I love this place it’s right by where I work the pizza is great I always call in my order and pick it up with no problems
Tim Holland
Great pizza! And the guy even hooked us up with an extra slice because one of the slices was on the small side - we didn't even ask him. Highly recommend
Susana Canelo
Delicious pizza! Friendly staff. The owner is super nice. Love this spot
reynold arnold
Place is well kept and clean. Pizza tastes great and the owner is very nice! 100% recommend!
Latisha Isley-Robinson
The pizza is extremely good however their phone rarely works and the website is not up so it’s hard to order.....
Doris Weintz
First time I ordered. But will not be the last. Penne with meat sauce was better than mom's. Portions are generous. I really enjoyed the pasta and Caesars salad. I will have enough for dinner tomorrow!!Let's support local businesses!!
Daniel Hoey
I ordered a salad and it was appalling. Doesnt anyone pride themselves in quality ingredients anymore? Seemingly pickled “Italian vegetables” (carrots and cauliflower) not fresh, rolled up slices of provolone instead of chunks off the block, canned sliced black olives instead of whole olives, store bought croutons, questionable lettuce and eh chicken. Paid $18.50 to be disappointed. Even the dressing was in a bag. Italian food is about quality and being homemade. The eggplant rollatini was okay but does not make up for this lackluster salad. Maybe your pizza Is great, haven’t tried it... but if you can’t do a good salad then don’t sell them and spare your customers
Tina Daniels
Great pizza , nice and attentive staff, can’t wait to try other items on the menu. I would definitely recommend Carlino’s pizza .. my favorite is sausage pizza..
Scott Carlino
Had to post. It keeps.popping up on my phone. I'm not that arrogant to give myself 5 stars...dwl! Hope to see everyone soon.
Denise Thompson
First time ordering from here. Wow! Excellent choice. Finally a pizza that has that NY excellence. Perfect sauce. Perfect crust. Bye bye commercial pizza places. I'll be ordering from here from now on. So if you guys are tired of the commercial same old same, give this place a try. Spoke with the owner who was so nice and I believe it was the mom who delivered and she was so nice. Thank you guys for setting up shop in Teaneck.
This was my 1st visit & the owner was so pleasant. He was training a new employee who was also very pleasant. Now to the food. I ordered the Philly cheesesteak sub & the meatball sub. They were both so delicious. They did not skimp on the meat & the bread was extremely fresh. Glad I went there & I will be back. -Pamela
I love this place it’s right by where I work the pizza is great I always call in my order and pick it up with no problems
Great pizza! And the guy even hooked us up with an extra slice because one of the slices was on the small side - we didn't even ask him. Highly recommend
Delicious pizza! Friendly staff. The owner is super nice. Love this spot
Place is well kept and clean. Pizza tastes great and the owner is very nice! 100% recommend!
The pizza is extremely good however their phone rarely works and the website is not up so it’s hard to order.....
First time I ordered. But will not be the last. Penne with meat sauce was better than mom's. Portions are generous. I really enjoyed the pasta and Caesars salad. I will have enough for dinner tomorrow!!Let's support local businesses!!
I ordered a salad and it was appalling. Doesnt anyone pride themselves in quality ingredients anymore? Seemingly pickled “Italian vegetables” (carrots and cauliflower) not fresh, rolled up slices of provolone instead of chunks off the block, canned sliced black olives instead of whole olives, store bought croutons, questionable lettuce and eh chicken. Paid $18.50 to be disappointed. Even the dressing was in a bag. Italian food is about quality and being homemade. The eggplant rollatini was okay but does not make up for this lackluster salad. Maybe your pizza Is great, haven’t tried it... but if you can’t do a good salad then don’t sell them and spare your customers
Great pizza , nice and attentive staff, can’t wait to try other items on the menu. I would definitely recommend Carlino’s pizza .. my favorite is sausage pizza..
Had to post. It keeps.popping up on my phone. I'm not that arrogant to give myself 5 stars...dwl! Hope to see everyone soon.
First time ordering from here. Wow! Excellent choice. Finally a pizza that has that NY excellence. Perfect sauce. Perfect crust. Bye bye commercial pizza places. I'll be ordering from here from now on. So if you guys are tired of the commercial same old same, give this place a try. Spoke with the owner who was so nice and I believe it was the mom who delivered and she was so nice. Thank you guys for setting up shop in Teaneck.
Restaurantji Recommends
This was my 1st visit & the owner was so pleasant. He was training a new employee who was also very pleasant. Now to the food. I ordered the Philly cheesesteak sub & the meatball sub. They were both so delicious. They did not skimp on the meat & the bread was extremely fresh. Glad I went there & I will be back. -Pamela