PF Seafood Market & Restaurant

A totally dependable restaurant for good fish & friendly servers. There's a varied menu and they now offer New Jersey wine as an option. The lack of atmosphere is balanced by the good food.

Dinner choices were great, I was only sorry to not order the soft shell crabs which were on special that night! What we did chose was cooked to perfection , the stuffed flounder for me and a pasta dish with scallops & shrimp for my hubby, we thoroughly enjoyed them. It was our 1st dining experience here, and will definitely be back; but we were already familiar with the Seafood Market that they have since we've purchased fresh fish during Lent which was totally great!

The meals were excellent. I had the lobster ravioli topped with shrimp. Wow! My wife had the sauteed softshell crabs. The waiter, Cole, was delightful. We'll be back!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

My husband and I love this place as it is our go-to when we are craving for good and fresh seafood. It is really one of the best around and I am not sure why this place is not more busy (except for the weekends) but that's ok because then we don't have too much of a hard time geting a table. The service is also always excellent. Their portions are also big---try the Seafood Fra Diavolo. This is definitely an awesome seafood restaurant!

The appetizers and our entrees were all well prepared with absolute perfection and all the ingredients were fresh and delicious! I without hesitation would make that long drive again to this fine establishment!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great prices for quality product

We absolutely LOVE PF Seafood!! We've been customers since 2025 and have never been disappointed! They offer a dine-in option plus a large array of seafood to prepare at home. When we want to eat at home, I typically buy PEI oysters, little neck clams, COLOSSAL crab meat in 1 pound cans and shelled lobster meat, which is delicious! When dining, I always intend to try a different dish, but I can't resist the seafood boil. Sooo excellent!! The owner(s) are very gracious, attentive and sincere. Also, they offer a wine option: BYO or purchase from the restaurant.
So, if you are a seafood lover, either to dine-in or to prepare at home, PF is THE place! ENJOY!
Ray

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is a jewel for Western Essex County. Freshest fish, risotto with mushrooms ,oooh so good. The menu has so many fresh fish and other entrees to round things out. Service is excellent with a local flare, friendly, have to try it.

Nice little restaurant. Food was good but not as good as I expected for the prices. Wine is only by the bottle. Nothing on the website about that.

We're repeat dinners at PF Market. Great fish menu. Always fresh. Service is great. We ate upstairs which was nice.

They added new items to their menu, all of which really look amazing. I know I can count on their meals being tasty, so seeing at least 10 new choices made me excited for coming back.

PF Market is a good restaurant for the price; the service is fine, the ambiance is fine....nothing special. The food was ok...Chilean sea bass excellent, cod and stuffed flounder very good. Shrimp parmigiana overcooked but still fine. Not 5 star but perfectly fine meal.

Service was very friendly. Ambience was nice - tablecloths and lines napkins. Food delicious. Love the PF Market salad and the pistachio crusted halibut.

This place is the best. Fresh and delicious. I've been coming here for years and it never disappoints. Highly recommend.

We ordered the grilled swordfish, but instead were given the swordfish coated with panko .