Panini Bay Waterfront Restaurant

The grilled eggplant panini was not edible, it tasted like propane. My husband's grilled chicken panini also had that awful taste. We couldn't eat it. However, the carrot cake was delicious. The only nice thing about the place is the beautiful bay view.

From the moment we walked in i felt an amazing atmosphere. Our waitress Bridget was amazing. She was so humble, Kind and fun in conversation. My little girl loved her ! The food was beyond what i expected. So delicious and so fresh and amazing portions with great prices. It was our first time and will not be the last. We can not wait to go back ! Thank you for a great experience.

Beautiful restaurant with fantastic views of the bay. Staci was excellent explaining the dishes we weren't familiar with. She definitely nailed it because our meals were outstanding. Beautiful clean restaurant with an awesome staff a definite 5 star.

Excellent food, great service, nice view. Table of 4, all thoroughly enjoyed. In season ,make a reservation for any night. Went on a Monday, every table was seated.

Wheelchair accessibility: Elevator to dining room is available

Really solid waterfront dining experience. The food is reasonably priced and delicious. We had the spicy crab bisque, calamari and muscles for apps we all shared. For entrees we had the steak, shrimp linguini and the chicken parm. Everyone really enjoyed their meals on top of a fantastic view. The steak is really delicious and was a big hit. The space itself is not huge but doesnt feel like you're on top of another table. Our waitress was newer so somethings took some time but totally understandable. She was super friendly nonetheless. My only complaint would be the shrimp linguini mentioned procuitto in it yet we later found out the sauce is made with it. (We were under the impression it was pieces in the dish itself. ) and the sauce was a little watery for one of our group members liking. We would definitely all return.

This place has been on my bucket list for quite some time. I made a reservation for a Saturday night and brought my father for a nice day out in Tuckerton followed by an evening at Panini Bay for dinner. This place was very busy, which tells me it's popular. The restaurant is BYOB, but there is some wine available to purchase for dinner. The menu had a good variety of choices. There's something for everyone. We went with the Ravioli and Chicken Parm. We both had salads as well. For dessert, we shared a slice of coconut cake with coffee. The staff was friendly and the service was great. We stayed for about an hour and 15 minutes. We never felt rushed and were allowed to enjoy the food, views and experience as long as we wanted. We departed with full bellies, a beautiful sunset and the excitement of coming back for more. I might get the salmon next time. That looked delicious!

Went there on my birthday,in May. Asked to sit by the window.(only 3 tables had people at them.The rest of the room was empty) she refused our request.this was at 4:30, and we had a reservation.we decided not to stay. The manager very faciously said "happy birthday", as well as the chubby waitress, I told her that was uncalled for and she said "what are you going to do, get us all fired"? And laughed in my face. If this is how their business is run, I'm glad we left.

The two of us went here for a random dinner date night. The food was incredible. I got the Mahi Mahi in the red sauce with mashed potatoes, and he got the creamy shrimp linguini. Both were delicious, and our waitress was awesome. We also got the calamari for an app, super crunchy and hit the spot. For dessert we had the lemon blueberry cheese cake (which had a coffee cake esque top to it) which was AMAZING. Highly reccomend checking this place put!

First time dining at Panini Bay Waterfront and won't be the last! From the moment we walked in, we were immediately greeted and given the choice of two seating options. Service was spot on. Food was delicious. Such great vibes with the ambiance and atmosphere. This place certainly is a hidden gem.

Great place! Everything was delicious - oyster po' boy, bruschetta, soup. And the view and atmosphere are spectacular. I want to go back!

Looking forward to another great season visiting Panini Bay - ❤️❤️❤️❤️. My father is in love with the pork chop which is the best he has ever had. I stick to the wonderful chicken parm which is so perfect every time - thin and pounded out just right. The best last night was the peanut butter pie and coconut cake to finish it up. If you like coconut at all - they have the ABSOLUTE BEST! I have had every kind of coconut pie and cake over the years and this is the best…no lie!

Very nice family run business artichoke and calamari appetizers were wonderful, spicy sausage and clams were excellent , pork chop asks a great choice,view of the bay spactular the only reason not 5 stars wine list needs alot of help but BYOB and no corkage fee, so no worries on second thought changing to 5 star ⭐ rating. Looking forward to go back

I have been going to panini bay since it opened. I was extremely disappointed. I have had the linguini with white clam sauce before. This time I received linguini in Luke warm salty water. No garlic flavor and it was barely room temperature. About a dozen clams. Tasteless. I could go on about other things but I won’t. The staff tries really hard to please. All I kept hearing was apologizing at all of the tables

We had reservations for 4 people and at the last minute we had another couple join us. We called and they accommodated us no problem. We got seated immediately when we arrived. The food & the staff could not have been any better! It's refreshing to experience such great service! Go, you will not be disappointed.

Great service and great food. Will definitely return. They were slammed today because of Valentine's day. Great team effort.