Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream

462 Shrewsbury Ave #4901, Tinton Falls
(732) 842-5874

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Frozen Yogurt Sundae
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Italian Ice Flavors
Ice Cream Cakes
Salted Caramel
Cookie Dough

Menu

Hot Fudge Sundae
Soft Hot Fudge Sundaes
Any soft serve ice cream flavor with hot fudge, whip cream & cherry.

Create Your Own Sundae
Hard Ice Cream Sundae
Create your sundae with a choice of hard ice cream with one topping, whipped cream and a cherry. Choose up to 5 additional toppings.
Soft Ice Cream Sundae
Create your sundae with a choice of soft-serve ice cream with one topping, whipped cream and a cherry. Choose up to 5 additional toppings.
Frozen Yogurt Sundae

Banana Boat
Banana Split Hard Ice Cream
Your choice of 3 flavors of ice cream along with 3 of your chosen toppings.
Banana Split
Soft serve. Your choice of 3 flavors of ice cream along with 3 of your chosen toppings.
Banana Split Frozen Yogurt
Your choice of 3 flavors of ice cream along with 3 of your chosen toppings.

Ice Cream
Hard Cup of Ice Cream
Freshly made and scooped daily into a cup.
Soft Cup
Creamy and delicious.
Frozen Yogurt

Blend In
Blend In
Hand spun ice cream with your favorite toppings included.

Italian Ice
Italian Ice Flavors
Freshly made with real flavoring.

Gelati
Small Gelati
Layer of Italian ice and custard.

Cakes
Ice Cream Cakes
Rounded ice cream cakes made fresh daily to accommodate any occasion.

Take Home Items
Chippers
Everyone's favorite chocolate chip cookie served with vanilla soft serve and spun in chocolate chips.
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Soft serve vanilla or chocolate ice cream sandwiched between 2 flying saucers.
Party Cups
Vanilla soft serve ice cream, topped with rainbow sprinkles and a cherry.
Tortonis
Vanilla soft serve ice cream, topped with toasted coconut and a cherry.

Shakes
Hard Shakes
Hand spun shake, with your choice of ice cream.
Soft Shake
Hand spun shake, with your choice of ice cream.
Soft Shake Float
Your favorite shake topped with a scoop of your favorite ice cream.
Hard Shake Float
Your favorite shake topped with a scoop of your favorite ice cream.
Hard Ice Cream Soda
Your choice of ice cream served with your favorite soda milk mix.
Frozen Yogurt Shake
Soft Ice Cream Soda
Your choice of ice cream served with your favorite soda milk mix.
Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream Soda

Beverages
Canned Soda
Pepsi, Root Beer, Diet Pepsi, Sparkling Soda, Orange Crush, Vanilla Pepsi.
Bottled Water

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+72 photos
Photo credit: nextdoor
+71 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Ryan’s Homemade Ice Cream is easily one of the best ice cream spots in the area. The ice cream is incredibly creamy and flavorful, and you can really taste the difference compared to regular store-bought ice cream. Everything tastes fresh and truly homemade.

They have a great variety of flavors, from classic favorites to unique seasonal options, and it’s always fun trying something new. The portions are generous and the quality is consistently great every...
March 2026
Ryan’s Ice Cream has the best ice cream around. The homemade ice cream is incredible, rich, creamy, and full of flavor, and you can truly taste the difference. Can’t wait to go back.
December 2025
Ice cream is fire. This feels like a crazy thing to say, but there are too many toppings/mix ins.

I was excited to try the ice cream but the two flavors I got are about 60-80% toppings so it kind of just feels like I’m taking bites of brownies.

It’s really hard to say that “bites of brownies” is a bad thing so 5 stars!
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Dom's Cherry Street Deli - 530 Shrewsbury Ave
Deli
Bayroot - 555 Shrewsbury Ave
Lebanese, Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, Vegan, Vegetarian
Emperor Wok - 555 Shrewsbury Ave # K
Chinese

Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream

462 Shrewsbury Ave #4901, Tinton Falls, NJ 07701
(732) 842-5874