It was our first time at The Arlington recently, and we had a bad experience overall. Everything on the menu was extremely expensive for what you get. It was small portions, drink options were limited with not much variety, and the service was poor. The food tasted okay but nothing special. The biggest thing was the price… the bill absolutely shocked us when we received it. We thought during the off season maybe they would’ve lowered the prices for the locals, but that was not the case here. We wanted to try a new place on the island that we haven’t tried before, but we will not be going back unfortunately as there are much better options in the area on and off the island.
Julia Silva
Definitely overpriced! Food was just ok - cocktails were served in a mini cocktail glass. Most likely not returning.
Tessa Piantadosi
Food and cocktails were extremely subpar for the price. I ordered my son ice cream dessert, and I did not double check the price which I admit was my fault.. a bowl of vanilla ice cream was $13. Cocktails were very subpar. Waitress was rude. They also sat a large party at the table right behind us when the whole dining room was open. Will not be recommending or returning
Bobby O'Hearn
Service was okay, at best. Very cold atmosphere. Chairs not comfy at all. Food was tasteless, rigatoni was awful, flavorless... Average at best. Will not be back. The previous design, food, and ambiance was 100% better.
Scott Hayes
All good things must come to an end, and that absolutely applies here. This WAS an excellent restaurant, but now everything has changed and NOT for the better. Crappy attitudes, AWFUL interior, and even the food was mediocre at best! I am literally gutted by this crushing disappointment! I will literally never come back! Soooo unbelievably disappointed!!!! Will NEVER come back!!!!
Michelle DeNuzzo
The Brussel sprout kale salad was very good and enough to share. The fish and chips served like a child meal with tiny pieces of fish like chicken nuggets. The ketchup and tartar are served in tiny paper cups. The cosmos are so small! Its not worth the price!
Mike
Right around corner from us and part of Resy group so stopped in to take advantage of the Amex quarterly credit. Nice sized bar and restaurant with great atmosphere. Service always good although bar area can get loud. Food is ok. It’s not bad it’s just not the best on the island although I think having a wide variety of options on menu plus full bar makes up for it. I had a ribeye special last night, was a reasonable portion for price and overall good although some tougher portions. Wife had same and kids had fish and chips and the burger both looked good. The hand cut fries are very good. Good beer selection too. I do wish they changed up menu more and offered a wider variety of appetizers.
Karl Sillitoe
Ordered 3 appetizers. Not very appetizing at all. Atmosphere inside was nice and pleasant. Apps a no go.
I heard about their pork chops being very good so my husband and I decided to give it a try. We must say best pork chops ever! Tender and delicious. Atmosphere very nice would definitely recommend restaurant.
J Backlund
Slow service and food and drink not even close to being good enough for what they charge.
Nick Grey
Great spot with friendly staff and atmosphere. Good choice of menu items.
Jo Dean
DELICIOUS. All of our dishes were great, especially the swordfish.
Scott Baumann
Staff was truly awful. Told me my order was almost ready, then 10 mins later when I asked if it was ready they told me the order was never received. Owner was extremely rude and I would avoid this place at all costs
Tasty food and cocktails!
It was our first time at The Arlington recently, and we had a bad experience overall. Everything on the menu was extremely expensive for what you get. It was small portions, drink options were limited with not much variety, and the service was poor. The food tasted okay but nothing special. The biggest thing was the price… the bill absolutely shocked us when we received it. We thought during the off season maybe they would’ve lowered the prices for the locals, but that was not the case here. We wanted to try a new place on the island that we haven’t tried before, but we will not be going back unfortunately as there are much better options in the area on and off the island.
Definitely overpriced! Food was just ok - cocktails were served in a mini cocktail glass. Most likely not returning.
Food and cocktails were extremely subpar for the price. I ordered my son ice cream dessert, and I did not double check the price which I admit was my fault.. a bowl of vanilla ice cream was $13. Cocktails were very subpar. Waitress was rude. They also sat a large party at the table right behind us when the whole dining room was open. Will not be recommending or returning
Service was okay, at best. Very cold atmosphere. Chairs not comfy at all. Food was tasteless, rigatoni was awful, flavorless... Average at best. Will not be back. The previous design, food, and ambiance was 100% better.
All good things must come to an end, and that absolutely applies here. This WAS an excellent restaurant, but now everything has changed and NOT for the better. Crappy attitudes, AWFUL interior, and even the food was mediocre at best! I am literally gutted by this crushing disappointment! I will literally never come back! Soooo unbelievably disappointed!!!! Will NEVER come back!!!!
The Brussel sprout kale salad was very good and enough to share. The fish and chips served like a child meal with tiny pieces of fish like chicken nuggets. The ketchup and tartar are served in tiny paper cups.
The cosmos are so small!
Its not worth the price!
Right around corner from us and part of Resy group so stopped in to take advantage of the Amex quarterly credit. Nice sized bar and restaurant with great atmosphere. Service always good although bar area can get loud. Food is ok. It’s not bad it’s just not the best on the island although I think having a wide variety of options on menu plus full bar makes up for it. I had a ribeye special last night, was a reasonable portion for price and overall good although some tougher portions. Wife had same and kids had fish and chips and the burger both looked good. The hand cut fries are very good. Good beer selection too. I do wish they changed up menu more and offered a wider variety of appetizers.
Ordered 3 appetizers. Not very appetizing at all. Atmosphere inside was nice and pleasant. Apps a no go.
Awesome food, only place open during the storm!
Restaurantji Recommends
I heard about their pork chops being very good so my husband and I decided to give it a try. We must say best pork chops ever! Tender and delicious. Atmosphere very nice would definitely recommend restaurant.
Slow service and food and drink not even close to being good enough for what they charge.
Great spot with friendly staff and atmosphere. Good choice of menu items.
DELICIOUS. All of our dishes were great, especially the swordfish.
Staff was truly awful. Told me my order was almost ready, then 10 mins later when I asked if it was ready they told me the order was never received. Owner was extremely rude and I would avoid this place at all costs
Loading...