Up the creek cafe
1214 St 1214, NJ-23 Building B, Wantage
(973) 702-1400
Customers' Favorites
Sausage Peppers Onions
Eggplant Parmesan
Meat Lovers Pizza
Calabrian Sausage
Cheesecake Slice
Chicken Parmesan
Oven Baked Wings
Slice of Pizza
Grilled Cheese
Italian Nachos
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Kori was super hospitable from the second we came in. Being from NY you’re always skeptical about NJ pizza but theirs is some of the best we ever had , especially a fan of their artichoke pizza ! We also needed to try their award winning cheesecake, it did not disappoint! 10/10 recommend stopping here.
Cheesecake and pizza are fantastic. The seating out back is lovely along the little counter with the running water. Perfect stop after a hike or scenic drive at highpoint. Will be back for sure. Super friendly service, too.
Parking: Small parking lot, adequate for the number of seats.
Parking: Small parking lot, adequate for the number of seats.
We were just passing through and wanted to give it a try. First of all prices were amazing for the amount of food you get. Food tasted amazing, salad was nice a fresh and my daughter truly enjoyed their prized #1 in the state cheesecake. Lg cheese pizza, garden salad, garlic bread, 4 sodas, 2 cheesecake all for $52 with tax! Highly recommend!!
You May Also Like
Elias Cole - 1176 NJ-23
![]()
American, Vegetarian
Clove Brook Market | Bakery, Deli, & Catering - 800 NJ-23
![]()
Bakery, Gluten-Free
Ventimiglia Vineyard - 101 Layton Rd
![]()
Wineries