EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN
9 Main Street, Sussex
(973) 875-3000
Customers' Favorites
Spice Is Nice Burger w Onion Rings
California Cobb Salad
Cheesesteak Hoagie
Prime Rib Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Fried Pickles
Fish and Chips
Irish Burger
Chicken Wings
Pretzel Bites
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We recently visited the Early American Tavern for the first time. My wife and I are not from the area but we went there based on reviews. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal along with the great conversations we had with Ashley. We topped it off with a great dessert and had a wonderful experience. We plan on returning to this establishment again in the near future. The boneless chicken in the peach bourbon sauce was delicious as an appetizer. My wife and I also really enjoyed the...
Lovely people and really good food. The onion petals were the hit! But old bay wings, buffalo chicken wrap, French onion soup, and pulled pork are highly recommended as well. Great friendly bar service and all around cozy place
Not sure what's going on at Early American tavern these days. I ordered the mushrooms burger as I always did in the past and it was horrible. This time the hamburger meat was disgusting it didn't taste good at all. It had no taste,no flavor I had to use salt,pepper and ketchup on it something I Never had to do in the past. UGH! Didn't even finish it. I will give it 1 more try and if it happens again I will not bring my family of 6 back again.
You May Also Like
Old Stone - 13 Mill St
![]()
Burgers, Sandwich Shop
Bobo Kitchen - 63 Main Street
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian