Anthony's Sea Isle City

Went in underdressed, sat at the bar for a few drinks.

I was treated no differently than everyone else there, and the tequila sunrise was incredible.

I highly recommend this spot to anyone who visits Sea Isle. I can’t say enough good things about it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time and likely the last time. We had a reservation on a Friday night and were sat promptly in the far back room. Seating is tight and the noise level was off the charts. It made it impossible to converse with table mates. I ordered the meatballs with gnocchi and asked for capellini instead and I am not exaggerating, they served 2 meatballs and no less than 2 lbs of pasta with a very bland sauce, aka gravy, in a large bowl. It was ridiculous! Really, only 2 meatballs with all that pasta?? My friends had the veal Oscar, veal Parmesan and eggplant Parmesan which they all said were good.
The waitress was friendly and attentive but the servers were always at the table looking to clear plates while folks were still eating. Pet peeve…Felt like we were being a bit rushed.

Overall, for what we spent, there are other options where we can go enjoy a more relaxed and comfortable meal and also be able to have an enjoyable conversation.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 4

Just treated my wife for her birthday there and we really LOVED their food there! Want to give you shout out to our waiter, Billy who was great! The vibe, atmosphere, staff, the food, etc. For those who want to celebrate and are around South Jersey shore area, this is the place to be. Highly recommend this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Truly has the best food and the best atmosphere in the Jersey Shore

Putting this first as a PSA: Don’t bother if you have any type of dietary restriction or food allergy. When we had made the reservation, we were assured there would be an option for one of the members of our group; unfortunately that wasn’t the case, and they failed to accommodate.

As for the food… Considering they advertise as a nicer Italian restaurant I was disappointed. The food was just okay and honestly on par with store bought.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Good food a a bunch local beers available. Bartenders are hustlers, always quick and attentive service despite being slammed with people. Be careful the espresso martinis will get you hooked for life!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The one hostess is the best. She needs a raise. Great chicken Stephen

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Miss my favorite
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Best clams casino, basked clams and bruschetta ever

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Have been going here for years and never had an experience like I did on Monday night. We sat down in the ballroom section of the restaurant because we were a party of 12. The waitress was very attentive throughout the night. Once they took our food order, then things went south. Our appetizers came out 1-2 at a time, so family members were done with theirs before others got theirs. It was the same thing with entrees, but WORSE! Not all the food came out at the same time , and my cousin didn’t get her meal! They said 2-3 times that it was on its way, and it never came. On top of that, no one at the table got theirs sides that came with the entree. Was brought to their attention , and nothing happened. Was told by our waitress that the manager would personally bring out my cousins meal, and he never showed his up. Finally we got the last meal; but asked for it to go because the other 11 people were done with their food. The entree that never came was gnocchi with meatballs! Why was that taking so long. Our entrees were fantastic, tasted great, but didn’t get our sides. The poor waitress was overworked/overwhelmed, and didn’t get the support from her manager OR the kitchen staff. It’s really a shame, because we have never had an experience like this. Our bill was over $600 and no one got their entire meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 2

The service was top-notch, but what really stood out was the incredible hospitality from the manager, Connor. He went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect—from checking in on our table personally to handling a minor request with professionalism and a genuine smile. You can tell he takes real pride in what he does and cares about the guest experience. The food was great, but the service made the night. Thanks, Connor—we’ll definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time here since it switched over from the previous tenant. We sat at the bar. Food was great, bar tender (Lauren I think?) was super friendly and always available. No complaints at all! Will definitely be back and recommend to others! We came on a slow night but I can see how reservations are recommended. And the bar filled up quickly after 6:30 so plan ahead!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Got seated immediately as a party of 6 with no reservation. Our server , maybe her name was Layla, was wonderful. She was personable, knowledgeable about the menu and so kind to our kids. We loved the beet salad, egg plant appetizer, crab risotto special, veal parm, crab cake and all of our items. Nice selection of wines and a full bar too.
Very pleased with our first visit here.

We had an unfortunate dinner at Anthony‘s tonight. My lemon drop martini came out with a salted rim instead of sugar rim two times before the bartender got it right. Additionally, three of our pasta dishes were incorrect in that they put meat in the vodka sauce, despite a lengthy conversation and assurances that there would not be meat in our meal. Will not return.

Incredibly mid, not worth the price. Food was bland and drowned in sauce and the drinks were sub-par. Do yourself a favor and grab a bottle of wine and go across the street to Sole

We just had dinner during Memorial Day weekend. The kitchen staff was not prepared for the crowd. We ordered the eggplant parmesan and unfortunately the sauce was tasteless. We had to add a lot of salt and pepper, it tasted like mass produced, canned sauce. We grew up in Hamilton so we have had Perfirios sauce and this didn't taste like it. Wait staff was wonderful but I see no reason to go back if food is mediocre.