I’m so happy I decided to order a cake from Theresa for Mother’s Day instead of ordering from a chain! Theresa was very responsive and had clear, detailed communications. The cake was also exactly like the mock up she sent, and it was STUNNING! Every person who saw it was in awe. Her piping skills are incredible. Most importantly, the taste of the cake itself was out of this world - even my family members who usually don’t eat cake all had a slice. The buttercream was also perfect - not too sweet, but just sweet enough. I will definitely be ordering a cake from Theresa again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daphne Briana Ferrin
CiCi's Cakery LLC is a lovely bakery that makes handmade cakes with love. From unique birthday cakes to sweet cupcakes, everything here is delicious and of high quality. The cakes are exquisitely designed to suit any special occasion. The attentive, friendly service and fast turnaround times keep customers happy. If you need a special cake to make a statement, CiCi's Cakery LLC is the perfect choice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debra Patri
I had the best experience working with Theresa from CiCi's Cakery! I inquired about a month before my event and received a prompt response. We discussed ideas/inspiration and she was able to transform that into reality. She was great at communicating throughout the process (I had order changes/requests/questions the week leading up to the event) and she was able to make last minute changes and kept me updated. Pick-up was easy and painless, the cake/pops/cookies traveled well and were packaged so nicely. Guests raved about not only the beautiful look of everything, but the taste as well! Theresa was a huge part in making my baby shower celebration a success and I am so thankful I had the opportunity to work with her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marissa Zayas Lenz
We ordered a custom, Barbie cake for my daughter's 7th birthday from Cici's Cakery with less than a week's notice and she executed the most perfect cake!! The design was perfect, exactly as we asked for AND it tasted delicious! All of the girls commented on how good the cake was, which is a ringing endorsement from a bunch of 7 year old girls!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cakes
LINDSAY WALL
5 star performance! Great communication! Delicious and amazing custom cake pops that fit our theme! So good none were left!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie Sharp
My husband and I ordered our daughter’s first birthday cake from Cici’s Cakery and it was amazing!! Our guests couldn’t get over how great the cake taste and the cookies were also delicious. It was such a beautiful cake as well and so well done. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alison Stella
Elegant cupcakes and incredibly delicious..highly recommend..and Cici makes the process so easy with speed of service and response time
Kid-friendliness: Kids loved them as much as adults
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake
Robert Tung
Awesome, creative cakes and cupcakes. My family really enjoyed these. Whether you like all-time favorites or distinctive unique flavors and creations, CiCi’s Cakery does it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara G
The best cupcakes in town! ??? They are the most beautiful and also super delicious! Theresa was kind enough to fulfill my order within a short notice. My daughter and her classmates enjoyed the exquisite cupcakes on her 18th birthday in college on 4/28/2024?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kimberly Tuano
Ordered a custom cake from Cici’s on a very short notice and was glad she was actually available to do it although some color changes to the design had to be made.Communication was fast and easy and the pickup location was good as it wasnt too far from where I live. I was really looking forward to this “Welcome Home” cake to celebrate our baby coming home from the hospital and her cake did not disappoint!We had chocolate cake and vanilla buttercream and it was absolutely delicious! just how I wanted and expected a homemade and fresh chocolate cake to be made! moist, chocolately and just enjoyable to eat! I would love to just have a stock of it at home to snack on lol Pricing is reasonable and not to mention the design is very clean and beautiful! So glad for this positive experience and that we have another wonderful baker we can order from!
Found Cici's Cakery for a last minute 1st birthday custom cake. I sent a few inspo pics and the cake came out beautiful! Every single person at the party said it was the best tasting cake they’ve ever had. The cupcakes were delicious also. Safe to say I’m a Cici's Cakery Customer for life!
I ordered custom cupcakes from Cici's Cakery. They were amazing and gorgeous. Turned out to be exactly what I wanted. It was easy to work with the owner/baker. I sent her a photo and a description of what I needed and she understood right away. We communicated everything through email since I'm not a local. Super easy. Excellent customer service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cakes
Randi Leone
This was seriously the most beautiful cake I have ever seen. CiCi literally built a cake around a Barbie Doll for my daughter’s birthday. It was absolutely stunning!!!The cake tasted delicious! Everyone at the party couldn’t stop talking about my daughter’s cake.CiCi really takes her time to work with the customer and build the cake just as the customer envisions it.I cannot recommend CiCi’s Cakery enough!
Thank you so much! My wife loved the cupcakes! We will definitely be ordering more in the future!
Anna Haworth
Cici's Cakery makes the most beautiful and delicious cupcakes!! I ordered cupcakes for my daughters bridal shower and they were a big hit. They looked beautiful too! Theresa is so nice and accommodating. She made exactly what I wanted!!
I’m so happy I decided to order a cake from Theresa for Mother’s Day instead of ordering from a chain! Theresa was very responsive and had clear, detailed communications. The cake was also exactly like the mock up she sent, and it was STUNNING! Every person who saw it was in awe. Her piping skills are incredible. Most importantly, the taste of the cake itself was out of this world - even my family members who usually don’t eat cake all had a slice. The buttercream was also perfect - not too sweet, but just sweet enough. I will definitely be ordering a cake from Theresa again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CiCi's Cakery LLC is a lovely bakery that makes handmade cakes with love. From unique birthday cakes to sweet cupcakes, everything here is delicious and of high quality. The cakes are exquisitely designed to suit any special occasion. The attentive, friendly service and fast turnaround times keep customers happy. If you need a special cake to make a statement, CiCi's Cakery LLC is the perfect choice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had the best experience working with Theresa from CiCi's Cakery! I inquired about a month before my event and received a prompt response. We discussed ideas/inspiration and she was able to transform that into reality. She was great at communicating throughout the process (I had order changes/requests/questions the week leading up to the event) and she was able to make last minute changes and kept me updated. Pick-up was easy and painless, the cake/pops/cookies traveled well and were packaged so nicely. Guests raved about not only the beautiful look of everything, but the taste as well! Theresa was a huge part in making my baby shower celebration a success and I am so thankful I had the opportunity to work with her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered a custom, Barbie cake for my daughter's 7th birthday from Cici's Cakery with less than a week's notice and she executed the most perfect cake!! The design was perfect, exactly as we asked for AND it tasted delicious! All of the girls commented on how good the cake was, which is a ringing endorsement from a bunch of 7 year old girls!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cakes
5 star performance! Great communication! Delicious and amazing custom cake pops that fit our theme! So good none were left!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I ordered our daughter’s first birthday cake from Cici’s Cakery and it was amazing!! Our guests couldn’t get over how great the cake taste and the cookies were also delicious. It was such a beautiful cake as well and so well done. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elegant cupcakes and incredibly delicious..highly recommend..and Cici makes the process so easy with speed of service and response time
Kid-friendliness: Kids loved them as much as adults
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake
Awesome, creative cakes and cupcakes. My family really enjoyed these. Whether you like all-time favorites or distinctive unique flavors and creations, CiCi’s Cakery does it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best cupcakes in town! ??? They are the most beautiful and also super delicious! Theresa was kind enough to fulfill my order within a short notice. My daughter and her classmates enjoyed the exquisite cupcakes on her 18th birthday in college on 4/28/2024?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a custom cake from Cici’s on a very short notice and was glad she was actually available to do it although some color changes to the design had to be made.Communication was fast and easy and the pickup location was good as it wasnt too far from where I live. I was really looking forward to this “Welcome Home” cake to celebrate our baby coming home from the hospital and her cake did not disappoint!We had chocolate cake and vanilla buttercream and it was absolutely delicious! just how I wanted and expected a homemade and fresh chocolate cake to be made! moist, chocolately and just enjoyable to eat! I would love to just have a stock of it at home to snack on lol Pricing is reasonable and not to mention the design is very clean and beautiful! So glad for this positive experience and that we have another wonderful baker we can order from!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Found Cici's Cakery for a last minute 1st birthday custom cake. I sent a few inspo pics and the cake came out beautiful! Every single person at the party said it was the best tasting cake they’ve ever had. The cupcakes were delicious also. Safe to say I’m a Cici's Cakery Customer for life!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Custom Cakes, Cupcake
I ordered custom cupcakes from Cici's Cakery. They were amazing and gorgeous. Turned out to be exactly what I wanted. It was easy to work with the owner/baker. I sent her a photo and a description of what I needed and she understood right away. We communicated everything through email since I'm not a local. Super easy. Excellent customer service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cakes
This was seriously the most beautiful cake I have ever seen. CiCi literally built a cake around a Barbie Doll for my daughter’s birthday. It was absolutely stunning!!!The cake tasted delicious! Everyone at the party couldn’t stop talking about my daughter’s cake.CiCi really takes her time to work with the customer and build the cake just as the customer envisions it.I cannot recommend CiCi’s Cakery enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Custom Cakes, Cupcake
Thank you so much! My wife loved the cupcakes! We will definitely be ordering more in the future!
Cici's Cakery makes the most beautiful and delicious cupcakes!! I ordered cupcakes for my daughters bridal shower and they were a big hit. They looked beautiful too! Theresa is so nice and accommodating. She made exactly what I wanted!!
Loading...