Da Mario Pizzeria

25 Park Ave, Rutherford
(201) 935-5817

Recent Reviews

Melissa Egusquiza (Melly)

Food is amazing, I’ve never had a bad dish here. Super affordable, and friendly people behind the counter. Love this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gabriela Mayorga

Amazing food. Love the pizza and minestrone, it tastes like homemade. Very affordable prices!

cmoi

Good little restaurant in New Jersey, affordable and very good service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Steve C.

First trying this local restaurant-ahhhh man! BOMB! Sausage and peppers, spaghetti and had them throw in meatballs. I'm hooked! Very flavorful and I've been trying different spots in the area. Then I get a phone call asking if I wanted to have a layer of cheese just to set it off even more-who does this? Love it. Thank you!

Tyler

Great local family friendly pizza place. Old-school. I have been going here forever and frequently visited back when I was in high school. The owners and staff are so friendly. Food is great. Affordable pricing and quality food. Definitely my go to spot in the area for some quick pizza and meals.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Summer M.

I was visiting from out of town so I am bummed I cannot go back, but it was absolutely delicious. I ordered the Philly wrap. Good portion sizes.

Magda G.

Just went to Da Mario's to pick up a pizza pie with onions. It was thin crust pizza, no frills and the price was great. A nice hot pie was pulled out of the oven just as I got there to pick up my pizza. Perfect timing. Good service.

Clarke Smith

Always an easy going place to pick up a few slices, a pie or pasta with chicken and veggies. The staff is super friendly and helpful. They get busy sometimes but always seems to have a seat available.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Nick C

This place is so good I had to take the time to leave a review. Great tasting pizza and affordable pricing. This place is a gem.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

B Mrkulic

Calamari was so dry and the wings were extremely salty.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

moon bars

Good food. Good prices. Good portions.I’ve ordered from here a few times before. It’s always been good, but it’s just little bit out of the way. From now on I will be taking the extra time to make the trip to Dimarios. Thank you for the food.

Joey

Never had a bad experience here. Food is ALWAYS GREAT and prices are more than reasonable. My only gripe is that I don't come here as often as I'd like too lol. As busy as they get here the staff is ALWAYS professional, politely and courteous. I love this place?

Mike R.

Solid place for pizza. Prices are good and the women is so sweet ! They just need to update the menu and tell people they deliver

Kat C.

Ordered the Mario's special on toasted bread and I'm really impressed with this sandwich. Very fresh, perfect balance of oil and vinegar and plenty of cold cuts. Definitely recommend.

Frank K

Not a very good place. I ordered a regular pie tonight. The guy on the phone who is the pizza maker said 20 minutes. I got there 25 minutes later. They made me wait another 20 minutes. I got a parking ticket waiting for these rocket scientists to make a regular cheese. They have no parking. Don't waste your time.

Load More