Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

50 W Bay Ave, Manahawkin
(609) 978-0587

Recent Reviews

joseph stoia

So good!

Don Massa

Love Mango Gelatis. Nice location friendly service. Many choices and flavors. Keep getting Mango. Nothing like a Wooder ice on a hot summers day.

monique l reyes

I enjoy Rita's custard it hasn't failed me yet.

Madison T

Never have the core flavors such as cherry, lemon, chocolate, etc. Always have the same flavors that nobody wants :(

Kimberly Fiore

Today I went to Rita’s in hopes I was gonna have a good mint custard (which I’ve gotten one other time and it was fine) , but unfortunately the taste was off, and I got it with chocolate sprinkles on a kids cone. I had brought my concerns to the manager in hopes of being able to get an exchange, which he told me that I had eaten more than half of it, which is impossible because I only had a couple of licks(also a kids size) of it until I realized that it was absolutely off putting & the taste is still on my tongue as I write this review, I was treated extremely poorly and he wanted nothing to do with me, and completely dismissed me in front of everybody. Also, he said he tasted it and it was fine but anyone could tell you it tasted like rotten milk & i payed aswell as tipped!! He said he couldn’t exchange it because we didnt like it, when that wasn't the case! He completely conducted business in the wrong manner & he lost two customers & customers families! What a horrible business owner. Also is dirty so no surprise the mint custard went bad!

Bridget steeb

Today I went to Rita’s in hopes I was gonna have a good mint custard (which I’ve gotten one other time and it was fine) , but unfortunately the taste was off, and I got it with chocolate sprinkles on a kids cone. I had brought my concerns to the manager in hopes of being able to get an exchange, which he told me that I had eaten more than half of it, which is impossible because I only had a couple of licks(also a kids size) of it until I realized that it was absolutely off putting & the taste is still on my tongue as I write this review, I was treated extremely poorly and he wanted nothing to do with me, and completely dismissed me in front of everybody. Also, he said he tasted it and it was fine but anyone could tell you it tasted like rotten milk & i payed aswell as tipped!! He said he couldn’t exchange it because we didnt like it, when that wasn't the case! He completely conducted business in the wrong manner & he lost two customers & customers families! What a horrible business owner. Also is dirty so no surprise the mint custard went bad! It wasn’t that i didn’t like it, ive had it there before and it was good, it was that it tastes like it went bad this time. why is this owners arrogance and ego getting in the way of conducting good business omg he is the worst , wow i’m applauded. Wouldn’t want him to be someone i ever do business with again. Hope they get new ownership again next year this franchise owner is doing it all wrong and i will be contacting corporate.

Kimberly F.

Today I went to Rita's in hopes I was gonna have a good mint custard (which I've gotten one other time and it was fine) , but unfortunately the taste was off, and I got it with chocolate sprinkles on a kids cone. I had brought my concerns to the manager in hopes of being able to get an exchange, which he told me that I had eaten more than half of it, which is impossible because I only had a couple of licks(also a kids size) of it until I realized that it was absolutely off putting & the taste is still on my tongue as I write this review, I was treated extremely poorly and he wanted nothing to do with me, and completely dismissed me in front of everybody. Also, he said he tasted it and it was fine but anyone could tell you it tasted like rotten milk & i payed aswell as tipped!! He said he couldn't exchange it because we didnt like it, when that wasn't the case! He completely conducted business in the wrong manner & he lost two customers & customers families! What a horrible business owner. Also is dirty so no surprise the mint custard went bad!

Elizabeth Piccinini

Only there once.Service was good.Parking was not the best, due to location.

Patrick Walsh

Visited tonight and it was great. Very good service.

Ed D.

Stopped here on the way back from LBI on a very sunny and hot Wednesday afternoon. There was a long line, staff very friendly, quick, and professional. The ice was fresh and many flavors were available. I highly recommend this place and will be back when in the area. They have a gate entrance to the lake in the back which was an added plus to the location.

Danielle

So far I have not been impressed with the ice flavors being offered. It seems like since they have opened back up it has been mostly the same flavors with minimum changes. No mint chocolate chip cream ice in sight. Plus you have to call half the time to even know what they have because the fb page hardly gives updates. Very annoying. The upside is if you love Swedish fish flavor then your in luck because that never goes off the menu…

Ben D.

Go home and put some color dye on an ice cubeBOOMCongratulations!!!You just made a superior product to Rita's Ice

Rob Haywood

I enjoyed Rita's after a long days work with a good friend and his son. Service was great

misty potoczak

First time coming this season. Ordered quite a bit and everything looked great till I noticed my Reeses concrete looked half eaten already. Didn't complain because I know the workers work hard just would of liked a full cup of icecream ??#UPDATEOwner was very nice and we recieved coupons for next visit. Hope to be back soon.

Scott

Your standard franchise custard close to the beach and next to a nice park to walk off the calories

Load More

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

50 W Bay Ave, Manahawkin, NJ 08050
(609) 978-0587