Scarborough Fair Restaurant

Food was good, but the overall experience fell short of the price point. The outdoor landscaping and food presentation both need improvement. Service was also disappointing; the server auctioned off dishes at delivery instead of tracking who ordered what, which felt highly unprofessional for a table of our size. Told the waitress we wanted to split the large salad but they brought it out in a large bowl but no plates. Better restaurants split in kitchen. Furthermore, the restaurant knew we were celebrating a wedding anniversary but simply dropped off dessert without a word. While minor, these are the touches you expect at this price level. Lastly, the indoor acoustics are very loud.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Osbuco was cold.I guess it was cooked refrigerated and reheated. Sent it back ordered filet mignon it was a little tough. Disappointed .

Wonderful place for a great dinner!!

My wife and I have dined at SF since it opened. We dined there yesterday, and had the pleasure of background music provided by a fine guitarist. In addition, for the first time in memory in a restaurant, we did not have our senses blasted by deafening and distorting amplification or pounding tympani. Instead of punishing us into submission, the music actually enhanced our dining experience. Why restaurants play insanely loud music at dining time is beyond me. But Scarborough Fair got it right.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Lovely place, good service, food preparation and flavor could use improvement. Expensive lunvh for what we got. Will probably not go back.

Food and service were top notch. Overall memorable experience. Loved the decor and atmosphere.

Great hidden gem.
Have been going here for years.
They keep getting better.
Atmosphere ,food ,service always very good.
Always consistent

Highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered the lamb chops and asked our waitress if there was mint jelly. It's the only way I like my lamb chops. She assured me there was. Well, when they brought out the food she told me there wasn't any jelly. I was disappointed. I definitely would have ordered something else. A man came over, I assume he was the manager. He asked how everything was going. I explained my disappointment. He told me he would get some jelly. He never came back to the table. My husband wasn't happy with his salmon and only ate very little.

A phenomenal restaurant in every way. A must do

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely amazing three course meal for Mother’s Day. Definitely with the higher price for quality food and great drinks!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This was our first time back to Scarborough Fair in a few years. Food, service and ambience was excellent! Our server, Gabby, highly recommended the fried calamari which was lightly coated in chick pea flour. It was the best we've had in the area in sometime. So tender and light! The scallops with mushroom and parmesan risotto served with crispy glazed brussels sprouts was a winner and well as the halibut with lump crab risotto. We were pleasantly surprised that the noise level in their dining room with a full seating was suitable for conversation with another couple joining us. Unlike many restaurants in the area. Overall a great experience and looking forward to our next dining experience there.

Beautiful setting, delicious and creative food, attentive and friendly staff- couldn't ask for more! Scallops were delicious, and I appreciated the willingness to switch out a side on the special. I enjoyed every bite of the meal, loved the martinis, and desserts were incredible (including candles for our birthday celebration). Looking forward to going back this summer to enjoy fire pits, live music and martini bar in the outdoor area. It's so nice to have a local restaurant that hits every note!

Scarborough Fair Restaurant is a great spot with consistently delicious food and a really welcoming atmosphere. Everything tasted fresh and well made, and the service was friendly throughout the entire experience.

It’s the kind of place that feels comfortable whether you’re going for a casual dinner or a special night out. Definitely a restaurant I’d recommend checking out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Quite an expensive. Food was good but not sure a cup of soup, eggs and avocado toast and a slice of cake was worth 65 for brunch. And all the eggs were overcooked or broken and the cook blamed the waitress! lol

Went to Scarborough with friend for Psychic Night and it was packed! We had such a great time. The clams were delicious, and we HAVE to give a shout out to the bartenders. They handled a huge crowd like pros, while still making really creative martinis. The service was truly fantastic, but also incredibly impressive. Give Scott and Haley the raises they deserve! We will definitely be back for another psychic night and the cool vibe.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5