Nicky G's Pizzeria

$ • Pizza, Salad

Hours today·

About Nicky G's Pizzeria

Nicky G's Pizzeria is a local spot known for solid, tasty pizza and excellent food. The pizza is considered the best around, with a crispy crust, generous toppings, and a nice balance of sauce and cheese, reminiscent of a Brooklyn slice. Dishes are all made to order. Popular items include a well-done cheese pizza, zeppoles described as amazing, and entrees like the eggplant parm. The meatball sandwich is also quite good. Some notes suggest a desire for more sauce on certain items and for pasta to be more al dente. The owner and staff are consistently praised as amazing, nice, honest, and great, with a strong sense of integrity and community contribution. Service is reliable, with on-time delivery and a willingness to customize orders. It is viewed as a great place with great service and great food, making it a regular spot and a local business worth supporting.

Menu

Add a Menu
Nicky G's Pizzeria Menu
Nicky G's Pizzeria Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Nicky G's Pizzeria
Nicky G's Pizzeria
View All Photos

Nicky G's Pizzeria Reviews

4.5
120 ratings
5
96%
1
4%
Food
4.9
Atmosphere
4.5
Service
4.8

Share your opinion about Nicky G's Pizzeria

LOVE IT MUST TRY
GREAT BANTER
The Pizza is Fantastic.

My 10 yr old was having a blah day. He said the only thing that could fix it was pizza. It had to be in Pompton Lakes and it had to be Nicky G's.

We had 2 slices each (which is a lot for him), a Yoohoo for him and a Nicky G's Vanilla soda for me.

It was definitely worth the cost, which wasn't expensive at all.
Food was great! Loved the pizza, garlic knots and chicken vodka sandwich

Read All Reviews(120)

Hours

Monday 11AM - 9PM
Tuesday 11AM - 9PM
Wednesday 11AM - 9PM
Thursday 11AM - 9PM
Friday 11AM - 9PM
Saturday 11AM - 9PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: