Carrie’s cakes are the best: moist, light, and flavorful. I ordered cakes from her for my daughter’s last 2 birthdays, and am about to order for the 3rd year in a row!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sameer Palande
Working with Carrie was such a piece of cake. We discussed details of a birthday cake over email and she was very attentive and responsive. Finally she made a cake that didn't just look pretty as per our asks but also tasted amazingly good!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alejandra Castellanos
Carrie is such a wonderful baker and person! I’ve had the pleasure to work with her for a few cakes now and they are always so delicious and beautiful. This past weekend we celebrated my nephews baptism and she made a strawberry filling cake and wow ! Everyone loved it. We were all so happy . Thank you again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Calvin Loke
The cupcakes are so so good. Good variety - all of them fantastic, moist with a very balanced icing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maria Benevento
Guys, I’m not even joking, I would have eaten this cake off the ground it was so good. I’ve never had a cake so good in my entire 40 years! And Carrie 🥹 she goes above and beyond for you. Her attention to detail and her artistry is unmatched. WORTH EVERY PENNY. I won’t order a cake from anyone else ever again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin Miu
GoodieBox Bakeshop made a special Knicks-themed cake for my son’s 5th birthday at the American Dream Mall Waterpark. The ordering process was simple and efficient — a quick call with the owner, Carrie, and she immediately understood what we wanted. She coordinated directly with the American Dream team on logistics, delivery, and presentation time, making the entire process seamless and stress-free.
When the cake was unboxed, the kids were buzzing with excitement. The cake itself was excellent — beautifully designed, very fairly priced, and enjoyed by all. It proved so popular that my wife and I didn’t even get a slice, and we received many compliments on the flavor. Even our son, who usually only eats the frosting, finished his entire piece.
We look forward to ordering from GoodieBox Bakeshop again for future celebrations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
kinjal patel
I had ordered smash cake for my daughter’s birthday. I really loved how the cake was. Carrie was amazing and accommodated all my requests. They go above and beyond to help their clients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbie V
I truly can’t say enough amazing things about Carrie at GoodieBox Bake Shop. She is a powerhouse of a woman and hands down one of my all-time favorite bakers. I’ve been a fan since the early days back in Hudson County/Weehawken—hooked ever since her Valentine’s Day box (we’re talking way back, maybe 2012… but don’t quote me!).
Her cakes and baked goods aren’t just beautiful to look at—they taste just as incredible. Whether it’s a specialty birthday cake for one of my parties or just a little treat to brighten my day, Carrie always delivers something special. She puts love into everything she bakes, and it shows.
I’ve watched her grow over the years and I couldn’t be more proud. Her success is so well deserved, and if you haven’t tried her goodies yet—seriously, what are you waiting for?
Even though I don’t live in the area anymore, I miss the bakery dearly… and I miss her. Carrie has that rare magic—she makes you feel like family from the moment you walk in. 💛
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vincent Wu
It was amazing working with Carrie. She was quick to respond to emails, and really followed through on the design of the cake. The lemon raspberry tasted wonderful, not super sweet, and just the right amount of tart. Would absolutely work with them again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anna Eggers
I love stopping in here for whatever treats they’ve baked up for walk-in customers. They have a great array of cake slices, cupcakes, cookies, etc. alongside their full size cakes you can order online. There’s always something new to try, and its always scrumptious!
This is a wonderful little shop with a super friendly staff and delicious confections. It's definitely worth checking out.
Barbara White
My family’s favorite bakeshop. Not only for their amazing cupcakes, brookies and GF cheesecakes. But also for their amazing custom cakes. I’ve ordered two cakes and will be ordering another soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chantip Wikler
Needed cake for a very important launch. Although we made many changes to delivery dates, we were greeted with great flexibility. The strawberry champagne/chocolate 2 layer cake was delicious. Moist, not heavy cake. Icing was buttery and light, and not waxy in texture at all. A great experience all around. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lori Hetzel
Goodiebox is the best in Rutherford, no question! I’ve had cupcakes, cake slices, a birthday cake, and most recently my baby shower cake from them and the quality is outstanding. My favorite flavor is the chocolate raspberry, which is a bakery staple and has its own distinctive design, but they were able to make the cake to match my shower theme. The cake was absolutely beautiful and so DELICIOUS! I’m so grateful to have such an amazing bakery in town and will be purchasing our cakes from Goodiebox for every celebration!
Carrie’s cakes are the best: moist, light, and flavorful. I ordered cakes from her for my daughter’s last 2 birthdays, and am about to order for the 3rd year in a row!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Working with Carrie was such a piece of cake. We discussed details of a birthday cake over email and she was very attentive and responsive. Finally she made a cake that didn't just look pretty as per our asks but also tasted amazingly good!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carrie is such a wonderful baker and person! I’ve had the pleasure to work with her for a few cakes now and they are always so delicious and beautiful. This past weekend we celebrated my nephews baptism and she made a strawberry filling cake and wow ! Everyone loved it. We were all so happy . Thank you again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cupcakes are so so good. Good variety - all of them fantastic, moist with a very balanced icing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Guys, I’m not even joking, I would have eaten this cake off the ground it was so good. I’ve never had a cake so good in my entire 40 years!
And Carrie 🥹 she goes above and beyond for you. Her attention to detail and her artistry is unmatched. WORTH EVERY PENNY. I won’t order a cake from anyone else ever again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
GoodieBox Bakeshop made a special Knicks-themed cake for my son’s 5th birthday at the American Dream Mall Waterpark. The ordering process was simple and efficient — a quick call with the owner, Carrie, and she immediately understood what we wanted. She coordinated directly with the American Dream team on logistics, delivery, and presentation time, making the entire process seamless and stress-free.
When the cake was unboxed, the kids were buzzing with excitement. The cake itself was excellent — beautifully designed, very fairly priced, and enjoyed by all. It proved so popular that my wife and I didn’t even get a slice, and we received many compliments on the flavor. Even our son, who usually only eats the frosting, finished his entire piece.
We look forward to ordering from GoodieBox Bakeshop again for future celebrations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had ordered smash cake for my daughter’s birthday. I really loved how the cake was. Carrie was amazing and accommodated all my requests. They go above and beyond to help their clients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I truly can’t say enough amazing things about Carrie at GoodieBox Bake Shop. She is a powerhouse of a woman and hands down one of my all-time favorite bakers. I’ve been a fan since the early days back in Hudson County/Weehawken—hooked ever since her Valentine’s Day box (we’re talking way back, maybe 2012… but don’t quote me!).
Her cakes and baked goods aren’t just beautiful to look at—they taste just as incredible. Whether it’s a specialty birthday cake for one of my parties or just a little treat to brighten my day, Carrie always delivers something special. She puts love into everything she bakes, and it shows.
I’ve watched her grow over the years and I couldn’t be more proud. Her success is so well deserved, and if you haven’t tried her goodies yet—seriously, what are you waiting for?
Even though I don’t live in the area anymore, I miss the bakery dearly… and I miss her. Carrie has that rare magic—she makes you feel like family from the moment you walk in. 💛
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was amazing working with Carrie. She was quick to respond to emails, and really followed through on the design of the cake. The lemon raspberry tasted wonderful, not super sweet, and just the right amount of tart. Would absolutely work with them again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love stopping in here for whatever treats they’ve baked up for walk-in customers. They have a great array of cake slices, cupcakes, cookies, etc. alongside their full size cakes you can order online. There’s always something new to try, and its always scrumptious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a wonderful little shop with a super friendly staff and delicious confections. It's definitely worth checking out.
My family’s favorite bakeshop. Not only for their amazing cupcakes, brookies and GF cheesecakes. But also for their amazing custom cakes. I’ve ordered two cakes and will be ordering another soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Needed cake for a very important launch. Although we made many changes to delivery dates, we were greeted with great flexibility. The strawberry champagne/chocolate 2 layer cake was delicious. Moist, not heavy cake. Icing was buttery and light, and not waxy in texture at all. A great experience all around. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Goodiebox is the best in Rutherford, no question! I’ve had cupcakes, cake slices, a birthday cake, and most recently my baby shower cake from them and the quality is outstanding. My favorite flavor is the chocolate raspberry, which is a bakery staple and has its own distinctive design, but they were able to make the cake to match my shower theme. The cake was absolutely beautiful and so DELICIOUS! I’m so grateful to have such an amazing bakery in town and will be purchasing our cakes from Goodiebox for every celebration!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
everything at this place is insanely good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...