Bay Treasure

308 S Main St, Forked River
(732) 240-3474

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Barbara Babbin Mulvey

Seafood treasures was a wonderful experience for us. We purchased seafood there two nights in a row. The lobsters were cooked from there to perfection and the next night we bought scallops which were very fresh, delicious and sweet!! Highly recommend!!! Marcell was a gem!!!

Leah Emmons

We bought scallops, shrimp and crab cakes for a Valentines day meal. Well...deliciousness is not the word...those crab cakes...incredible- beautiful texture,if there was even a hint of any filler you d be hard pressed to find it.Sweet meat with a very well balanced seasoning of the crab cake. Scallops sweet as sugar!!!Sautéed beautifully ( it was a butter and white wine sauce ) Shrimp- also perfect for the meal!!I bought the pre cleaned to save a little time. Any questions I had were answered also tips were given for cooking times as he inquired as to the meal preparation as well. We will definitely be back for more seafood!!!!!!

Mike P

Best seafood in New Jersey

Max Kulawiak

Great prices and awesome food!

Jay Ford

EASY TO DEAL WITH GREAT PRICES , THANKS JERRY

James Ward

EASY TO DEAL WITH GREAT PRICES , THANKS JERRY

Katie Davidson

Awful.

Rick Galgano

Great seafood and excellent service! Had the Sea bass with the Tuscan Seasoning! And the crab cakes! Don’t forget the shrimp and crab salad! All fantastic!

Lolita Albert

This market is a definite “treasure “. Everything is so fresh snd delicious AND the owners are such nice people!! Their homemade sauces, FraDiavoli/marinara are UNBELIEVABLY GOOD

Gina Woodbury

Clean, friendly, great prices! Grabbed the Labor Day special “Clam Bake” Definitely will be back!

Teresa Migs

Delicious. Quality is great!

Mike T

Fresh and delicious! Reasonably priced makes it even better every time I go!

joseph toth

Fresh and delicious! Reasonably priced makes it even better every time I go!

Donna Wileman Castellani

Always has just what i need

eden duke

Honestly my favorite evening place. The staff was very welcoming and observant. Prices are appropriate for the quality.

Loading...