Ice Cream Charlie's

200 Park Ave, Rutherford
(201) 939-8133

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Manon

I ordered a cake for a Halloween party / birthday two days before.
They did a fantastic job ! Not only the cake was tastefully decorated (the kids love all the little Halloween candies on top) but it was also delicious !

Laura Pashkowsky

Best ice cream!!!

Nelson Cordero

Excellent ice cream

Vahe Bakalian

Went here my son, service was quick. Good pricing.

A K

Ice cream is really good! Downsize is only cash. It is our favorite ice cream store in town.

Pamela Marino

Myself and my family have been coming here for over 25 years. We really never get ice cream any where else. It’s the best homemade ice cream around. And yes service is great, very nice and friendly. We just love it. It’s worth the 15 min ride. I’d even drive longer if I had to: 10 stars ⭐️ from us

Amanda Rozek

We were a party of 6, there was nobody else in the shop and there were two servers. While I understand usually one server helps a single group, the girl who was not helping us was sitting on her phone and didn't even acknowledge us when we asked her for water while our server was busy with the rest of our family.

Eric Oberman

My favorite local ice cream

Bud Cannaveno

Not much ambiance and limited seating, but the ice cream was delicious

David Lafarga

Housemade ice cream. Great and interesting flavors. Employs local kids. What more can you ask for?

Phil Latronico

Delicious

Jeff T. Critic

The chocolate soft serve ice cream was smooth, rich and creamy. It was very fulfilling, even for a kiddie size. You may have your ice cream in a cup, sugar cone, or wafer cone.

Be sure to have cash on hand because they do not accept credit cards, debit cards, Apple Pay or any other electronic form of payment.

prasad vallurupalli

A delicious and affordable home made Ice cream

Brendan Black

Your average ice cream parlor. Nothing special about it but nothing they really did wrong. The hard ice cream is homemade but doesn’t really taste that special or great, just like standard ice cream. It was a little pricey and nothing inside is really too pleasant about the place. Servers were nice and polite and they also offer the popular Dubai chocolates.

Sam Anderson

Delicious ice cream. I had a cup of chocolate peanut butter. Nice & cool inside!

Loading...