Sweet Avenue Bake Shop

153 Park Ave, Rutherford
(201) 935-2253

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Denise Vasquez

Honestly, this place is great. I've been ordering cakes consistently for both of my daughter's birthday's for the past few years. There have been times when I have given them just a general idea for a theme and the product I've received has always blown me away- it's always way more than I could have ever imagined. I've placed yet another order for my daughter's birthday cake and I can't wait to see their vision come to life! They are always quick to respond to any inquiries and I love that they can accommodate my children's dietary restrictions. Amazing place, highly highly reccommend.

Roseann

The place is small but the dessert is big with flavor. I bought six cupcakes. The non-vegans were delighted with them. I went close to closing time on a Friday and it was not packed. I’ll be back!

Lisa Gorman

They are so delicious. The gluten free cake pops are amazing! The owners and workers are very nice and helpful. .

Ilay Ayhan Turkmen

Amazing cupcakes! The gluten-free, vegan options are amazing. The lavender 💜 cupcake is my favorite.

C Nehme

I placed a custom order for a baby shower. They were quick to respond, easy to work with, and very professional. The cupcakes were beautiful and great tasting, I continue to get compliments about them.

Lindsay Ryder

I ordered a 6 inch cake for my son's first birthday - he has a dairy/soy allergy so I was really happy to find a place that offered options. But also the cake was DELICIOUS. I don't know how you make a cake without dairy to taste that good and it wasn't dry or anything. 10/10 amazing

Jayne

Cute Bakery with Gluten-free and Vegan desserts. The cookie sandwiches and donuts are to die for! I haven't had ones this good since going GF two years ago. 10/10 for this adorable bakery!!!

Dietary restrictions: Wonderful Gluten-free and Vegan options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gluten Free Vegan Donuts

Jacky Rodriguez (Esmeralda Merejo)

How to start WOW I had this cake for breakfast lunch and dinner the most delicious cake ,cupcakes , and truffles I wouldn’t of found out about them through my grandson allergy to milk and my son in law gluten free but I am soo thankful I did the only bad thing it’s far from where I live but then it’s for my good because I would be in that bakery literally everyday that’s how much I Love their bake goods especially their cakes they are amazing and oh my the butter cream I can eat that alone just delicious 😋 . My daughters birthday was coming up so I order a vintage cake I gave them a picture of what I wanted it to look like my gosh they did it exactly and it was just Beautiful everyone was in aww it was so Lovely too pretty to cut but we did it was just delicious like always Thank you ladies for the awesome job you guys do not only do you guys make delicious outstanding bake goods but also the art of decorating them too.

Cherie Hans

As a vegan since 2007, I love this bakery! Their baked products are delicious. The presentation is beautiful. The owners and staff are fantastic. I cannot say enough wonderful things about their shop.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Veronika Eulo

We've ordered my daughter's birthday cake twice from Sweet Avenue Bake Shop. We spend Christmas at my father in law's house every other year, and my daughter's bday is Christmas Eve. I found them on Instagram several years ago, and ordered a Corpse Bride cake that blew our whole family away, instantly making Sweet Ave a tradition for us. Two years ago, they did my daughter's Wednesday Addams cake impressed us once again. My daughter is already brainstorming this year's cake and excited to see what Sweet Shop can do again.
Excellent decorating skills.
Delicious cakes from a full family of non vegans who couldn't tell the difference.
Easy peasy online ordering process and fantastic communication.
No matter the time of year, if we're in NJ and one of our family members has a birthday, this is our go to bakery. Be sure to give at least two weeks notice before the date you need your cake.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mariela Santana

Best cupcakes!!! I had the strawberry shortcake and the vanilla cupcakes and they were delicious. I definitely will be going back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vegan Cupcakes

Grace Proetta

I cannot say enough about this place! Not only are their cakes allergy friendly for my children, but they are delicious and absolutely beautiful at that. Photo included is their most recent design for our little boo is turning 2 birthday party --- they totally nailed it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zuhdi Abdo

All vegan bakery with vegan + gluten free options. Friendly staff and the cakes are so good you wouldn’t know they were vegan!

Vegetarian options: All vegan

Dietary restrictions: Vegan and vegan + gluten free

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cake Balls, Carrot Cake

Kara Bachman

Sweet Ave Bake Shop is a hidden gem for anyone searching for the perfect cake! I recently ordered a custom 10" confetti cake for my birthday, and it was absolutely incredible. The flavor and presentation was perfect. My guests couldn't stop raving about it and asked me where I ordered it from. If you're looking for a bakery that truly cares about creating a unique and delicious cake, Sweet Ave Bake Shop is the place to go!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adrienne Valentine

Absolutely love this place! I order cupcakes for a bridal shower the next day (plus extra treats for myself) and it was all absolutely delicious!
I can't believe I just found this place. Will definitely come here for cupcakes again. Also, they are so nice there. Definitely go here for great tasting free-from cupcakes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...