Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Place is really good staff is always friendly, I just need them to bring back the sugar free cherry ice 🍒 🧊

I love this place. The girls behind the counter were so nice to me and my family. The ice is delicious. Try the Swedish Fish flavored ice. Amazing. The custard is also great. Get an ice with a scoop of custard on top. Prices are reasonable. I love this place. Highly recommend it.

why is there only one slow worker? wait is too long!

Very expensive for ice cream or shakes

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Brownie, Cotton Candy, Create Your Own Sundae

I came with my 2 daughters along with a friend and her children to eat ice cream on Saturday night.
Let's start with the fact that the air conditioner in the place did not work and it was terribly hot.
We ordered 3 types of ice cream with different flavors, we waited over 20 (!!) minutes until the ice cream was ready, when we received the order we tried to understand what flavor each ice cream was and to our surprise it turned out that all three ice creams had the same flavor and instead of apologizing, the store clerk explained to me that the flavors are very similar and therefore I can't tell them apart ( I ordered, cake batter, salted caramel and black cherry..).
Just a complete disgrace, I will not return to this store again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Horrible! Had to throw it out. Extremely sweet and tasted fake.

Food: 1

This Rita’s no longer serves custard yet claims to do so. If you have any doubt, get a vanilla custard from any other Rita’s and taste it compared to the Route 9 Toms River location. Perhaps it’s regular soft serve vanilla ice cream, but it absolutely is NOT Rita’s custard—so they should not claim to do so.

Food: 1

Recommended dishes: Vanilla Custard

Love the coffee coolata with caramel and whip cream,all Cholev Yisroel.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Ice

The overall flavor of the custard has changed and it simply isn’t good at all. Not sure exactly how it changed, but it doesn’t taste like any other Rita’s I’ve had.

Prices are also ridiculous. Not worth $9 for a 4 layer gelati!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

We stopped at the Rita's Rte 9, Toms River for a Gelato and cone. They didn't have chocolate Italian ice, so we bought two large vanilla custard cones. Spent $16.95. The color was a pale yellow, the consistency was that of poor quality ice cream and there was an after taste. Tried calling to speak to the manager...voice mail. This is not the first time I've been disappointed with this location.
Will not be stopping there again. The Rita's in the Ocean County Mall is far superior.

Food: 1

Prices have basically doubled. Be warned. Two ice creams for kids was almost 25$. Pup cups are now charged. There’s great homemade ice cream places all over Tom’s River that make everything from scratch and are way cheaper. Staff not trained well and not fully familiar with their own menu. This will probably be our last stop at Rita’s for some time. Disappointing as it was only minutes from our home. Oh well

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

This is the second time I've been to this place and I order Italian ice flavor mango and they don't have it

7 dollars for a small icecream cone is insane

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

crazy prices then try to charge me extra money so i can put the ice in a diffrent cup so it does not leak all over my car

All good but need to get Jelly Ring flavor Italian ices

Atmosphere: 3