Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream

462 Shrewsbury Ave #4901, Tinton Falls
(732) 842-5874

Recent Reviews

Kathleen Crosson

Asked for a hot fudge sundae..with walnutsThere was not even a teaspoon worth of hot fudge on it.And there were actually 3 half walnuts on it!You got to be kidding me!10.00 for 2 scoops of ice cream..Shame on you!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Craig James

At the time it was seasonal and I ordered the Eggnog ice cream very creative this year don't know whether the special ice cream would be will be going

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jette Stream

Great local ice cream place with new flavors

Lou McGuire

Used to have great ice cream just average

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 5

Rose Viragh

Great variety of ice cream especially seasonal special. Try pumpkin pie

Kathy Whooley

Liked the Italian cookie ice cream. Unique flavors. Chocolate shake was good too.

Brendon Fox

I just paid $15+ for three extremely tiny scoops of ice cream combined between one small and one medium cup and came home to find a massive hair in the medium mint chip. The place is skeevy and is always uncomfortably hot inside. The portions are minuscule in relation to the prices. Absolutely grossed out, will never be going back here.

Marc L.

Excellent homemade ice cream. Somehow I've lived in the area for 50 years now and I have zero memory of ever having come to Ryan's before, even though I've always known about it. Having now tried it, I'm sure I'll be back. They have numerous flavors to try and they all looked great. My father swore by the New Jersey Peach, which is apparently a favorite of customers because it was actually advertised on the sign as being back in stock. I personally dislike peach flavor so I had salted caramel instead. I was extremely happy with my selection. Like I said, I'll definitely be back.

Nicole Buntin

Disappointed, place smelled like spoiled milk, ice cream had freezer burn and the place was very dirty. The machines the floors everything looked like it hadn’t been cleaned in years and the staffs hands were dirty as well. SMH.

Eileen C.

I've been an on & off customer for several years. For a while, I stopped eating ice cream because of dairy issues. Went there two nights ago and immediately knew it has changed. I heard new owners took over, hoping the quality would stay the same. Forgettaboutit..., the coffee ice cream barely had any coffee flavor and my hubby had the pistachio. That had plenty of nuts but, the artificial pistachio flavor was so overpowering that it was barely edible. If it was mine, it would have been tossed! Guess I'm going to find a new go to spot!

J S.

Been going here since early eighties. Took a hiatus during COVID finally stopping in recently during the hot spell. Seemed different when I looked in the upright cooler. When I looked in the cooler beneath the counter I knew something had happened. 2/3 of the selections were empty. The girl apologized and said they'd have more tomorrow. The story is they changed ownership. The girl behind the counter tried to assure me they kept the recipes. The young man darting around the back room and behind the counter seemed anxious and not happy.Too bad another favorite is gone.Oh well.

Taline Papendick

Ice cream was inedible. Totally freezer burnt. Both flavors tasted like vanilla. No cookies in the Cookies and Cream. No coconut in the Samoa. Wouldn’t recommend.

J Flan

My family has been wanting to try Ryan's for quite a while now, and we finally got around to it. Ŵe are so glad we did! Homemade ice cream with fresh ingredients. Try and get there early so that they have all the flavors as they sell out fast. Try them all, you won't be disappointed!

Lisa Serronico

We stopped in on our way home from a family function I was in the mood for their peach ice cream and I have to say that it did not disappoint their ice cream is homemade if you are in the area stop by and enjoy.

Richard Link

Always loved this place. What happened?? No menu board, almost nothing available. Most of the ice cream bins were empty. What a shame.

Load More