Nostra Pizza & Italian Eatery

Im extremely disappointed. I ordered delivery and I had a bowl of half eaten pasta thrown outside of my front door. They don't even bother placing them in a paper bag. It's 2025!! AT THE VERY LEAST PLACE YOUR DELIVERY ORDERS IN A BROWN PAPER BAG AND STAPLE THEM! When people are hungry and spend their hard earned money at your establishment you should do the bare minimum of what's required for food safety.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The pizza, no matter what you order, is amazing. This is my third time here and it always delivers from a plain cheese, to a veggie, to a white with fresh spinach and onion; all made to perfection! Service is outstanding, prices are reasonable and entire facility is clean; from dining area to bathrooms. This is our “go to” pizza place, you have to try it to believe it. You wont be disappointed!

Vegetarian options: All types of pizzas; including “you build your own”, just tell them what you want! Pasta dishes and other Italian meals as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was good but they forgot 1 thing ordered

Food: 4

Service: 3

The food is good, if a bit pricey. The staff is friendly. I have only ordered from here twice, and both times there was a coupon for online ordering. The first time I was told the promotion had ended, even though this was not reflected on the website. The second time it just did not apply at all. I was told that since the payment had gone through, they were not able to refund the money and offered me a dessert instead. I appreciate the gesture, truly, but the point was to save money on the order. The fact this happened to me twice here is rather suspect. It makes it seem like a scheme to get people in the door under the pretext of a discount they don't intend to honor. Other reviewers have experienced the same issue. I will not be ordering from here any longer.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

The owners are exceptional and cater to the customer experience. We order here once or twice a week. Recently we started to order half tray meals. The food is tasty, full of flavor and very filling. You will not be disappointed! Stop on over!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cannoli, Thin Crust Pizza

The sauce is too sweet. Traditional pizza was avg. "Homemade" meatballs tasted thawed.. Service was great and atmosphere was real chill!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

My daughter had dance class down the street and while I was waiting for her I stopped in because I had seen so many good reviews. I told the person (which I think was the owner) that I had never been there and asked what was good. He gave me a free slice of pizza to try! And it was excellent! Wonderful people and excellent food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is not about their food- their food is good. this is about their customer service.
They have a coupon on their website that says 15% off the entire order when you order online. No strings attached. It does not say any exclusions.
My 15% off wasn’t working (I ordered 5 pizzas, 4 of which were their daily, i.e. NORMAL special of 2 for 35.99- a $100 order total). I called to ask if I could have the discount fixed and instead what I got was RUDE customer service telling me “it doesn’t work on coupons”. I told them this is not a coupon, it’s your regular special. Your website says 15% off all online orders flat out (as you can see from the picture). He did not help me AT ALL and instead got aggressive with me on the phone saying “that’s too much of a discount.”
Well if it’s too much of a discount then DON’T PUT IT ON YOUR WEBSITE. No apologies, no “sorry this is misleading.” All he did was argue with me on the phone.
I order from here all the time and have spent thousands of dollars at this point. Not anymore. You’ve lost my business. I don’t deal with people being rude to me and telling me I’m wrong when your WEBSITE says otherwise.

Stopped in for 2 slices, must have laying out for days, horrible.

A decent pizza place. It's got a restaurant feel but has take out. Variety of choices. Lots of selection.

You can dine in or take out. Overall a good experience. Lots of choice and pizza tastes pretty good.

Given limited choices in the area I would check this place out.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Nostra Pizza & Italian Eatery offers exceptional cuisine in an impeccably clean setting. The dishes are expertly prepared and served at just the right pace. Each bite is bursting with flavor and crafted to perfection.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I placed my first order with Nastro Pizza last week and had high hopes. I ordered on the website unaware it was being delivered through DoorDash until over an hour passed and I decided to track the order and the DoorDash popped up. My personal DoorDash didn’t pop up it was just a generic one. My order was missing something so I called the restaurant, because there was no option on the contact DoorDash and the guy was soooo rude to me. I explained it was my first time ordering and that I ordered directly through their website and I was missing food. Very rudely the guy says “well I cooked it and I know I sent it, you need to call DoorDash”. I reached out to DoorDash and after 30 mins of going back and forth they were trying to help but it was determined that I had to contact Nastro again because they have the money for the order. By this time the restaurant was closed and I sent an email about the situation. A week exactly no response. I called several times and had no luck. I’m really annoyed because they are very local to my house and I love supporting small businesses. Very disappointed! Do better Nastro treat your customers better.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Pizza was watery, wings are the worst. They must by pre breaded frozen wings. Cutlets on the garlic knot was like cardboard. No sauce. The only thing good was the celery. Never eating here again. Dont waste your time or money.

Food: 1

Your looking for Pizza...ol school, delicious, with only the best quality ingredients ? You know the kind that GrandMa used! First bite and I was instantly taken back to a time when I was a kid in the mid 80’s in south Philadelphia. Pizza & pizza parties were my favorite & still are! No matter at roller skating rinks, bowling allys or friends' houses & at home where my Mom or dad would order a pizza every Friday night a tradition I keep now that Im the Dad ording my daughter's favorite food!
But thats just the Pizza!!! Garlic knots a must chicken parm that was like I was back at my Grandmothers as a teen! Real shit people... I teared up remembering what really good food cooked by lifelong lovers of food themselves I wont order from anyone else... I even drive in from Delco now... Eat in its even better & this place is so clean Joey Vento would be proud! I. Cant say enough about the food but the service top notch! So with that said my wife & 3 year old love it! My parents love it... And I know Grandma would love it as well! From me there is no greater compliment then that! Stay the same please! Change nothing! You guys are going to explode when it comes to orders thats a given... Just never change!

Parking: Lot & street parking...

Kid-friendliness: Yes... Its pizza... But so much more!

Wheelchair accessibility: No worries

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Drunk Grandma Pizza, Tiramisu, Cannoli, Thin Crust Pizza

Cold dining area. A pizza place with no cheese pizza. Brought home 3 slices. Margarita slice had a dead mosquito backed into the cheese. “Brooklyn” pizza tasted like cardboard. One slice of pepperoni was barely passable. Counter girl had the personality of a wet rag. Stay away.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1