Mex Rolls $13.95
Southwest style chicken rolls, spicy chicken, corn, black beans, peppers, onions, & melted cheese. Served with salsa verde, chipotle sour cream, & guacamole.
-
Mozzarella Sticks $12.75
Fried crispy golden brown. Served with marinara sauce.
-
Nachos $12.75
Great for sharing! Tortilla chips topped with Cheddar & Jack cheeses, tomato salsa, guacamole, jalapeños, & sour cream.
-
Gotham's Appetizer Combo $18.95
Great for sharing! Wings, Tex-Mex roll, cheese quesadilla, & mozzarella sticks. Served with salsa verde, bleu cheese, & marinara sauce.
-
BBQ Beef Brisket Sliders $12.75
Slow roasted brisket with BBQ sauce. Topped with goat cheese, arugula, & crispy onions.
-
Loaded Skins $12.75
Potato skins loaded with Jack and Cheddar cheese with choice of bacon or broccoli. Served with sour cream.
-
Popcorn Shrimp $14.50
Dusted with creole seasoning. Served with spicy remoulade sauce.
-
Fried Calamari $15.95
Lightly breaded with our lemon-garlic aioli and fra diavolo sauce.
-
Spinach & Artichoke Dip $18.95
Great for sharing! Our classic recipe. Served piping hot with tortilla chips.
-
Reuben Sliders $12.75
Mini corned beef Rueben's on mini rolls with sauerkraut, Russian dressing, & Swiss cheese.
Over the Top Fries
-
Techno Fries $10.75
Our famous French fries topped with brown gravy & American cheese.
-
Chili-Jack Fries $12.75
Our French fries topped with chili & pepper Jack cheese.
-
Texas BBQ Fries $11.95
Our French fries topped with New York sharp Cheddar cheese, crispy smoked bacon, & BBQ sauce.
-
Nachos Fries $12.75
Our French fries topped with Cheddar & Jack cheeses and jalapeños. Served with tomato salsa & guacamole.
-
Gotham Express Fries $12.75
Our French fries with our secret steak sauce. Topped with chopped scallions, tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella cheese.
-
Greek Fries $11.50
Lemon fries topped with oregano & crumbled feta cheese.
Homemade Soups
-
Chicken Soup $5.45
Chicken broth with vegetables and with lots of chicken pcs. Prepared fresh daily.
-
French Onion Soup $8.40
Served with provolone & croutons. Prepared fresh daily.
-
Consomme Soup $5.45
Served with matzoh balls. Prepared fresh daily.
Crispy Salads
-
Caesar Salad $12.95
Crisp romaine, shredded pecorino Romano cheese, & garlic croutons.
-
Greek Salad $14.75
Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, crumbled feta, red onions, Kalamata olives, grape leaves, & pepperoncini with our house dressing.
-
Romano Chicken Tender Salad $18.95
Breaded chicken tenders sliced over mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, & red onion. Topped with shredded pecorino Romano cheese with creamy Italian dressing.
-
Gotham House Salad $11.25
Romaine & iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, & croutons with choice of dressing.
-
Avocado Chicken Salad $19.75
Marinated grilled chicken over mixed greens, avocado, walnuts, red onions, & crumbled bleu cheese with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
-
Apple Pecan Salad $18.75
Grilled marinated chicken over mixed greens, apples, pecans, craisins, & Monterey Jack cheese with choice of dressing.
-
Apple Berry Salad $19.75
Marinated grilled chicken over field greens, strawberries, Granny Smith apples, goat cheese, & pine nuts with our house dressing.
-
Tuscan Portobello Chicken Salad $19.75
Grilled marinated chicken over field greens, portobello mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, & roasted peppers with our house dressing.
-
Mandarin Chicken Salad $18.50
Grilled marinated chicken over mixed greens, Mandarin oranges, lo mein noodles, roasted almonds, & sesame seeds with sesame tahini dressing.
-
Buffalo Chicken Salad $19.75
Boneless chicken wings tossed with buffalo sauce over mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, & melted Cheddar cheese with choice of dressing.
-
Thai Beef Salad $22.25
Grilled skirt steak over mixed greens, zucchini, yellow squash, carrots, cucumber, tomato, & sesame seeds with an Asian chili-lime vinaigrette.
-
Starburst Salad $16.44
Smoked turkey over baby spinach with goat cheese, almonds, Mandarin oranges, strawberries, & grapes with our famous house dressing.
-
BBQ Cobb Salad $20.95
BBQ grilled chicken over romaine lettuce, bacon, avocado, bleu cheese, tomatoes, hard-boiled egg, & Kalamata olives with bleu cheese dressing.
-
Quinoa Salad $9.55
A mix of red & white quinoa, roasted sweet potato, red onion, pumpkin seeds, and grape tomatoes. Served with choice of dressing.
-
Garden Spinach Salad $12.15
Fresh baby spinach, mushrooms, hard-boiled egg, tomatoes, red onion, & crumbled bacon with our famous house dressing.
-
Chef Salad $19.50
Sliced turkey, ham, Swiss cheese, American cheese, & roast beef over mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, & hard-boiled egg with choice of dressing.
-
Santa Barbara Salad $19.75
Grilled marinated chicken over mixed greens, Mandarin oranges, walnuts, craisins, & bleu cheese with choice of dressing.
Wrap' T
-
Chicken Caesar Wrap $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with romaine lettuce, shredded Romano, & Caesar dressing. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Park Avenue Wrap $17.50
Spicy grilled chicken, guacamole, Jack cheese, lettuce, & salsa mayonnaise. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Buffalo Chicken Wrap $17.50
Breaded chicken with Buffalo sauce, Jack cheese, jalapeño peppers, lettuce, & tomato. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Honey Balsamic Chicken Wrap $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with honey balsamic dressing, fresh mozzarella cheese, lettuce, & tomato. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Philly Wrap $17.50
Thinly sliced steak with grilled onions, peppers, & melted American cheese. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Greek Chicken Wrap $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, & feta cheese. Served with our house dressing. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Greek London Broil Wrap $17.50
Char-grilled London broil with lettuce, tomato, & feta cheese. Served with our famous house dressing. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Majestic Wrap $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken, sliced pears, baby spinach, feta cheese, walnuts, & balsamic glaze. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Veggie Hummus Wrap $17.50
Oven-roasted zucchini, yellow squash, eggplant, tomato with spinach, & lemon-herb hummus. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
BBQ Chicken Wrap $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with BBQ sauce, Cheddar cheese, lettuce, & tomato. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle and homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Waldorf Chicken Wrap $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with Granny Smith apples, lettuce, tomato, crumbled bleu cheese, walnuts, & our house dressing. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Laguna Wrap $17.50
Roast fresh turkey, avocado, bacon, red onions, romaine, Swiss cheese, & cranberry citrus vinaigrette dressing. Served on garlic pesto wrap with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
Fresh Pressed Paninis
-
Tuscan Fresh Pressed Panini $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella cheese, roasted peppers, & baby spinach. Stuffed with your favorites & made hot & crispy on a hot iron press. Served with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Prima Pesto Chicken Fresh Pressed Panini $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken, grilled tomatoes, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella cheese, & basil pesto. Stuffed with your favorites & made hot & crispy on a hot iron press. Served with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Gotham Jack Fresh Pressed Panini $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken, pepper Jack cheese, grilled mushrooms, & bacon. Stuffed with your favorites & made hot & crispy on a hot iron press. Served with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Venice Beach Fresh Pressed Panini $17.50
Roast beef, mozzarella cheese, arugula, tomato, red onion, & basil mayonnaise. Stuffed with your favorites & made hot & crispy on a hot iron press. Served with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Chicken Malibu Fresh Pressed Panini $17.50
Breaded chicken with ham, Swiss cheese, & honey mustard. Stuffed with your favorites & made hot & crispy on a hot iron press. Served with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Cuban Fresh Pressed Panini $17.50
Pulled pork, ham, Swiss cheese, sliced pickles, & Dijon mayonnaise. Stuffed with your favorites & made hot & crispy on a hot iron press. Served with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Smoked Turkey Fresh Pressed Panini $17.50
Served with crispy bacon, tomatoes, & Jack cheese. Stuffed with your favorites & made hot & crispy on a hot iron press. Served with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Chicken Portobello Fresh Pressed Panini $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken, portobello mushrooms, onions, & provolone cheese. Stuffed with your favorites & made hot & crispy on a hot iron press. Served with seasoned fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
Deli Sandwiches
-
BLT Deli Sandwich $8.25
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Chicken Salad Deli Sandwich $8.75
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Grilled American Cheese Deli Sandwich $7.65
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Roast Turkey Deli Sandwich $12.00
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Taylor Ham, Egg, & Cheese Deli Sandwich $9.85
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Pastrami Deli Sandwich $12.35
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Tuna Salad Deli Sandwich $9.75
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Corned Beef Deli Sandwich $12.35
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Egg Salad Deli Sandwich $7.40
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Smoked Turkey Deli Sandwich $10.95
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Individual Tuna Deli Sandwich $9.75
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Taylor Ham Deli Sandwich $8.25
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Fried Egg Deli Sandwich $6.05
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Roast Beef Deli Sandwich $11.55
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Mama's Meatloaf Deli Sandwich $11.55
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Grilled Swiss Cheese Deli Sandwich $8.25
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Grilled Cheddar Cheese Deli Sandwich $8.25
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Boiled Ham Deli Sandwich $9.35
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Taylor Ham & Egg Deli Sandwich $9.85
Pickle & our homemade Cole slaw upon request.
Specialty Sandwiches
-
Lancaster Pretzel Specialty Sandwich $15.35
Marinated grilled chicken on a buttered pretzel roll. Topped with pepper Jack cheese, baby spinach, sliced apple, & cranberry mayonnaise. Served with French fries. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Triple Decker Club Specialty Sandwich $14.85
Your choice of roast beef, roast turkey, smoked turkey, ham, tuna salad, chicken salad, or grilled chicken. Topped with crispy smoked bacon, lettuce, & tomato. Served with French fries. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
City Classic Reuben Specialty Sandwich $15.35
Pastrami, corned beef, or turkey with sauerkraut on rye. Topped with melted Swiss cheese. Served with French fries and Russian dressing. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
BBQ Beef Brisket Specialty Sandwich $16.44
Slow roasted beef brisket with BBQ sauce, sauteed onions, & mushrooms on a ciabatta roll. Served with French fries. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Tuna Melt Specialty Sandwich $13.75
Chunky tuna salad on a large English muffin topped with fresh grilled tomato slices & melted Cheddar cheese. Served with French fries. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Bronx Bomber Specialty Sandwich $16.44
Thinly sliced steak with sauteed onions & provolone cheese on a garlic ciabatta roll. Served with French fries. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
The Gotham Express Specialty Sandwich $18.65
Sliced seasoned skirt steak. Tossed in our secret steak sauce. Topped with chopped scallions, tomato, & fresh mozzarella cheese on a garlic ciabatta roll. Served with French fries. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Gyro Specialty Sandwich $14.85
Seasoned beef wrapped in a pita with shredded lettuce, tomato, & onions. Served with French fries & our zesty cucumber sauce. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
French Dip Specialty Sandwich $15.95
Thinly sliced roast beef on a ciabatta roll. Served with French fries & au jus for dipping. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Pulled Pork Specialty Sandwich $15.95
Fresh and tender BBQ pulled pork. Served on a brioche roll with shoestring onions. Topped with Cole slaw. Served with sweet potato fries. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
-
Chicken Souvlaki Specialty Sandwich $14.85
Marinated & wrapped in a pita with shredded lettuce, tomato, & onions. Served with French fries & our zesty cucumber sauce. Pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request.
Chicken Sandwiches
-
American Classic Chicken Sandwich $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, & American cheese. Served on a Kaiser roll with our famous fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Manhattan Chicken Sandwich $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with mozzarella cheese & grilled tomatoes. Served on a Kaiser roll with our famous fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Bourbon Street Chicken Sandwich $17.50
Blackened chicken with Cajun spices, hot peppers, & Jack cheese. Served on a Kaiser roll with our famous fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Back Yard BBQ Chicken Sandwich $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with Cheddar cheese, bacon, & our famous BBQ sauce. Served on a Kaiser roll with our famous fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Portobello Chicken Sandwich $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with portobello mushrooms, fresh basil, tomatoes, & fresh mozzarella cheese. Served on a Kaiser roll with our famous fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Chicken Cordon Bleu Sandwich $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken with grilled ham & melted Swiss cheese. Served on a Kaiser roll with our famous fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Milano Chicken Sandwich $17.50
Marinated grilled chicken topped with sun-dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella cheese, & a touch of garlic. Served on a Kaiser roll with our famous fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich $17.50
Breaded chicken topped with mozzarella cheese & marinara sauce. Served on a Kaiser roll with our famous fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
Signature Burgers (1/2 lb)
-
Saloon Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with pepper Jack cheese, shoestring onions, & our steak mayonnaise. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
American Classic Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with crispy smoked bacon, Cheddar, & American cheese. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Texas Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with New York sharp Cheddar cheese, crispy smoked bacon, & BBQ sauce. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Up All Night Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with a fried egg, crispy bacon, & American cheese. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Soho Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with sauteed mushrooms & Swiss cheese. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Tzatziki Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with our homemade tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomato, and red onion. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Elmwood Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with crispy smoked bacon, sauteed mushrooms, & Swiss cheese. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Gotham Patty Melt Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Pressed on rye with Swiss cheese & crispy smoked bacon. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Brooklyn Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with sauteed peppers, onions, mushrooms, & a touch of Worcestershire sauce. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Twisted Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Served on a buttered pretzel roll topped with bacon, grilled red onions, Gouda cheese, & spicy brown mustard. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Canadian Smokehouse Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with Canadian bacon, crispy smoked bacon, New York sharp Cheddar cheese, & grilled onions. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Park Avenue Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with Jack cheese, guacamole, & salsa mayonnaise. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Route 66 Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Blackened with Cajun spices topped with Jack cheese & grilled onion. Served with shoestring fries. (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
-
Red Hook Burger (1/2 lb) $17.75
Topped with our special seasoning, Gouda cheese, shoestring onions, & chipotle mayonnaise. Served with shoestring fries (pickle & homemade Cole slaw upon request).
Burgers
-
Cheeseburger $10.25
Your choice of cheese.
-
Gotham City Burger $8.75
Made with 100% black angus beef served with pickle & our homemade Cole slaw.
-
Pizza Burger $10.95
-
Turkey Burger $10.50
-
Veggie Burger $10.50
Sides
-
French Fries $6.60
-
Onion Rings $8.25
-
John T's Broccoli $7.65
Sauteed with garlic & olive oil.
-
Seasoned Fries $7.70
-
Shoestring Fries $7.15
-
Garlic Mashed Potatoes $6.50
-
Homemade Cole Slaw $5.50
-
Sweet Potato Fries $8.25
-
Garlic Bread $4.50
-
Linguine $9.35
-
Penne $9.35
-
Baked Potato $5.25
-
Ziti $9.35
-
Stuffed Grape Leaves (4 pcs) $6.35
-
Mashed Potatoes $6.05
-
Potato Salad $5.50
Dinner Classic Specialties
-
Roasted Turkey $22.95
Layers of turkey on traditional stuffing served with turkey gravy & cranberry sauce with choice of potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Mama's Fried Chicken $21.50
Honey dipped breaded chicken. Served with French fries & homemade Cole slaw. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Chicken (Half) $22.95
Roasted with olive oil & herbs. Served with stuffing & choice of potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Piled High Meatloaf $20.95
Thick slices of homemade meatloaf piled on top of our mashed potatoes with grilled onions & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Roasted Top Sirloin of Beef $22.95
Served in it's own natural sauce with choice of potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
Sizzling Fajitas
-
Shrimp Fajita $27.75
Served with sauteed bell peppers, onions, Cajun spices, jalapeno peppers, fresh cilantro, sour cream, Cheddar cheese, guacamole, & warm flour tortillas.
-
Steak Sizzling Fajita $23.75
Served with sauteed bell peppers, onions, Cajun spices, jalapeno peppers, fresh cilantro, sour cream, Cheddar cheese, guacamole, & warm flour tortillas.
-
Chicken Sizzling Fajita $22.50
Served with sauteed bell peppers, onions, Cajun spices, jalapeno peppers, fresh cilantro, sour cream, Cheddar cheese, guacamole, & warm flour tortillas.
-
Chicken and Steak Combo Sizzling Fajita $24.75
Served with sauteed bell peppers, onions, Cajun spices, jalapeno peppers, fresh cilantro, sour cream, Cheddar cheese, guacamole, & warm flour tortillas.
Pasta and Chicken
-
Chicken Parmigiana $24.25
Breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese. Served over linguine. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Chicken and Broccoli Pasta $24.25
Chicken & broccoli in a white wine butter sauce with a touch of garlic. Tossed with penne pasta. Topped with grated Romano cheese. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Chicken Portobello $24.25
Sauteed chicken with sun-dried tomatoes, artichokes, & portobello mushrooms. Prepared in our delicious light brown sauce. Served with rice or linguine. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Rigatoni Alla Vodka $19.75
Rigatoni pasta with crushed plum tomatoes in our light pink cream sauce with a touch of vodka. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Chicken Penne Pesto $24.25
Penne pasta tossed with chicken & fresh tomatoes in our pesto sauce. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Chicken Teriyaki $24.25
Sauteed chicken with fresh chopped veggies & ginger in a light teriyaki sauce. Topped with sesame seeds. Served with rice, fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, and a cup of soup.
-
Specialty Macaroni and Cheese $20.95
Elbow pasta, Cheddar, & Gouda cheese with breadcrumb topping. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Mediterranean Chicken $24.25
Tender chicken chunks with onions, peppers, mushrooms, broccoli, & tomatoes in a light white wine sauce. Served with rice, fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, and a cup of soup.
-
Sauteed Chicken $24.25
Marsala, franchise, scampi, or piccata with choice of potato, rice, or pasta. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Rigatoni Bolognese $22.50
Rigatoni pasta with our hearty slow-cooked meat sauce. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
-
Chicken Murphy $24.25
Sauteed chicken with peppers, mushrooms, & crispy potatoes in a lemon white wine sauce with choice of potato, rice, or pasta. Served with fresh bread, a crispy dinner salad, & a cup of soup.
Steak, Chops, and Ribs
-
London Broil $29.95
Boneless marinated flank steak sliced & char-grilled to your specifications. Served in our house marinade. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, soup, and choice of potato & vegetable.
-
Pork Chops $25.25
Butcher cut pork chops char-broiled. Served with flame-roasted apple. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, soup, and choice of potato & vegetable.
-
Baby Back Ribs $26.25
Slow-roasted ribs glazed in BBQ sauce. Served with shoestring fries & homemade Cole slaw. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, soup, and choice of potato & vegetable.
-
Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak $31.95
Chimichurri style with peppers, onions, & garlic or plain. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, soup, and choice of potato & vegetable.
-
Ribs & Chicken $29.95
Our slow-roasted ribs & chicken breast both glazed in BBQ sauce. Served with shoestring fries & homemade Cole slaw. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, soup, and choice of potato & vegetable.
Down by the Sea
-
Flamed Grilled Salmon $29.25
Grilled Atlantic salmon topped with a caper & dill cream spread. Served with potato & grilled vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup.
-
Shrimp Parmigiana $26.25
Breaded fried shrimp with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese. Served over linguine. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup. Many of our seafood dishes can be prepared to your liking, broiled, pan seared, grilled, or fried.
-
Fish and Chips $25.25
Fresh beer battered Atlantic scrod and fried golden brown. Served with French fries and tartar sauce. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup. Many of our seafood dishes can be prepared to your liking, broiled, pan seared, grilled, or fried.
-
Broiled Salmon $26.50
Broiled Atlantic salmon. Served with potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup.
-
Siesta Scrod $25.25
Scrod fillet broiled with lemon butter, white wine, & a touch of garlic. Served with potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup. Many of our seafood dishes can be prepared to your liking, broiled, pan seared, grilled, or fried.
-
Fulton's Fillet $29.95
Broiled fillet served with lemon butter, white wine, & a touch of garlic. Served with potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup. Many of our seafood dishes can be prepared to your liking, broiled, pan seared, grilled, or fried.
-
Fulton's Stuffed Filet $32.50
Fillet stuffed with crab meat stuffing, broiled with lemon butter, white wine, & a touch of garlic. Served with potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup. Many of our seafood dishes can be prepared to your liking, broiled, pan seared, grilled, or fried.
-
Broiled Tilapia $24.25
Served with potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup.
-
Blackened Tilapia $24.25
Served with potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup.
-
Fried Scallops $32.95
Served with potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup.
-
Scampi Style Shrimp (6 pcs) $29.25
Jumbo shrimp sauteed in a garlic & butter sauce. Served over linguine. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup. Many of our seafood dishes can be prepared to your liking, broiled, pan seared, grilled, or fried.
-
Seaside Shrimp (6 pcs) $29.25
Juicy shrimp. Served broiled or fried with tartar & cocktail sauce. Served with potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup.
-
Stuffed Seaside Shrimp (4 pcs) $31.95
Juicy shrimp with crab meat stuffing. Served with potato & vegetable. Served with fresh bread, crispy dinner salad, & soup. Many of our seafood dishes can be prepared to your liking, broiled, pan seared, grilled, or fried.
Gotham City's Sweet Stuff
-
Gelato (2 Scoops) $5.50
Premium Italian ice cream (assorted flavors)- two scoops.
-
Fudge Brownies $4.35
-
Sundaes (2 Scoops) $6.50
Syrup & whipped cream.
-
Oreo Cheesecake $7.65
-
Gourmet Carrot Cake $7.65
-
Assorted Pudding $4.95
-
Assorted Pies $6.05
-
Assorted Pound Cake $3.85
-
Strawberry Cheesecake $7.65
-
Plain Cheesecake $7.15
-
Banana Split $13.00
A split ripe banana with vanilla, chocolate, & strawberry ice cream, wet walnuts, chocolate syrup, & whipped cream.
-
Ice Cream (2 Scoops) $4.95
-
Brownie Sundae $12.00
A fudge brownie with three scoops of vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup, & whipped cream.
-
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae $13.00
Pound cake with three scoops of vanilla ice cream topped with strawberries & whipped cream.
-
Assorted Muffins $4.35
-
Cookies $4.35
-
Danish Pastries $4.35
-
Jello $3.60
-
Gelato Sundaes $7.15
Frosty Milk Shakes
-
Milkshake Classics $7.65
Chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry, and whipped cream.
-
Oreo Cookie $9.85
Oreo gelato, Oreo cookie crumbles, chocolate syrup, and whipped cream.
-
Going Bananas $9.85
Bananas, peanut butter gelato, & whipped cream with a drizzle of caramel sauce.
-
Mint Chocolate Chip $9.85
Chocolate chip mint Gelato, chocolate chips, and whipped cream.
-
Strawberries & Cream $9.85
Strawberry and vanilla ice cream, strawberry jam, and whipped cream. Topped with fresh strawberries.
-
Chocolate Brownie $9.85
Chocolate ice cream, chocolate syrup, brownie chunks, and whipped cream.
Cold Fountain Drinks
-
Soft Drinks $3.60
-
Water $3.25
-
Lipton Iced Tea $3.60
Raspberry or unsweetened.
-
Chocolate Milk $3.85
-
Fresh Brewed Iced Coffee $3.60
-
Seltzer $2.25
-
Milk $3.60
Coffee Shop
-
Cappuccino $5.75
-
Fresh Ground Coffee $3.25
-
Frappuccino $6.85
Vanilla ice cream blended with espresso. Topped with whipped cream & cinnamon.
-
Jamaican Coffee $9.35
Tia Maria, crème de cacao, coffee, & whipped cream.
-
Herbal Tea $3.35
Chamomile, lemon, orange, peppermint, or green tea.
-
Mexican Coffee $9.35
Kahlua, coffee, & whipped cream.
-
Cappuccino Delight $6.25
Hazelnut, vanilla, chocolate mint, or raspberry.
-
Espresso $4.50
-
Hot Lipton Tea $3.25
-
Double Espresso $5.50
-
Nutty Irishman Coffee $9.35
Irish cream, Frangelico, & coffee.
-
Hot Chocolate $3.85
With whipped cream.
Custom Chopped Salads
-
Custom Chopped Salads $11.25
Photos
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I consider myself a Diner’head because I prefer a diner over a restaurant any day. GC Diner Waiter/Waitress have a special kind of “let me get to know u while your here service, so that customers can keep coming back to Gotham City diner”.
Kid-friendliness:...