Amazing tasting items often, especially the jelly cookies. Normally dont love jelly cookies but these were great!Only downside is they only accept cash, which is borderline not acceptable by todays standards. Had to leave to withdraw money from atm.Otherwise though, very friendly staff as well, and very experienced it seems
I went to this bakery a few times several years ago. The brownies were dry and hard. The rainbow cookies were awful.A few other items I got were meh.Go to Dad's Royal Bakery , or Shoprite bakery instead in Parlin NJ.
Carolyn Santos Otersen
Thanks for making the cake just as we asked . It was the perfect Outer Banks themed cake!
Amy Miller
The birthday cake that I ordered was amazing! It was cookies and cream in addition to vanilla pudding filling, with a buttercream frosting. The theme was a Yankees baseball field - it was a big hit!This is an exceptional bakery.
Sara Vincent
Krystal’s is our family favorite bakery, especially for the Rum Cakes! After moving to Tennessee, we make sure we get a cake every chance we can! After 900 miles of travel this cake is still as delicious as eating one fresh! Thank you for always making such a delicious cake!
Vincent Conti
Great service, very sweet. Gave me a discount because I was buying for the local PD. Very kind.
Awesome bakery. Friendly staff. Reminds me of bakeries of past. What they do they do well. Kudos!!!!!
Delicious baked holiday cookies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
I have loved this bakery for many years. I moved to upstate NY 10 yrs ago, and whenever I'm in the area, I make sure I make a stop at Krystal Bakery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Mousse, Cookies, Birthday Cake, Cupcake
Amazing tasting items often, especially the jelly cookies. Normally dont love jelly cookies but these were great!Only downside is they only accept cash, which is borderline not acceptable by todays standards. Had to leave to withdraw money from atm.Otherwise though, very friendly staff as well, and very experienced it seems
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Birthday Cake, Cupcake
Have bought several cakes and cookies from them and everything is always fresh and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A great assortment of cookies! I bought a plate of chosen cookies as a gift and they were beautifully wrapped!
Delicious! Fresh Italian cookies that are outstanding! Best Connoli I've tasted in NJ. Very caring and helpful owners. Highly recommend!
Sooooo glad I stumbled upon this gem. Everything in here is fresh and delicious and at a great price point.Support a small family business.
Excellent pastries but their cake is amazing!!
We love this place...best cookies, donuts and cannolis around. I've lived in Sayreville 19 yrs now & I hope they never close down
Restaurantji Recommends
I went to this bakery a few times several years ago. The brownies were dry and hard. The rainbow cookies were awful.A few other items I got were meh.Go to Dad's Royal Bakery , or Shoprite bakery instead in Parlin NJ.
Thanks for making the cake just as we asked . It was the perfect Outer Banks themed cake!
The birthday cake that I ordered was amazing! It was cookies and cream in addition to vanilla pudding filling, with a buttercream frosting. The theme was a Yankees baseball field - it was a big hit!This is an exceptional bakery.
Krystal’s is our family favorite bakery, especially for the Rum Cakes! After moving to Tennessee, we make sure we get a cake every chance we can! After 900 miles of travel this cake is still as delicious as eating one fresh! Thank you for always making such a delicious cake!
Great service, very sweet. Gave me a discount because I was buying for the local PD. Very kind.