Boniello's

$$ • Italian, American, Pizza

Hours:
72 Hamburg Turnpike, Riverdale
(973) 831-0222

Customers' Favorites

Boniello's Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4 (84)
Restaurantji Rating

Aside from making reservations for six and being crammed on a table for four and not being able to be moved to a bigger table.....dinner was good, portions always large, salads are really appealing with lots of extras like roasted peppers,.olives, artichoke, pepperoncini and great dressing choices. Flounder francese was tasty, large portion of fish and nice choice of sides. Veal picatta also very good. Eggplant rolatini was definitely a miss, eggplant tough, not appetizing and...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

Everything was average. Not the highest quality of ingredients or presentation. Perhaps a bit too pricey for the quality of food but they are generous with portion size. Staff were essentially high school students. You can honestly make a more flavorful and enjoyable Italian dish at home for substantially less.

Restaurantji Rating

This is my boyfriend’s families restaurant and they did not disappoint with my first time! We went with a group of friends who had a mix of pasta and the gluten free menu which was amazing. Can not wait to go back.Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free

More Reviews(325)

Ratings

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 11AM - 9PM
Wednesday 11AM - 9PM
Thursday 11AM - 9PM
Friday 11AM - 10PM
Saturday 11AM - 10PM
Sunday 3 - 9PM
Updated on: