GoodieBox Bakeshop
2 Franklin Pl, Rutherford
(201) 256-3016
Customers' Favorites
Old Fashioned Birthday Cupcake Vanilla Butter Cake with Chocolate Buttercream
Strawberry Cakesicle
Decorated Cookie
Goodie Box
Smores Bar
Red Velvet
Cupcakes
Menu
Photos
+3 photos
+2 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Working with Carrie was such a piece of cake. We discussed details of a birthday cake over email and she was very attentive and responsive. Finally she made a cake that didn't just look pretty as per our asks but also tasted amazingly good!
Carrie is such a wonderful baker and person! I’ve had the pleasure to work with her for a few cakes now and they are always so delicious and beautiful. This past weekend we celebrated my nephews baptism and she made a strawberry filling cake and wow ! Everyone loved it. We were all so happy . Thank you again
Guys, I’m not even joking, I would have eaten this cake off the ground it was so good. I’ve never had a cake so good in my entire 40 years!
And Carrie 🥹 she goes above and beyond for you. Her attention to detail and her artistry is unmatched. WORTH EVERY PENNY. I won’t order a cake from anyone else ever again.
And Carrie 🥹 she goes above and beyond for you. Her attention to detail and her artistry is unmatched. WORTH EVERY PENNY. I won’t order a cake from anyone else ever again.
You May Also Like
Rutherford Coffee Co. - 70 Park Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Bakery, Colombian
Paisano's - 132 Park Ave
![]()
Italian, Vegan, Vegetarian
Steven's Cafe - 106 Park Ave
![]()
Cafe, Italian, Bakery, Coffee Shops