46 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Milford

“Used my gift certificate I got from WM Beautification clean up day at Macopin Pizza! Ordered a sausage, peppers, & onion personal pie and got a free pepperoni spinner! Both were delicious! Owner is so sweet and friendly! Will definitely support another small business as often as we can!“

“Love the service.. Pizza/food is made exactly how we like it. Perfection“

“Ordered two cheese pies yesterday. Well done. It was the best pizza I’ve had since moving up here. Crust was thin and crispy. Can’t wait to do it again.“

“1st timer. I gotta say - good crust. I’ll be back next time I’m passing by.“

“We love them! Just had the best Mediterranean salad with calamari, stromboli, hot antipasto, pasta carbonara, accompanying awesome rolls. And have dinner for tomorrow!“

“1/2 Burger with onions, mushrooms, tomatoe, bacon and mozzarella cheese was mouth watering delicious. Best burger in town.“

“Great service, friendly atmosphere, and delicious food. What more could you want?

Kid-friendliness: Pretty good. The only thing that is somewhat troubling is the seating. We usually need a table for our elderly members and they are limited. Booths are not comfortable for us.“

“Great menu! I had one of the best salads I've ever had here! Friendly, fast, and delicious! Highly Recommended!“

“I stopped into Danny's Pizza early in the day, shortly after they opened. I saw a sign outside that said they were voted #1 best pizza which I'm usually skeptical about. After having a slice though, I was pleasantly surprised. The pizza had a thin, crispy base with an incredibly flavorful sauce. The sauce to cheese ratio was spot on and the cheese was perfectly fresh and melted to perfection. Even the crust was bready and delicious. I'm definitely a fan.“

“Just stopped in/didn’t realize owners changed. They were super accommodating g while under construction. Grab a small marg pie w grilled chicken and it was really good.“

“Just had dinner at Skyline Pizzeria and I had the best creamy chicken soup, and the best chicken franchise!!“

“Was in town for work last night. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza. Best pizza I had in a long time. Super fast delivery. Friendly delivery guy. Came with plates and napkins too! When back in the area, I’ll hit y’all up again.“

“On the first chilly fall night we enjoyed excellent escarole and bean soup as well as black bean and prosciutto soup! We followed those huge bowls (which were so large we each took half home) with the best salad slice of pizza BAR NONE ANYWHERE, and delicious Eggplant Rollatini.

Frank’s isn’t just pizza but delicious Italian food as well. Angelo is a lovely and generous guy. Our only negative is that the bathrooms could surely use updating and improvement.“

“Grabbed a takeaway from here a few weeks back. So welcoming, I spoke with the owner for a while - an incredibly warm and charming fellow. The young lady serving was very polite and helpful. Pizza was huge, reasonably priced and for me, delicious. Don't think you can go wrong.“

“We had our daughter’s bridal shower here this past weekend…cannot say enough good things about the food service and total atmosphere..all of our guests loved the food the staff was fantastic and so very accommodating. They worked with us regarding the room set up and the several changes we needed to make. I highly recommend this restaurant.“

“just ordered a cheese pie, to go, and it is DELISH!!“

“I love Ferati’s - The food is delicious, service is great, they are very accommodating shud I request a little change in Preparation.“

“A saying Margherita Pizza is the best judge of how good a pizza place will be. Skyline Pizzeria has best Margherita Pizza ever! lots of basil toppings with thick and fresh mozzarella cheese and much more ingredients spring all over! I recommend you won’t be disappointed.“

“Excellent Italian food. They know what it should be.“

“while visiting our daughter near Oak Ridge, I called and placed a take out for my wife , myself, daughter and 3 grandkids. I had the Chicken Parm dinner and my wife had a large Arugula salad. My 2 pieces of chicken were tender and delicious along with choice of pasta and fresh bread. My wife said the salad was excellent; very tasty and delicious. We will stop in again on future trips!“

“Attended a baby shower. The food was the best I have ever had in a long time. Everything was delicious. I will be back really soon“

“The Pizza is Fantastic. My 10 yr old was having a blah day. He said the only thing that could fix it was pizza. It had to be in Pompton Lakes and it had to be Nicky G's. We had 2 slices each (which is a lot for him), a Yoohoo for him and a Nicky G's Vanilla soda for me. It was definitely worth the cost, which wasn't expensive at all.“

“we're new to the area and took a shot. It was the best decision and best pizza I've had. thin crust Sicilian...fantastic!“

“Very friendly staff. Food was great. Nice ambiance. Highly recommend.“

“I slept on this place for 4 years. I moved to the area 4 years ago and I never gave it a shot. I went every where else in the area including another place called Tjs. Recently one of my colleagues ordered a Pie from TJs. I was skeptical. I was wrong. It was fantastic. The sauce on the pie is something in itself different. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for pizza in the North Morris County/West Milford area.“

“Awesome food, great atmosphere, and outstanding waitress(Rose). Had the best mussels ever.“

“If you want a slice of pepperoni, they take a plain slice, apply pepperoni pieces on top, then heat it until the pepperoni is melted into the cheese. Definitely one of the outstanding slices in the area. Nice, old fashioned Baker's Pride oven, too. Not many of them left.

Parking: A difficult left turn off 511, particularly during lunchtime, but there seems to be enough parking , just.“

“We were visiting our son on the Appalachian Trail and stopped by for 6 different pizzas to bring to him and his fellow hikers on the trail. All were absolutely delicious! We were happy and so were the hikers!“

“Best customer service around plus everything on the extensive menu is delicious and large portions. Something for everyone and always open.“

“Six people came to eat on Thanksgiving, and it was delicious! The kitchen made the noodles and sauce by hand, and it was very tasty and special!

Chinese people don’t lie to Chinese people, Italian food is the most suitable for Chinese babies’ stomachs!“

“Coney Island mobile pizza truck came to our son's 1st birthday party and they were fantastic! Throughout the planning process, Robert always made us feel comfortable by assuring us they would be there to help rain or shine! Robert and his guys were great to our guests, ensuring everyone had what they wanted. They even gave us so many pies left over that we could enjoy throughout the rest of the day/evening. We cannot wait to work with them again for future parties and would highly suggest them to anyone looking for a unique, fun party idea!“

“todo lo que se vende aquí se prepara a la orden del dia“

“Employees are all very friendly. Food is delicious.“

“I can’t rave enough about Gene and the gang at Frank’s Pizza. Our son was in a play at StageWorks 237 on Hamburg Turnpike. We don’t know the area well but I was looking, last minute (Thurs 11/3, the first night of the show) for somewhere to have a cast party for 19 kids and at least one chaperone per kid on Sat 11/5 after the show. I thought it would be easy to find a pizza place because where we live most places are open on Saturdays until at least 10-11p Finding an appropriate place was proving to be very difficult because apparently most places in Pompton Lakes close by 8:30p, even on Saturday. I asked the pizza place closest to the theater, which shall remain nameless, but they not-so-nicely turned me away, even though I was going to guarantee them 30-40 people. I kept googling and found Frank’s, just a minute down the road. I was nervous to ask because of how I was treated at the other place but I cautiously asked Gene if they could host our party. He enthusiastically agreed. What made this even nicer is that they actually close at 8:30p but would stay open for us - which meant that we had the whole place to ourselves! We started trickling in about 8:50p. Approximately 40 people. Gene had a full staff - two wonderful servers who graciously dealt with our chaos and like four guys dealing with the counter orders. There was more than enough food, everything was delicious, and they couldn’t have been nicer. If we do any other plays at StageWorks or Rhino theaters, Frank’s will be our only choice for our cast party. It was so amazing for the kids to have closure on their play in such a great space. It’s large, clean, and the servers are fantastic. I don’t know if they normally do parties but if you’re thinking of having a large gathering in this area, this is the place to do it. The kids appreciated it so much! Thank you Gene and staff!“

“Taco Tuesday is real real tasty , I love the pork and the shrimp tacos. the burgers are delicious , they cook them just the way you like them , onion rings yum yum , Thursdays is prime rib night … cooked to perfection, different sides to choose from , I always get the baked potatoe and the salad it comes with … is real good also , ya gotta try it. Oh I forgot Greg is a great bartender.“

“Cubsaw Market is out standing the food is great the owner is awesome Sam. We meet in morning for coffee. Is it is just a great place to see good friends and people“

“Delicious food and the pizza is out of this world. The people are really nice. I love coming here.“

“I DON'T RECOMMEND DOMINO'S PIZZA, I STATED THAT BEFORE I EVEN STARTED MY REVIEW. IT APPEARS THAT FACEBOOK REMOVED THE WORD "DON'T" FROM MY REVIEW AND REPLACED IT WITH A RED EMOJI WITH A WHITE STAR INSIDE IT. FACEBOOK CAN BE BOUGHT. IF YOU PAY THEM ENOUGH MONEY, THEY WILL EDIT CUSTOMER REVIEWS AND LIE TO YOU INSTEAD, MAKING THE TOP PAYING BUSINESSES LOOK GOOD. DO NOT TRUST FACEBOOK, THEY LITERALLY CHANGED MY REVIEW, WICH CAUSED ME TO EDIT IT AND TELL YOU THE TRUTH. Domino's Pizza isn't real pizza, however, I crave it three or four times a year. This location at 94 Wanaque Ave. in Pompton Lakes is the perhaps the worst location that I've ever ordered from. Both times that I've ordered were both wrong, and today, my pizza is ony 15 minutes old and it's already dried out. That's definitely a Domino's Pizza problem, not location, because the doe and every single ingredient are made at a central location in the middle of America, then distributed throughout the country, that way it tastes exactly the same in NYC or LA. They've changed a lot of ingredients in their Pizza, I can taste the difference from only six months ago. Domino's has become Burger King and McDonald's, I don't crave it anymore, I only order real pizza here on out.“

“Great food friendly staff“

“Thank you. I moved to a cabin in west Milford and had no idea they would actually deliver to my door. They exceeded my expectations. I was met with the friendliest Asian man with the biggest and most beautiful smile. My order was beyond perfect too. I came from south Jersey. Our dominoes down there was not good. I ordered regularly but this is the food I was looking for. Great customer service. Great delivery crew and great food. My wings were fully coated too and I actually got my 2 blue cheeses. If you live remote they got you. I am so shocked. Thank you to the team here. You guys are doing a great job. Dominoes better pay y’all at least an extra dollar per hour.“

“My favorite pizzeria in Warwick. I’ve been eating their pizza since I was a kid, going on 30 years! The staff is very friendly, the prices are reasonable, and the food tastes great (awesome pizza, garlic knots, and wings). I also appreciate the daily and lunch specials that they’ve introduced recently. Some of the deals are unbeatable.“

“We had a wonderful Dinner at Novelli Restaurant in Wayne NJ yesterday celebrating my amazing Wife Karen's birthday. Food,service and ambiance was outstanding !“

“The pies are great! Friendly service!“

“I got the Strawberry salad from here today. It was really good. The staff was really friendly. They treat you like family. I from out of town (Michigan) and felt cozy and comfortable eating there. I hope to go back tomorrow and try the pizza.“

“I can’t say enough about the catering we got yesterday from here! The food was so yummy thr trays were JAM PACKED! The staff was so friendly and hospitable! And the price was right!“

“Great Store! Excellent Service! Ken the owner, Debbie and the rest of the staff always greet you warmly great people all around. Beautiful view of lake from inside! Cute dock outside perfect for sunrise pics! The perfect stop when you don’t want to be bothered going to a supermarket. Love it! Wouldn’t trade them for anything!!“