Restaurants in Wantage

Up the creek cafe 1214 St 1214, NJ-23 Building B, Wantage Italian • $
1214 St 1214, NJ-23 Building B, Wantage

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread
Italian Nachos
Chicken Parm
Cheese Steak
Soup
Meat Lovers Pizza
Calabrian Sausage
Cheesecake Slice
Grilled Cheese
Large Salad

“I visited the place with my family and friend. We stopped over for late lunch after our visit to High Point Monument park. We had Vegetarian along with us and we could find only Pizza for them. Pizza with veggies topping was ordered and pizza was decently good, thin crust was pretty nicely baked.I enjoyed eating chicken parm with a cup of coffee ☕.The cafe is decorated with small details taken in consideration and a must try thing is cheesecake . They say they are the best cheesecake seller in 2020,2021,2022 and it really tastes good.Vegetarian options: Only Pizza is available for vegetarians”

Options

delivery
4.8Superb93 Reviews
New Airport Diner 51 County Rd 639, Wantage Diner • $
51 County Rd 639, Wantage

Customers` Favorites

Eggs Benedict
French Toast
Home Fries
Biscuits and Sausage Gravy w Eggs and Sausage
Over Easy Eggs with Hash Browns
All Day Breakfast Skillets
Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese

“Food is very good, but they need to check their menu on Doordash. The Doordash menu states that their kid's meal comes with a dessert but when I received my ordered, the receipt said "Not allowed to give kid's dessert to go"”

Options

take-out
delivery
4.7Superb98 Reviews
Skylands Craft Beer & Wine Garden 447 NJ-284, Wantage Bar • $$
447 NJ-284, Wantage

Customers` Favorites

Beer Flight
Giant Hot Salted Pretzel
Rare Breaker Mango Cart
Abrett All Beef Hot Dog

“Living close to the NY/PA/NJ border definitely has its perks.Decided to head over to Sussex County NJ to try something new for lunch. First of all, the beer flights are only $7, the downside is all beer is served in plastic cups, but the pours are nice size. They do have wine but nothing that this wine snob wanted, lol. The kitchen offers something for everyone. I had the hot Italian panini, my husband the pepperoni pizza, zero complaints. Big bonus there's was music on Sunday! Nice gentleman singing not your ordinary songs, like Eleanor Ribgy! Very cool.2nd Bonus.There's specific parking spots for motorcycles. So we will definitely be back on our scoot with some friends, scenic route from home is no highway. Nice outdoor seating and ice cream for kids, bring the whole fam, no dogs tho.”

Options

take-out
4.7Superb30 Reviews
Ventimiglia Vineyard 101 Layton Rd, Wantage Wineries
101 Layton Rd, Wantage

“We love coming to Ventimiglia. It's a small quaint place. It's not owned by a huge power house. It's a family run business that has great wine. We brought some food up and had a few drinks outside. Had a small hike on the trail behind the house after.”

Options

take-out
delivery
4.7Superb29 Reviews
Cow Patty's 154 NJ-23, Wantage Burgers
154 NJ-23, Wantage

Customers` Favorites

Fried Pickles
Border Burger
Pineapple Jalapeño Burger
Jersey Burger
Cajun Fries
Hamburger
Monsterella Sticks
Jumbo Wings
Buffalo Blue Cheese Burger
BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger

“1st time here. We ordered 2 burgers for lunch, came with fries and coleslaw. BEST burgers we have eaten in a long time. Brioche buns and patty was cooked perfectly. OUTSTANDING!We will be coming back for more. Well done on all aspects.”

Options

take-out
delivery
4.1Good185 Reviews
Yamato Hibachi Steakhouse 205 NJ-23, Wantage Japanese • $$
205 NJ-23, Wantage

Customers` Favorites

Thai Basil Beef
Filet Mignon and Chicken Volcano Onion
Thai Spring Roll 2
Lemon Chicken
Chicken Tempura
Ginger Dressing
Ocean King Roll
Treasury Island
Shrimp and Asparagus
Yellowtail & Jelapeno Rolls

“First time trying Hibachi with my family and it was delicious! Ordered the steak hibachi with fried rice, and some salmon sushi as an appetizer. Everything is fresh and well cooked. You get alot of meat in the meal, and it was so filling and delicious. Not greasy at all. This place is wonderful. Prices reasonable compared to other places.Will definitely be coming back in the future.”

Options

take-out
delivery
3.5Good50 Reviews
Extreme Pizza 218 Wantage Ave, Wantage Pizza • $$
218 Wantage Ave, Wantage

“GREAT PIZZA! Dont listen to the negative reviews, some people will never be happy. Everytime I visit Space Farms I look forward to having my lunch and dinner here. The staff is always very friendly and efficient! They also sell wings, mozzerella sticks, chicken and meatball parm sandwhiches that are to die for! Prices are great too!”

Options

take-out
delivery
3.2Average25 Reviews
Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant 455 NJ-23 #4, Wantage Pizza • $
455 NJ-23 #4, Wantage

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken
Pepperoni Roll
Cheese Pizza

“Honest to God this is the best food I have had from a Pizzeria in 20+ years. Other restaurants need to pay attention to Brothers. From the first bite to the last the food is beyond savory. My meal was so very yummy!! This restaurant is clean and the staff is super polite!!. I will return again and I WILL be taking food home across the state border.”

Options

take-out
delivery
3.3Good138 Reviews
Dunkin' 190 NJ-23, Wantage Coffee Shops • $
190 NJ-23, Wantage

“I got to this Dunkin on a daily basis and I have to say how helpful. courteous and nice all of the employees are. Again, I go there every morning and I look forward to the experience!They make me fresh decaf and serve it with a smile. Great coffee, great people, great service.”

Options

take-out
drive-through
2.3Poor147 Reviews
map Map