The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+88 photos
+87 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

Outstanding from start to the end of our meal! We were a party of 9 kite flyers in town after performing at the LBI Kite Festival over the weekend. The entire staff treated us like royalty. Great appetizers (fried calamari and fried crab cakes balls were delicious! Huge variety in the menu. Some guests ordered their famous wedge salad and other salads to have with after appetizers. Large portions. Their steaks (NY Strip-Prime cutand the Tenderloin) were perfectly prepared to our...
We don't usually dine out on a Saturday, but had a family gathering and we thought everyone would enjoy The Causeway. Our group of 7 adults and 2 children was lucky to get a reservation. Parking was atrocious, as the restaurant was extremely busy. I have to say, our server was pleasant and very efficient. There was a bit of a wait for food, but the kitchen had to be slammed. Kid's meals came out quickly, however. Noise level was very high. Future visits will be weeknights.
I had thought the restaurant was more up-scale than it was, just being really a large bar atmosphere. It was soo crowded that we parked probably a half-mile up an adjacent nearly unpaved road across the way.

More Reviews