TJ's Pizza Cafe
18 Marshall Hill Rd, West Milford
(973) 728-2228
Customers' Favorites
Soup of the Day
Piece of Pie
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I used to go across the street to Franks, however Franks quality has declined and their prices are outrageous. Decided to try TJ's about a month ago and have been hooked ever Since! Friendly staff, fair prices, and top notch pizza! I find the pizza to be a perfect ratio of Sauce, cheese and crust. Never under or over cooked, just consistent perfection. Chicken bacon ranch is phenomenal!
Found this gem of a place over covid 2020 shut down ... and to this this day they are just amazing .... this eggplant spinach panini is my go to after 3 years!!! Love this place and the staff is awesome ❤️
Excellent food. Pizza is crispy with a not too thick crust, filled with flavor. Pepperoni nice and robust. And I CHALLENGE you to find a better House, or Anti-pasta, Salad. Buffalo chicken bites are crispy and taste like the original Buffalo NY sauce. Italian Hoagie almost as good as Bellvale Market. True gem. Recommend take out. Not much room to dine in.
You May Also Like
Mario's Deli - 10 Marshall Hill Rd
![]()
Deli, Bagels
Frank's Pizza (West Milford) - 31 Marshall Hill Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian