Papillon 25

Name: Papillon 25
Address: 25 Valley St, South Orange, New Jersey, 07079, US
Telephone: (973) 761-5299
Price range: $$
Rating: 3.8

$$ • American, French, Cajun

Hours:
25 Valley St, South Orange
(973) 761-5299

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Papillon 25

Papillon 25 offers a great atmosphere, perfect for socializing and enjoying drinks. The restaurant boasts friendly and efficient staff, generous food portions, and flavorful drinks. The calamari and oxtail were really good. The salmon, mash potatoes, and mac and cheese were delicious. Every drink was just as good as the previous one, with the bartender Brianna W known for mixing great drinks. The red snapper was so filling and worth every penny. The bread was awesome, and the mimosa was especially good. The jerkwings were legit, and the Wasabi dip was a good compliment. The inside area has a nice vibe with a mature crowd, making it a nice place to relax. Visitors enjoyed the ambience and the variety of food, although some found the prices a bit high for what they received. Parking can be tight, and service charges can be unexpected, especially for just drinks at the bar. The bartender’s attitude was noted as rude by some, and there was an upcharge for a drink made by another bartender.

During a late Valentine’s Day dinner, guests could still enjoy the Valentine’s Day menu, which added a fun touch. The waiters were attentive, and food was served timely. Meals included buffalo shrimp, surf & surf (shrimp, scallops, and lobster in a sauce with white rice and veggies), and surf and turf (lobster, steak, mashed potatoes, and spinach with mushrooms). Desserts featured run raisin ice cream and chocolate-covered strawberries. Some dishes, like the lobster, did not meet expectations in texture, and the ice cream's texture was not ideal for everyone. A sangria pitcher was enjoyed and appreciated. Overall, Papillon 25 remains a delightful spot with a nice atmosphere, great service, and flavorful drinks, making it a good place to visit again.