PF Seafood Market & Restaurant

1090 Bloomfield Ave, West Caldwell
(973) 227-1007

Recent Reviews

Carl Oliveira

Grilled Octopus appetizer was great and the Stuffed Flounder entree was fresh and flavorful. Service was great considering every table was allocated and the place was busy. Would definitely dine again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Flounder Filet

Matthew Barrett

Lobster roll was a hot dog bun with shredded lettuce and lobster dip.not cool at all I paid 23$ for that

Renee Faibis

My wife and I had dinner at this restaurant in the past, but not since it was sold to the new owner. The food in the past was mediocre so we thought the new owner will improve the menu. We went to OpenTable to make a reservation and on a Friday evening was lots of availability, that should have been a red flag. When we arrived at the restaurant and passed by the window and saw the place almost empty, red flag number 2. We ordered a bowl of lobster bisque, a Greek salad, and two grilled seafood combo. The salad was small enough to fit in half a cup. When I told the waiter the size of the salad is a joke he told me that by accident he placed the order for a small salad and replaced with a normal appetizer size. The lobster bisque was average. The seafood combo had 6 medium size shrimps, 3 small scallops and a small filet of flounder, rice and broccoli. When the plate arrived it did smell fishy and by the time we got home, we were nauseous and needed ginger ale to the rescue. I hope the owner improves the quality of food before is to late.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Lauri

Wonderful fresh seafood-love sitting upstairs with all the window lighting... Sea Bass was wonderful with fresh veggies & rice- The desserts are well worth saving room for! Highly recommend PF Market

gotogeezers

Our resevvation was early so we enjoyed the ambience,music and impeccable service. We are recurring customers, The seafood was well prepared and mostly excellent. The Tuesday oyster special was awesome. Order 6 and get 6 is an amazing offer. The Western oysters were fresh and sweet. So tempting to order another another 6! The lobster bisque was delicious and had morsels of lobster in it. My crabcake did not have lump crab meat but still very full of crab with less fillers. The broiled octopus was superb and tender if just a tad over seasoned. Loved it and the accompnied potatoes were delicious. My husband's scallop dinner was theroughly enjoyed.

Tina Marinaccio

Excellent every time from service to food to finish. We shared seafood salad, I had halibut, he had shrimp franchise plus shared long hot peppers. We have tried many other menu items. Raw bar is phenomenal. And they have a fish market too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeanette Viruet

Soooo good! We had the jumbo scallops and short ribs !Topped off with the amazing pistachio gelato!delectable Valentine’s Day !

Carl O.

Service was prompt and courteous, food presentation was excellent, and flavorful. We were both very happy with the specials we decided on. Entrees were colorful and fullfilingl, and it was all well put together and fresh. Compliments to the Chef and Staff.

Luv2eat

This was always our go to place for seafood where the fish is always fresh and delicious. The portions were really nice on the salads and the calamari was delicious as was the crab cake. However the presentation on our main dishes was not up to what we expect from PF Market. I had the coconut crusted halibut. I was disappointed that the halibut was breaded but not one bit of coconut flavor could be found. It came with butternut squash. The squash was diced and I think mixed with carrot but I could not tell. It turned brown and the halibut was thrown on top with 3 asparagus spears. You would have thought the chef would have pureed the squash to make it more appealing. My husband did not enjoy his fished stuffed with crab meat. The presentation was not very appetizing. They took a scoop of rice and simply threw it on the plate. Very disappointed this time.

DebbieM

Friday, 2/2/24 was my husband's birthday and there was nowhere else he wanted to go but back to PF Seafood for the third time in about 6 months. We absolutely love this place. We started with the apple pecan salad, our favorite. He had the Swordfish Milanese which he loves and I had the special Chilean sea bass over couscous with a lemon garlic sauce which was amazing. We finished with cappuccinos and the apple berry crisp with vanilla ice cream. We were again fully satisfied and loved everything. If you are looking for fresh seafood prepared perfectly, try PF Seafood. We will be back again and again that is for sure.

Gabriele Buccella

Perfect!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joseph Palumbo

New owner food just as good as in the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kurt Edmond

Stuffed Salmon was great!Decor and attentiveness of waiter could be better, but I’ll definitely be

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Angela Liu

We had a company holiday dinner at the restaurant (upstairs private party room). It was perfect! Emad and his team did a great job from the decoration to the service. The food was fantastic!!! which was the reason that I chose to host the dinner party there to begin with. It was not disappointed. Well do it again next year!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jyotsna Patel

Had our corporate Holiday party held there on Friday, 12/8/23, the food, Service and the atmosphere was excellent. Emad was very accommodating, I am a vegetarian, he made a special Veg Risotto for me. Had a fantastic time. Would greatly recommend!Vegetarian options: Vegetable Risotto, and Vegetarian Pesto pasta.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Calamari, Lobster Bisque

Load More