Pop's Bagelry
1943 Union Valley Rd, West Milford
(973) 506-4870
Customers' Favorites
Bagel w Flavored Cream Cheese
Cinco De Mayo Sandwich
Linzer Tart Cookie
Chicken Sandwich
Classic Italian
Egg and Cheese
Avocado Toast
Breakfast Meat
Hot Cross Bun
Mozz Sticks
Bagel
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese
A simple yet satisfying dish featuring a bagel paired with plain cream cheese.
Bagel with Sliced Lox & Cream Cheese
Enjoy a bagel topped with sliced lox and a spread of cream cheese.
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese
A delightful bagel served with a spread of flavored cream cheese.
Baker's Dozen
A selection of thirteen assorted bagels.
Bagel with Sliced Lox, Capers & Tomatoes
Savor a bagel topped with sliced lox, capers, and tomatoes.
Bagel with Butter
This dish features a bagel served with a spread of butter.
Bagel Plain
This plain bagel is a simple yet satisfying option for any time of the day.
Bagel with Nova Salmon Cream Cheese
This dish features a bagel topped with nova salmon and cream cheese.
Breakfast Sandwich
TEC Sandwich
BEC Sandwich
TC Sandwich
SEC Sandwich
TE Sandwich
BC Sandwich
Just Meat Sandwich
HEC Sandwich
Egg Cheese Sandwich
BE Sandwich
HC Sandwich
HE Sandwich
SC Sandwich
SE Sandwich
Specialty Breakfast Sandwiches
The Potatonator Sandwich
Potatonator 2 eggs, hash brown, cheese, and a choice of breakfast meat.
Classic Breakfast Sandwich
This sandwich features eggs, bacon, and cheese served on a toasted bagel.
Healthy Clean Start Sandwich
3 egg whites with broccoli, spinach, onions, and tomatoes.
The Vermont Sandwich
2 eggs, bacon, cheddar cheese, peppers, onions, and topped with hints of Vermont's maple syrup.
St Pete's Sandwich
3 egg whites, fresh turkey, avocado, and choice of cheese.
Avocado Toast Sandwich
2 eggs, bacon, arugula, balsamic glaze, and fresh mozzarella on your choice of bread.
The Pop's Sandwich
This dish features a delightful combination of bagel, eggs, bacon, and cheese.
The Farmhouse Sandwich
Grilled chicken or roasted turkey breast with scrambled eggs, sliced avocado, arugula, pepper jack cheese, and chipotle mayo.
The Swiss Bliss Sandwich
2 eggs with sautéed portabella mushrooms, onions, and Swiss cheese.
Avocado Bagel Sandwich
This dish features a bagel topped with ripe and creamy avocado.
Omelets
BYO Omelet
Craft your omelet with a variety of ingredients to choose from.
Western Omelet
Served with ham, peppers, onions, and cheese.
Veggie Omelet
With tomatoes, onions, broccoli, peppers, mushrooms, and cheese.
3 Cheese Omelet
This omelet is made with a generous amount of cheese.
Breakfast
Pancakes
These pancakes are made with a simple batter of eggs, milk, and flour.
French Toast
Savor our French toast, made with quality bread soaked in a rich egg mixture.
Egg Platter
Egg platter with choice of breakfast meat with 2 hash browns and toast.
Corn Beef Hash Pl
This dish features a hearty combination of corned beef and hash.
Waffle
This dish features a perfectly cooked waffle and is ideal for a satisfying breakfast.
Silver Dollar Pancakes
Yogurt Parfait
This dish features a delightful combination of yogurt, granola, and mixed berries.
Deli Sandwiches
Turkey Breast Deli Sandwich
This sandwich features succulent turkey breast layered between soft bagel slices.
Roast Beef Deli Sandwich
This deli sandwich features succulent roast beef layered with a soft bagel slice.
Cheese Sandwich
Ham Deli Sandwich
This sandwich features premium ham served between freshly baked bagels.
Bologna Deli Sandwich
This sandwich features bologna layered between slices of bread.
Corned Beef Deli Sandwich
This sandwich features hearty corned beef layered between slices of bread.
Liverwurst Sandwich
A savory combination of liverwurst spread layered between slices of bread.
Salami Deli Sandwich
Experience a delightful combination of salami layered between soft, fluffy bagels.
Pastrami Deli Sandwich
This dish features a hearty serving of pastrami layered between slices of bread.
Cold Sandwiches
Classic Italian Sandwich
Ham, salami or capicola, provolone, oil, and vinegar.
Chicken Salad Sandwich
This sandwich features tender chicken and crisp salad served on a soft bagel.
NJ Sloppy Joe Sandwich
Roast beef, turkey, and coleslaw on rye.
Tuna Salad Sandwich
This sandwich features a hearty serving of tuna salad nestled between slices of bread.
Gobbler Sandwich
Turkey, provolone, and cranberry sauce.
Egg Salad Sandwich
This sandwich features a hearty serving of egg salad between two slices of bread.
Hot Sandwiches
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
Served on a sub with peppers, onions, and mushrooms.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Fried chicken cutlet in buffalo sauce with avocado, onion, blue cheese, or ranch.
Eggplant Sub (Chix Parm) Sandwich
This dish features a hearty combination of chicken, Parmesan, and eggplant in a sub.
Reuben Sandwich
This Reuben sandwich features corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
A warm sandwich filled with melted cheese.
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich
Served on a sub with peppers, onions, and mushrooms.
Cinco De Mayo Sandwich
This sandwich features a delightful combination of avocado, turkey, and Monterey jack cheese.
Grilled Cheese Bac/Tom Sandwich
This dish features a delightful combination of grilled cheese and bacon.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Lettuce and tomato with honey mustard or mayo.
Holy Cow Sandwich
This sandwich features premium beef, melted cheese, and a perfectly toasted bagel.
Irish Sandwich
This Irish sandwich features a hearty combination of corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese.
Little Italy Sandwich
This sandwich features a delightful combination of salami, provolone cheese, and bell peppers.
Naples Sandwich
This Naples sandwich is a delightful combination of premium ham, melted cheese, and ripe tomatoes.
Skinny Sandwich
This skinny sandwich features a selection of premium meats and cheeses layered on a warm bagel.
The Houston Sandwich
This Houston sandwich features a delightful combination of premium ham, melted cheese, and a perfectly toasted bagel.
The Texan Sandwich
This Texan sandwich features a hearty combination of bacon, egg, and cheddar cheese.
The Ty Sandwich
This dish features a delightful combination of bagel, eggs, cheese, and bacon.
Tst Monte Cristo Sandwich
This sandwich features a delightful combination of ham, turkey, and melted cheese.
Turkey Club Sandwich
Greenwood Sandwich
This greenwood sandwich features a delightful combination of eggs, cheese, and bacon.
Salads
Garden Salad
Garden salad.
Baja Chix Salad
This salad features chicken, mixed greens, and a tangy baja dressing.
Caesar Salad
This Caesar salad is composed of crisp romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, and croutons.
Cobb Salad
Served with grilled chicken, avocado, bacon, egg, blue cheese, tomato, cucumber, and corn.
Greek Salad
Served with grilled chicken, stuffed grape leaves, feta cheese, olives, cucumbers, tomatoes, and oregano.
Waldorf Salad
Served with grilled chicken, apples, celery, candied walnuts, blue cheese over spring mix, and romaine with homemade balsamic.
Pop's Salad
Grilled chicken, fried goat cheese, strawberries, candied walnuts, carrots, cucumbers, and tomatoes over mixed greens with homemade creamy balsamic.
Sides
Hash Brown
A crispy and golden brown potato delight.
Mozz Sticks
These mozzarella sticks are a delightful and cheesy treat.
Corned Beef Hash
This dish features corned beef combined with diced potatoes.
French Fries
Savor the crispy delight of our golden-brown french fries.
Onion Rings
A crispy delight featuring golden-fried onions.
Breakfast Meat
A selection of breakfast meats to complement your meal.
Grilled Chicken
This dish features succulent chicken and is expertly grilled to perfection.
Toast
A simple yet satisfying dish featuring lightly toasted bread.
Specialty Drinks
Almond Joy Latte
This latte features a delightful blend of almond and joy flavors.
Latte
A warm beverage made from espresso and steamed milk.
Wt Choc Rasp Latte
This latte features white chocolate and raspberry for a delightful blend.
Cafe Macchiato
This cafe macchiato is a delightful blend of rich espresso and frothy milk.
PB Latte
A delightful blend of premium espresso and steamed milk topped with a hint of peanut butter.
Cappuccino
A warm blend of espresso and frothy milk topped with a dusting of cocoa.
Cafe Mocha
A delightful blend of rich coffee and smooth chocolate.
Flavored Tea
A specialty beverage featuring a blend of high-quality tea leaves.
Fresh Brewed Coffee
Savor the rich taste of our meticulously brewed coffee.
Americano
A robust blend of espresso and hot water, perfect for a morning pick-me-up.
Black Zing
Freshly brewed coffee with a double shot of espresso.
Espresso Shot
A robust serving of espresso, perfect for a quick caffeine boost.
Tea
A simple, warm beverage made from steeped tea leaves.
Iced Drinks
Iced Latte
This iced latte is a chilled blend of espresso and milk.
Iced Coffee
A chilled beverage featuring robust coffee served over ice.
Iced Matcha Latte
This iced beverage features a blend of matcha and creamy latte.
Iced Tea
A chilled beverage made from steeped tea leaves served over ice.
Iced Black Zing
This iced beverage features a robust black tea with a hint of zing.
Bottle Drinks
Nesquik
A bottled Nesquik drink, perfect for a quick and convenient refreshment.
Gatorade
A thirst-quenching bottled beverage from Gatorade.
Snapple
A refreshing bottled beverage from Snapple.
Seltzer
A refreshing and carbonated beverage.
Bottled Waters
A simple and hydrating option for your meal.
Soda
A refreshing carbonated beverage to quench your thirst.
Muffins
Chocolate Chip Muffin
A delightful muffin filled with rich chocolate chips.
Banana Nut Muffin
This muffin is a delightful blend of ripe bananas and crunchy nuts.
Corn Muffin
This corn muffin is a simple yet satisfying breakfast treat.
Pumpkin Muffin
This pumpkin muffin is a delightful blend of sweet pumpkin and aromatic spices.
Raisin Bran Muffin
A hearty muffin filled with raisins and bran for a satisfying breakfast.
Desserts
Chocolate Chunk Cookie
This dessert features chunks of rich chocolate embedded in a crisp cookie.
Linzer Tart Cookie
This linzer tart cookie is a sweet treat featuring a jam-filled center.
Crumb Cakes
This dessert features a delightful blend of sweet crumbs and soft cake.
Peanut Butter Cookie
It is a delightful treat made with rich peanut butter baked to perfection.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
This oatmeal raisin cookie is a sweet treat featuring hearty oats and juicy raisins.
Pond Cakes
A delightful dessert featuring sweet and fluffy cakes.
Sprinkle Cookie
This dessert features a delightful cookie adorned with colorful sprinkles.
Smoothies
Berry Blast Smoothie
Raspberries, blueberries, strawberries, apples, and honey.
Strawberry Banana Smoothie
Banana, apple, and strawberry juice.
Honeysuckle Smoothie
This smoothie is a delightful blend of honey and suckle.
Tropical Peach Smoothie
Peach, mango nectar, and pineapple.
B's Choice Smoothie
Blueberries, raspberries, bananas, apple juice, and honey.
Mango Bliss Smoothie
Mango, banana, apple, and pineapple juice.
Temptation Smoothie
Mango nectar, banana, strawberries, and raspberries.
Fresh Juice 16 Oz
Detox Juice (16 oz)
Apple, carrot, lemon, and ginger
Beat BP Supreme Juice (16 oz)
Beets, grapefruit, lemon, and ginger.
Green Glow Juice (16 oz)
This refreshing juice is a blend of kale, cucumber, apple, and lemon.
Green Supreme Juice (16 oz)
Kale, spinach, green apple, romaine, cucumber, celery, ginger, and turmeric.
Immune Boost Juice (16 oz)
Orange, carrot, and turmeric.
Morning Energy Juice (16 oz)
Carrot, orange, pineapple, green apple, and lemon.
Beach Fuel Juice (16 oz)
Pineapple, ginger, lime, and coconut water.
Bowls
Hella Nutella Bowl
Served with Nutella, granola, strawberries, bananas, and coconut.
Lakeshore Bowl
With blueberries, banana, granola, and coconut flakes.
Protein Power Bowl
This bowl features a hearty mix of proteins including eggs, turkey, and quinoa.
Crepes
Blueberry Dream Crepes
This dish features crepes filled with luscious blueberries.
Mixed Berry Crepes
This dish features a delightful combination of mixed berries enveloped in soft crepes.
Nutella Banana Crepes
A delightful combination of Nutella and banana wrapped in a delicate crepe.
Savory Crepe
Served with scrambled eggs, Taylor ham, and cheese.
Burgers
Cheeseburger
Served with lettuce, tomato, coleslaw, and pickle chips.
Pops Burger
Cheeseburger topped with Taylor ham and egg.
Hamburger
Served with lettuce, tomato, coleslaw, and pickle chips.
Milkshakes
Strawberry Milkshake
This milkshake is a delightful blend of ripe strawberries and creamy milk.
Photos
+17 photos
+16 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Me and my wife love this place. Angela, Dan, Mike, and John are so nice and friendly. The foods always good and the prices are the best. We often get ice coffees and they’re very good ! It’s a hidden gem. Give Pop’s a try, you will be glad you did !
February 2026
I love Pop’s Bagelry! The staff is awesome and very friendly. The food is always delicious! I have had bagels, breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwiches, and it they have always been great! 100% would recommend for any and all food options
December 2025
Food was good. I got the cinco de mayo- was my own fault but I was upset that it was on a round roll and not a sub roll I had no idea
So for everyone who wants to know what it looks like here’s a picture-
Someone said here how huge it was for $15 but I just think it’s normal- but the Italian sub was packed and a good size!
This pic shows half
So for everyone who wants to know what it looks like here’s a picture-
Someone said here how huge it was for $15 but I just think it’s normal- but the Italian sub was packed and a good size!
This pic shows half
September 2025
You May Also Like
DeMarco's Pizzeria & Restaurant - 1926 Union Valley Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
Mr.Wonton - 1926 Union Valley Rd
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian