I can only comment on the hamentashen and the cheese danish. Both are the best ever. Soft fresh and stuffed. Hard to stay away from
Alexander R.
This bakery has been in this town for as long as I remember. The only thing I ever get here is their cheese danish and coffee. Not that I don't like anything else, it's that I'm freaking crazy about cheese danish. Anytime I go into a bakery I look for them before anything else. If they have them then it's what I'm getting, and Miller's always has them. They make a big one for 9.95 that lasts me at least a couple of days. They also make a large cappuccino with an extra shot that is really good. Most places won't make you a large cappuccino so for that I choose Miller's when I want a big cup of coffee. The servers are always pleasant and professional and they have ample seating if you want to sit and enjoy your coffee. The spot is quiet so if you're looking for a nice quiet spot then this is the place for you.
V M
7 teenage boys came in from subzero temperatures after playing soccer and No one wanted to eat the birthday cake!!!! That's how terrible the cake was.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Robert Pavone
Recently stopped in twice, once to order a yule log cake, and once to pick it up, and both times I had the pleasure of being helped by Annie. Very polite, very professional, and really cares about getting your order exactly the way you want it.The cake itself was amazing! Not only did it look like an actual log made of wood, but it tasted delicious! They also added some plastic people and animal figures so that when you open the box it looks like a classic winter scene. Very nicely done! I only wish I had taken a picture.Miller's bakery does not disappoint! Delicious cakes and cookies and friendly staff. How can you go wrong?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian S.
Stail,. The cookies are hard as rocks. Owner is oblivious. I over paid and left a good tip, in a town where nobody tips. From there I walked through the CVS Alley way and couldn't believe how filthy everything is. Trash everywhere. Looks like Mexico! Good work to the people who run this town.
Susan Cohen D.
We are long-time Millers customers. Their baked goods are thoughtfully made and consistently delicious. Ani and Kristina, the weekday counter-workers, are always friendly and helpful, and we enjoy chatting with them. The custom cakes we order are always made to perfection. We only wish that Millers hadn't removed the TVs that used to be in the corners of the dining area; it would encourage people to extend their stay at the tables.
Sarah Baradaran-Noviri
Millers bakery has been a staple in our home for years and every holiday they do not disappoint. Not only is the quality superb but the people there even more. I wouldn’t recommend any other bakery.BTW try to find better black and white cookies anywhere else!!!!!!
Yayi U.
New to neighboring town. Was searching a bakery with primo reputation for my sister's birthday cake, which I had to bring to New York. First of all.. what is happening with the prices of everything food- related?? I know businesses have to stay in good operating condition, but wow! Who pays $100 for a simple 1tier cake with frosting and 4 words?? Ugh! I came across Miller's and didn't know I'd struck gold. I don't want to ramble on and on.. but it's beyond DELICIOUS. The cake, chocolate with an amazing white filling, was a huge hit! Even the restaurant owner had a slice and asked me where I got it.... I, of course sang their praises. The service is top notch. Greeted with smiles and gratitude. I grabbed pound cake too.. slices in a basket by cashier... NOT disappointed. I found my Go To bakery. Plan to go back to sample Everything else!!
Kathy Chou
The filling for the cream puffs and eclairs is whipped frosting, not pastry cream
恩知说中文Let’s speak Chinese together.
Beautiful, abundant assortment of different delicious baked goods, great prices, and Incredibly friendly ownership. Highest recommendation.
Saw the old, guy owner being rude to a black customer. he treated the other customers nicely. Only hires pretty, young girls, too. The food was tasteless and carelessly made, as many other people have stated. has he thought about retiring yet?
Peter Luger
Called in and reserved something to be made for a birthday. Showed up on the day which they said it will be done.Nothing was made, they saw the order in the computer but didn’t provide any explanation as to why it wasn’t made.Told me that they can have it done by 1pm of that day, but that didn’t work out for us and defied the whole purpose of ordering a week in advance. All good, ended up getting cupcakes in a pinch, but overall not satisfied with the job they had and therefore will curb how many times we do business with them.
Nancy Alonso
Review long overdue. I personally had one of the best experiences ordering from Millers in tenafly. I ordered a custom cake for my sons 10th birthday and they did exactly what I asked for. Even delivered! The cake was so moist and delicious. It was more than I could ask for. The staff was friendly communicating and efficient. I will be ordering from here all my cakes.
Minseon
I visited here this morning and overall it was disappointing.No one said hi when I entered not even when I said hello at the counter.Someone else came in when I was looking at the menu. I told him I need more minutes so you can go ahead.One of the staff was so welcoming to him and said hi as soon as she saw him.But I didn’t get any greeting even when I said hi first.I ordered hot latte and was waiting for it.The staff who made my coffee roughly poured milk into a cup in front of me and turned around without answering when I said thank you so much. She didn’t even look at me as if I wasn’t there.I don’t know if it was just my misunderstanding but I could tell that the way they treat other customer and me were different.I don’t know if it was because I’m Asian or because I’m younger than them so they don’t really care about young customer like me.I don’t think I’ll visit again.
Anna J.
We ordered a chocolate cake with strawberry filling and Bavarian cream. We paid $50 for a custom cake and we didn't expect to receive an old dried out cake that didn't have what we ordered. Was really disappointed and could've went with a cheaper shoprite cake.
I can only comment on the hamentashen and the cheese danish. Both are the best ever. Soft fresh and stuffed. Hard to stay away from
This bakery has been in this town for as long as I remember. The only thing I ever get here is their cheese danish and coffee. Not that I don't like anything else, it's that I'm freaking crazy about cheese danish. Anytime I go into a bakery I look for them before anything else. If they have them then it's what I'm getting, and Miller's always has them. They make a big one for 9.95 that lasts me at least a couple of days. They also make a large cappuccino with an extra shot that is really good. Most places won't make you a large cappuccino so for that I choose Miller's when I want a big cup of coffee. The servers are always pleasant and professional and they have ample seating if you want to sit and enjoy your coffee. The spot is quiet so if you're looking for a nice quiet spot then this is the place for you.
7 teenage boys came in from subzero temperatures after playing soccer and No one wanted to eat the birthday cake!!!! That's how terrible the cake was.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Recently stopped in twice, once to order a yule log cake, and once to pick it up, and both times I had the pleasure of being helped by Annie. Very polite, very professional, and really cares about getting your order exactly the way you want it.The cake itself was amazing! Not only did it look like an actual log made of wood, but it tasted delicious! They also added some plastic people and animal figures so that when you open the box it looks like a classic winter scene. Very nicely done! I only wish I had taken a picture.Miller's bakery does not disappoint! Delicious cakes and cookies and friendly staff. How can you go wrong?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stail,. The cookies are hard as rocks. Owner is oblivious. I over paid and left a good tip, in a town where nobody tips. From there I walked through the CVS Alley way and couldn't believe how filthy everything is. Trash everywhere. Looks like Mexico! Good work to the people who run this town.
We are long-time Millers customers. Their baked goods are thoughtfully made and consistently delicious. Ani and Kristina, the weekday counter-workers, are always friendly and helpful, and we enjoy chatting with them. The custom cakes we order are always made to perfection. We only wish that Millers hadn't removed the TVs that used to be in the corners of the dining area; it would encourage people to extend their stay at the tables.
Millers bakery has been a staple in our home for years and every holiday they do not disappoint. Not only is the quality superb but the people there even more. I wouldn’t recommend any other bakery.BTW try to find better black and white cookies anywhere else!!!!!!
New to neighboring town. Was searching a bakery with primo reputation for my sister's birthday cake, which I had to bring to New York. First of all.. what is happening with the prices of everything food- related?? I know businesses have to stay in good operating condition, but wow! Who pays $100 for a simple 1tier cake with frosting and 4 words?? Ugh! I came across Miller's and didn't know I'd struck gold. I don't want to ramble on and on.. but it's beyond DELICIOUS. The cake, chocolate with an amazing white filling, was a huge hit! Even the restaurant owner had a slice and asked me where I got it.... I, of course sang their praises. The service is top notch. Greeted with smiles and gratitude. I grabbed pound cake too.. slices in a basket by cashier... NOT disappointed. I found my Go To bakery. Plan to go back to sample Everything else!!
The filling for the cream puffs and eclairs is whipped frosting, not pastry cream
Beautiful, abundant assortment of different delicious baked goods, great prices, and Incredibly friendly ownership. Highest recommendation.
Restaurantji Recommends
Saw the old, guy owner being rude to a black customer. he treated the other customers nicely. Only hires pretty, young girls, too. The food was tasteless and carelessly made, as many other people have stated. has he thought about retiring yet?
Called in and reserved something to be made for a birthday. Showed up on the day which they said it will be done.Nothing was made, they saw the order in the computer but didn’t provide any explanation as to why it wasn’t made.Told me that they can have it done by 1pm of that day, but that didn’t work out for us and defied the whole purpose of ordering a week in advance. All good, ended up getting cupcakes in a pinch, but overall not satisfied with the job they had and therefore will curb how many times we do business with them.
Review long overdue. I personally had one of the best experiences ordering from Millers in tenafly. I ordered a custom cake for my sons 10th birthday and they did exactly what I asked for. Even delivered! The cake was so moist and delicious. It was more than I could ask for. The staff was friendly communicating and efficient. I will be ordering from here all my cakes.
I visited here this morning and overall it was disappointing.No one said hi when I entered not even when I said hello at the counter.Someone else came in when I was looking at the menu. I told him I need more minutes so you can go ahead.One of the staff was so welcoming to him and said hi as soon as she saw him.But I didn’t get any greeting even when I said hi first.I ordered hot latte and was waiting for it.The staff who made my coffee roughly poured milk into a cup in front of me and turned around without answering when I said thank you so much. She didn’t even look at me as if I wasn’t there.I don’t know if it was just my misunderstanding but I could tell that the way they treat other customer and me were different.I don’t know if it was because I’m Asian or because I’m younger than them so they don’t really care about young customer like me.I don’t think I’ll visit again.
We ordered a chocolate cake with strawberry filling and Bavarian cream. We paid $50 for a custom cake and we didn't expect to receive an old dried out cake that didn't have what we ordered. Was really disappointed and could've went with a cheaper shoprite cake.