Mel's Butcher Box

10 W Railroad Ave, Tenafly
(201) 266-4633

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Mel's Double Butcher Box Classic Pat's Prime Rib and House Fries
Prime Rib Sandwich and Disco Fries
Bacon Double Cheeseburger
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Tomahawk Ribeye Steak
Cheesesteak Sandwich
Mel's Double Burger
Sweet Potato Fries
Crispy Onion Rings

Menu

Burgers
Smash Burger.
4 oz. Lafrieda blend burger, grilled red onions, smash sauce & pickles, with cheese
Mel's Double
Caramelized onions, American cheese & Mel's secret sauce
10 West Burger
8 oz. Lafrieda blend burger with bacon jam, lettuce, tomato & cheddar cheese on a toasted English Muffin
Butcher Box Classic
Lafrieda blend burger, American cheese & pickles
Country Apple Chicken Burger
Pepper Jack cheese, pickled red onions, arugula & honey mustard
Eat Your Veggies Burger
Provolone & sundried tomato aioli
Butcher Box Sliders
American cheese & pickles
Burger Bash Winning Burger
.WINNER of the NYC WFF Blue Moon Burger Bash People's Choice Award 2023!! Two Lafrieda burger patties, maple bourbon bacon jam, melted cheddar cheese, crispy seasoned shallots on a toasted buttered Martin's potato roll

Sandwiches
Sliced Ribeye Cheesesteak
Caramelized onions, American cheese & steak sauce aioli
Italian Stallion
Grilled chicken, broccoli rabe, fresh mozzarella & garlic aioli
Crispy Chicken
Celery root slaw, spicy mayo & pickles on a Martin's potato roll
House Roasted Turkey
Lettuce, tomato and avocado spread
Ultimate BLT
Crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato & garlic aioli on toasted heritage wheat
Turkey Club
Crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato & garlic aioli on toasted heritage wheat
Butcher Box Cubano
House roasted pork, Virginia Ham, Swiss cheese, pickles & honey mustard aioli
Hot Pastrami
Swiss cheese, celery root slaw, honey mustard aioli & pickles on rye
Grilled Chicken
Provolone, arugula & chipotle spread on a pressed baguette

Mel's Specialties
Chicken Tenders
4 Bell & Evan's organic chicken tenders
World's Greatest Hotdog
Pat Lafrieda 100% all beef hotdog
Hot Honey Chicken
Crispy chicken breast, sriracha hot honey, ranch & pickles on a toasted Martin's potato roll
Brooklyn Italian Hero
Imported ham, salami, provolone cheese, shredded lettuce, roasted red peppers & red wine vinaigrette
Steak Frites
Marinated Pat Lafrieda reserve cut steak with seasoned house fries & steak sauce aioli
Grandma Janet's Meatballs
Housemade marinara, fresh mozzarella & basil on a pressed baguette
Lasagna

Salads
The Butcher Box Salad
Seasonal greens, cherry tomato, cucumbers, chickpeas, red onion, crumbled feta & balsamic vinaigrette
Classic Ceasar Salad
Housemade croutons & shaved imported parm
Hold The Bun Salad
Class butcher box burger with romaine lettuce, cherry tomato, cucumber, pickled red onions, shredded lettuce & creamy Italian dressing

Fries & Sides
Hot Sourdough Pretzel
Cheese dip & honey mustard aioli
Big Mozz
Panko-crusted mozzarella sticks with housemade vodka sauce
Seasoned Tater Tots
3 Homemade Cookies
Homemade Cookie
Loaded Tater Tots
Kettle Chips
Half Dozen Housemade Cookies
House Fries
Crispy Onion Rings
Sweet Potato Fries
Mac & Cheese Bites

Mel's Milkshakes Bar
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry
Peanut Butter
Salted Caramel

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+13 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+12 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Had the absolute best burger of my life prepared by Melanie herself. She is wonderful omg what a kind, authentic and most talented lady . Gina who also was there to ring customers was so nice. My brother and sister let me know about this place. Its amazing. I had the smashburger, fries the Joes tea and bought my 12 yeaf r old home a homeade rice crispie oreo treat. My son an absolute foodie loved it. They use the best meats and the prices are attainable. I was just wowed!!
July 2025
EAT AT MEL'S BUTCHER BOX NOW... YOU WILL THANK ME!

If you’re looking for the PERFECT place to host a private event—or just want the BEST burger, milkshake, and onion rings of your life—go to Mel’s Butcher Block in Tenafly. Full stop.

We recently celebrated my son’s graduation here, and I can’t say enough about how amazing the experience was. Mel and her sister, Gina, went above and beyond to make it unforgettable. We rented...
July 2025
I would love to share a beautiful photo but I finished my burger 2-3 minutes after my order arrived so I could only take this photo. You can see other great burgers when you go there. Mel is an incredible person and I order from her at least 3 times a week. Definitely the best in the area.
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Tavlin - 7 W Railroad Ave
Mediterranean, Kosher, Middle Eastern, Israeli, Vegan
Bread Boutique and Cafe - 15 W Railroad Ave
Cafe, Bakery, Coffee & Tea, Salad, Gluten-Free
Brasserie Tenafly - 4 Washington St
French, American, Vegetarian

Mel's Butcher Box

10 W Railroad Ave, Tenafly, NJ 07670
(201) 266-4633