Wallington Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant
437 Paterson Ave, Wallington
(973) 679-0086
Customers' Favorites
Plain Pizza Slice
Margarita Pizza
Garlic Knots
French Fries
Menu
Photos
+5 photos
+4 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Food is absolutely incredible. Staff is always amazing. All thanks to the the workers and the front for more than a pleasant experience. Friendly conversation as well. I believe the lady named Bri & the cook Vincent.They were awesome 💯💯🔥. i’ll come back a million times
Pizza is great, highly recommended. The only disappointing item was the Tiramisu, I thought it would have been a slice from a cake, but sadly it was a simple dessert in a cup from a grocery store.
The pizza I had here was delicious. Of all the time I was here in NY this was definitely the best pizza I had so far. Sauce was flavorful, pizza slices were crispy and large, and the garlic knots I had were above average - good amount of cheese and garlic but they were a little dry.
Only complaint was that they had run out of some menu items - I wanted to try some of the stromboli roll but they had run out.
Only complaint was that they had run out of some menu items - I wanted to try some of the stromboli roll but they had run out.
You May Also Like
Viva Margarita - 413 Paterson Ave
![]()
Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian
Wallington Diner - 417 Paterson Ave
![]()
Diner, Burgers, Comfort Food
Dunkin' - 443 Paterson Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Donuts, Coffee & Tea