The Chicken Parm Stracciatella is Delicious!!! We had it with the Vodka Sauce. I will be coming back for the tomato sauce Chicken Parm Stracciatella very soon! If you’re a fan of chicken parm you’ve to have this one!
I placed my order online and came to pick it up. The front is a classic neighborhood pizza parlor. There was a few guys sitting out front who's stares made it know that outsiders aren't so welcome. I stepped inside the restaurant and that was a lot more welcoming. The dining area looks like grandma's living room in the 1980s. I loved the decor and the old school wooden phone booth with the payphone in it. I had the chicken parm stracceriatelli(fantastic!!!!!!) & I got the new haven pie with pepperoni which was great also. I ordered a side of grandma's meatballs, they were ok. 10 minutes or less from Meadowlands arena. Would definitely recommend and will go back soon!!!! Update Tried the chicken parm with tomato sauce and the one with vodka sauce, I liked the one with vodka sauce better. I do recommend you asking for a cup of vodka sauce to go so you can pour some on the chicken.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jess Hernandez
Not that it even needs to be said—the incredible food here speaks for itself. My husband and I are regulars, and the food is always top-tier—nothing compares. What truly stands out, though, is how much Dave and his team care about their customers. We had a small issue with a delivery driver, and Dave personally made it right by re-delivering our order and even including an extra meal at no charge. That’s someone who values not just great food, but exceptional service. Thank you, Dave and the entire Casano’s team.
Kalani Pornelos
Casano’s is more than just pizza. As soon as you pull up, you see your grandparents lawn chairs and dinner trays all over the sidewalk. When you open the door, you’re standing in Grandmas living room. This place feels like memories of times when things were simpler and people were happier. You can’t help but instantly be in a good mood. Then your food comes out and it’s some of the best pizza the state of NJ has to offer. Got the DrunkenTor which they’ve been perfecting since the Tavolino days. Paired with their chicken parm, you’re in heaven. Do yourself a favor and head over to Rutherford asap
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edgar Morales
Chicken Parm is very good. Big enough to it comes in a Pizza Box. The set up inside is pretty cool. Definitely support this establishment.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
chefchris21
3rd time going and I love this place. Last nights order, New Haven tomato pie- amazing Philly cheese steak- perfect in every way Vodka chicken parm- great cutlet Meatballs- very good They have the it factor, and Im a fan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lori Hetzel
I’m not personally a fan of this style of pizza but absolutely loved the cheesesteak sandwich, this might be the best cheesesteak I’ve ever eaten. The Caesar salad was great but massive so it’s best to order that for a crowd. I did enjoy the chicken parm stracciatella but agree with other reviews that it can lack seasoning. Overall the food is very good but pricey so this isn’t your everyday pizza spot.
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm Stracciatella, Cheesesteak Sandwich, Caesar Salad
Andrea Kayal
As a NJ-native, this was the best chicken parm and pizza I've had! The atmosphere was also retro (couches, fridges, phone booth and more). They had an old TV playing Donnie Brasco which fit the theme:)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm Stracciatella
Eric Oberman
It's basically a Nonna's apartment from 1973 with pizza ovens. The Pizza is top shelf! NO SLICES
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Theresa Hetzel
Had dinner here with my husband, son, and in laws & we all had delicious meals! The cheesesteak sandwich was phenomenal, so was the chicken Stracciatella! My son tried both plain pizzas and really enjoyed it. Love the aesthetic inside too. We look forward to the next time we order from here- our goal is to eat the whole menu and I’m sure we will love everything!
From the ambiance to the taste of food 10/10 like my friend said worth the toll from NY! What an amazing experience from walking inside and seeing the couches and jukeboxes to eating outside on the beach chairs! So dope 10/10 no slices but who comes here for slices 🗣️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ivy Carbone
This place is a cute little hidden gem. So yummy! Good pizza, the chicken vodka parm came out smaller for our order than we hoped especially since it comes with no pasta or anything. Like they're charging a full chicken pasta vodka meal and you don't get pasta so toh I would argue this isn't worth the money. But also to each their own!! If i could afford to spend $$$$$ just chicken and order my pasta separate I would!!. The service is slowwwww. There's always hella people waiting inside but luckily my mom placed our order a day in advance so it was ready lolol. I def will be coming back here. Also they only do pies no slices!! Bummer but respect.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Joe Reilly
Best chicken parm I ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
William Kilberg
Ordered the cheese pie, flavor and crust of the pizza was good. Not sure if it was an off night but so much cheese was added the pizza became a soup.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Zac VanAernum
Not a bad pizza spot. It seems that you have to order online as there is no phone number anywhere, kind of strange but no big deal. We ordered the Chicken Stracciatella with vodka sauce which I had high expectations for based on the buzz on social media. Overall it was decent but not the best I’ve ever had. The cheese was great, the vodka sauce was decent but not overly flavorful and the chicken although cooked really well, left something to be desired in the seasoning department. We also ordered the New Haven pie with half pepperoni. Again the pie was good but nothing that blew me away. Given the pretty expensive price, I would say everything was just decent but not spectacular.
The Chicken Parm Stracciatella is Delicious!!! We had it with the Vodka Sauce. I will be coming back for the tomato sauce Chicken Parm Stracciatella very soon! If you’re a fan of chicken parm you’ve to have this one!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Chicken Parmesan
I placed my order online and came to pick it up. The front is a classic neighborhood pizza parlor. There was a few guys sitting out front who's stares made it know that outsiders aren't so welcome. I stepped inside the restaurant and that was a lot more welcoming. The dining area looks like grandma's living room in the 1980s. I loved the decor and the old school wooden phone booth with the payphone in it. I had the chicken parm stracceriatelli(fantastic!!!!!!) & I got the new haven pie with pepperoni which was great also. I ordered a side of grandma's meatballs, they were ok. 10 minutes or less from Meadowlands arena. Would definitely recommend and will go back soon!!!!
Update
Tried the chicken parm with tomato sauce and the one with vodka sauce, I liked the one with vodka sauce better. I do recommend you asking for a cup of vodka sauce to go so you can pour some on the chicken.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not that it even needs to be said—the incredible food here speaks for itself. My husband and I are regulars, and the food is always top-tier—nothing compares. What truly stands out, though, is how much Dave and his team care about their customers. We had a small issue with a delivery driver, and Dave personally made it right by re-delivering our order and even including an extra meal at no charge. That’s someone who values not just great food, but exceptional service. Thank you, Dave and the entire Casano’s team.
Casano’s is more than just pizza. As soon as you pull up, you see your grandparents lawn chairs and dinner trays all over the sidewalk. When you open the door, you’re standing in Grandmas living room. This place feels like memories of times when things were simpler and people were happier. You can’t help but instantly be in a good mood. Then your food comes out and it’s some of the best pizza the state of NJ has to offer. Got the DrunkenTor which they’ve been perfecting since the Tavolino days. Paired with their chicken parm, you’re in heaven. Do yourself a favor and head over to Rutherford asap
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chicken Parm is very good. Big enough to it comes in a Pizza Box. The set up inside is pretty cool. Definitely support this establishment.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
3rd time going and I love this place. Last nights order,
New Haven tomato pie- amazing
Philly cheese steak- perfect in every way
Vodka chicken parm- great cutlet
Meatballs- very good
They have the it factor, and Im a fan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’m not personally a fan of this style of pizza but absolutely loved the cheesesteak sandwich, this might be the best cheesesteak I’ve ever eaten. The Caesar salad was great but massive so it’s best to order that for a crowd. I did enjoy the chicken parm stracciatella but agree with other reviews that it can lack seasoning. Overall the food is very good but pricey so this isn’t your everyday pizza spot.
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm Stracciatella, Cheesesteak Sandwich, Caesar Salad
As a NJ-native, this was the best chicken parm and pizza I've had! The atmosphere was also retro (couches, fridges, phone booth and more). They had an old TV playing Donnie Brasco which fit the theme:)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm Stracciatella
It's basically a Nonna's apartment from 1973 with pizza ovens.
The Pizza is top shelf!
NO SLICES
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Had dinner here with my husband, son, and in laws & we all had delicious meals! The cheesesteak sandwich was phenomenal, so was the chicken Stracciatella! My son tried both plain pizzas and really enjoyed it. Love the aesthetic inside too. We look forward to the next time we order from here- our goal is to eat the whole menu and I’m sure we will love everything!
Restaurantji Recommends
From the ambiance to the taste of food 10/10 like my friend said worth the toll from NY! What an amazing experience from walking inside and seeing the couches and jukeboxes to eating outside on the beach chairs! So dope 10/10 no slices but who comes here for slices 🗣️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is a cute little hidden gem. So yummy!
Good pizza, the chicken vodka parm came out smaller for our order than we hoped especially since it comes with no pasta or anything. Like they're charging a full chicken pasta vodka meal and you don't get pasta so toh I would argue this isn't worth the money. But also to each their own!! If i could afford to spend $$$$$ just chicken and order my pasta separate I would!!. The service is slowwwww. There's always hella people waiting inside but luckily my mom placed our order a day in advance so it was ready lolol. I def will be coming back here.
Also they only do pies no slices!! Bummer but respect.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Best chicken parm I ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Ordered the cheese pie, flavor and crust of the pizza was good. Not sure if it was an off night but so much cheese was added the pizza became a soup.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Not a bad pizza spot. It seems that you have to order online as there is no phone number anywhere, kind of strange but no big deal. We ordered the Chicken Stracciatella with vodka sauce which I had high expectations for based on the buzz on social media. Overall it was decent but not the best I’ve ever had. The cheese was great, the vodka sauce was decent but not overly flavorful and the chicken although cooked really well, left something to be desired in the seasoning department. We also ordered the New Haven pie with half pepperoni. Again the pie was good but nothing that blew me away. Given the pretty expensive price, I would say everything was just decent but not spectacular.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...