Restaurants in West Milford

“It was pretty quiet inside but my son was welcomed which goes miles for me. The server was a young boy who had asked a billion questions to make my son comfortable which is great! Everyone walked away very happy the food was delicious. It was toddler approved so that is a win!”

“Amazing place owned and operated by a great hard working people, keeping the American Dream alive. I saw High Strung Band there again at their 8 year Anniversary Party. The band was great as usual, and the food was awesome and abundant. It is a very warm and welcoming place. I highly recommend it. ❤️??❤️??”

“Update: After a huge investment in renovation, they are re-open! Check out the HUGE new bar, outside deck, and 2nd parking lot behind the restaurant. Same amazing food, same suppliers, same recopies, same friendly staff.Feels like a traditional British pub in West Milford. Great diversity of food/amazing specials - and a great "core" menu. The quality of their meats is amazing, and they have the tenderest steak sandwich I have ever had! Worth the trip, just for their Seafood Bisque. If they have it as a special, I'M THERE!”

“This is a very small pizza and Italian restaurant which seems to primarily cater to takeout. Out of towners dining in, the service was terrific and accommodating. The mozzarella sticks were perfectly crispy. Baked Ziti was cheesey and served ”

“Found this gem of a place over covid 2020 shut down ... and to this this day they are just amazing .... this eggplant spinach panini is my go to after 3 years!!! Love this place and the staff is awesome ❤️”

“I aint eva had angel hair pasta like this with marinara and the delectable choice of herbs they use and garlic and cheeses. The side salads are bangin and come with garlic knots I honestly think this is the best angel hair I've ever had in my entire life! The garlic cheesy bread is sooooo good! That angel hair ? sent me to heaven.”

“Legit luncheonette food. Hot dogs, onion rings, salads, milkshakes, Philly cheesesteak etc. Service is friendly and welcoming. Ambiance deserves a green check too.”

“My first time here, and all i can say is that this establishment is amazing. The staff, the food, and the ambience is top-notch. This place was recommended by a friend of mine and we decided to throw my husband's 50th birthday surprise dinner. We had 20 guests and Sat at one long table. The whole restaurant was in on the surprise. They all clapped and whistled when my husband walked in. So sweet! It was such a fun filled evening with great food and friends. Everyone loved their meal. I can recommend the corn beef, chicken fajitas, steak Cobb salad, shrimp scampi and the sangria was on point! They even let me bring in my own cake. Can't wait to go back!”

“Ended up at DeMarco’s after a hiccup with the bus schedule back to NY. The stuffed calzone and spinach and cheese slice was so delicious. Quality ingredients and crust with just the right amount of chewiness. Great people running the place, let us hang out past closing while we sorted out our transportation. So glad we stumbled upon this authentic Italian spot. Great to see a family owned restaurant serving hot honest food.”

“This is my favorite pizza in North Jersey and possibly all of NJ. The dough and crust is just perfect. Highly recommend ordering a whole pepperoni pie. Haven't tried individual slices, but a fresh pie will not ”

“Thank you, Mike, once again for the delicious pizza and for being so accommodating to use my vegan “cheese”! My birthday dinner was fantastic!Dietary restrictions: It’s great to have a local pizzeria who will not only happily use my vegan “cheese” but thoughtfully uses a clean cutter for my vegan pizza too!”

“We had nine adults for Easter. We all Enjoyed our apps and meals. No one had anything negative to say. Staff and owner were friendly and welcoming. There was nice spacing between tables and it wasn't too loud.”

“This was hands down the best bagels I’ve ever had in New Jersey, crunchy outsides and soft and fluffy innards, not only was it the best most well made scallion cream cheese ive ever had but I also bought a breakfast sandwich after that and may I say, they don’t skimp on the meat OR the quality!!!! The staff was extremely welcoming and I felt a happy sensation being in the building… ten out of ten I don’t know how to explain it further…… GO TO THIS BAGEL SPOT RIGHT NOW”

“Highlander has careful employees who consistently watch the wonderful layered sandwiches and make sure that the old fashioned system they use and idolize their customers who are using excellent bread and first class processes to continue their wonderful, but ancient, "true to form topped with fresh cut today vegetables" with authentic meats and salads.”

“Good spot to go in a get a good slice of pizza or some garlic knots. Friendly service and food was ready fast. ( even though place was busy). Would definitely stop in again if in the area and need a quick bite to eat.”