Papa's Tomato Pies

Name: Papa's Tomato Pies
Address: 19 Main St, Robbinsville, New Jersey, 08691, US
Telephone: (609) 208-0006
Price range: $
Rating: 4.2

$ • Pizza, Italian, Pet Friendly

Hours:
19 Main St, Robbinsville
(609) 208-0006

Menu Order Online

About Papa's Tomato Pies

Papa's Tomato Pies, an established restaurant since 1912, is famous for its traditional Trenton style thin crust pies. Customers praise the well-cooked pizzas with delicious tomato sauce, which many consider the star of the show. The menu includes options like Margherita pizza, chicken Caesar salad, and basil pie. The restaurant has a friendly staff and a charming, 100-year-old atmosphere that many find inviting. It offers accessible seating, indoor and outdoor dining areas, and a pick-up window for takeout orders, making it suitable for family dinners or post-game meals.

Recent reviews highlight the exceptional quality of the tomato pie, with some calling it possibly the best pizza they've ever had. The sauce is described as savory, flavorful, and so good that one customer joked about wanting to bathe in it. The thin crust is crunchy, chewy, and baked perfectly without dryness or limpness. The cheese is 100% premium whole milk mozzarella, adding to the overall delicious experience. Customers note that the place feels old but charming, and the pies are really good, though some mention it just below De Lorenzo's. Service is friendly and attentive, and parking is plentiful since the restaurant is located inside a strip mall. Overall, Papa's Tomato Pies remains a well-loved spot for authentic, traditional pizza and a cozy atmosphere.