EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN
9 Main St, Sussex
(973) 875-3000
Customers' Favorites
Spice Is Nice Burger w Onion Rings
California Cobb Salad
Cheesesteak Hoagie
Prime Rib Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Fried Pickles
Fish and Chips
Irish Burger
Chicken Wings
Pretzel Bites
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Have been coming here for quite some time and was always satisfied with the food and service. But today was very disappointed with the service or lack thereof. The server never checked to see if our meals were alright and didn't check to see if we wanted another drink until we were almost finished even with an empty glass on the edge of the table. Server was too busy talking about employees bartending abilities with two other workers. Also we were the only occupied booth....
so check it, food is pretty good, wings fire, corn bread banging, but kinda like the other dude mentioned, the waitress also forgot about one of our dishes. came out after we brought it up to her so that's cool. first time I visited my beer was actually carbonated but idk if the person who poured it put their heart in it (it was flat) told the waitress and she mentioned that it's on tap and just like shrugged, which cool! but didnt really offer a resolution so I just...
Solid 4 here! The food was very good. We had a cheese steak, a cheese calzone and a burger. The burger was absolutely delicious!! The cheese steak and the calzone were also outstanding. The only thing I wasn’t impressed with was the soup. It was lukewarm and a little tasteless. We will be back and I would definitely recommend! Oh and the dessert was also delicious.
You May Also Like
Old Stone - 13 Mill St
![]()
Burgers, Sandwich Shop
Bobo Kitchen - 63 Main St
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian