I might have had the best vodka chicken Parmesan sandwich ever today. The chicken was tender, the sauce fantastic and the bread second to none. Great job!
I have never had better food from 5 star restaurants. Seriously the absolute best place around. Everything is amazing.
Eileen Kimbell-Meaney
Excellent pizza and meatballs here. I'm sure the rest of their food is just as good! Pizza is perfect, with a nice crisp crust! Meatballs are better than most Italian restaurants around here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fred Hirsch
Always great service and pizza at Nicky G's. My son wanted pizza. He wanted it IN Pompton Lakes. He wanted Nicky G's.Kid-friendliness: Nicky G's does lunch deals for the High School kids since the school is around the corner. They offer their own line of beverages.
I seriously love Nicky Gs pizza! I don't know what it is but something in/with the crust is amazing! It's by far in my top 5 favorite pizza parlors! I have lived in NJ all my life (since I was 6 - 42 years in NJ/NYC) and I work in NYC - 20sh years, so pizza is everywhere! But, I go out of my way to get Nicky G's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristopher Klenotiz
Hands down best pizza in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
George Vanderhoof
The best shrimp parm dinner by far better than your favorite Italian restaurant can't say much about his other dinners his shrimp parm is so good I can't bring myself to order anything else but my girl has been happy with everything she gets
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Delahanty
I ordered a pizza for the first time yesterday and I just want to say it was really delicious!! From the toppings, sauce and what a crispy awesome crust. I will be back.....
Worst Pizza I’ve ever eaten and he overcharged me. For high school kids He was charging them two dollars no tax and when I went to get my pizza he charge me $2.25 plus tax. What’s garbage do not recommend anybody to go there.
Robyn C.
First, we are in the food industry & normally would hate to leave a review but we finally ordered from Nicky G's last Friday night 11/4 & we so wanted to be a fan. My hubby is definitely a pizza connoisseur and we heard from someone the Grandma Pie was supposed to be decent, we definitely should have stuck with our go too. We normally have our staples: Anyhony Franco's & Neil's for Grandma & Donnas for Sicilian. It s hard to explain: cheap cheese, a drizzle of what might have been Pesto ( why) and brunt crust ( THE WHOLE BOTTOM OF THE PIE). Normally we have a slice or 2 each and always freeze the rest, this went right in the garbage. And the cold Antipasto, overall everything was just way off I hope they were just having a bad night, just wish it wasn't on our $$. FYI: my husband is insisting when we first moved here in 2018 he grabbed a slice and it was awesome.....
emma M.
ordered delivery with the slice app, got Buffalo chicken slice and chicken bacon ranch slice. both were normal cheese slices (with marinara sauce) with the other toppings and sauces on top. marinara on a Buffalo chicken and a chicken bacon ranch pizza. no go.
john z.
This is the best pizza in the area. Both the regular pie and the Grandma pie are not only good, they are great. The sandwich and dinner options are also great. Large, tasty portions at reasonable prices, even lower than you might expect. We order from Nicky G's once or twice a week and everything is excellent.
Mary Silvestri
Ordered wraps and spaghetti w/meatballs. Delicious and special directions followed completely. Excellent♥️
Best pizza in town! Quality is always consistent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I might have had the best vodka chicken Parmesan sandwich ever today. The chicken was tender, the sauce fantastic and the bread second to none. Great job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Cheese Pizza
Pizza is soo
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pie, Chicken Parmigiana, Garlic Knots, Sicilian Slice, Antipasto, Cheese Pizza, Wings
I have never had better food from 5 star restaurants. Seriously the absolute best place around. Everything is amazing.
Excellent pizza and meatballs here. I'm sure the rest of their food is just as good! Pizza is perfect, with a nice crisp crust! Meatballs are better than most Italian restaurants around here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always great service and pizza at Nicky G's. My son wanted pizza. He wanted it IN Pompton Lakes. He wanted Nicky G's.Kid-friendliness: Nicky G's does lunch deals for the High School kids since the school is around the corner. They offer their own line of beverages.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Plain Cheese Pizza, Cheese Pizza
I seriously love Nicky Gs pizza! I don't know what it is but something in/with the crust is amazing! It's by far in my top 5 favorite pizza parlors! I have lived in NJ all my life (since I was 6 - 42 years in NJ/NYC) and I work in NYC - 20sh years, so pizza is everywhere! But, I go out of my way to get Nicky G's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down best pizza in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best shrimp parm dinner by far better than your favorite Italian restaurant can't say much about his other dinners his shrimp parm is so good I can't bring myself to order anything else but my girl has been happy with everything she gets
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a pizza for the first time yesterday and I just want to say it was really delicious!! From the toppings, sauce and what a crispy awesome crust. I will be back.....
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Worst Pizza I’ve ever eaten and he overcharged me. For high school kids He was charging them two dollars no tax and when I went to get my pizza he charge me $2.25 plus tax. What’s garbage do not recommend anybody to go there.
First, we are in the food industry & normally would hate to leave a review but we finally ordered from Nicky G's last Friday night 11/4 & we so wanted to be a fan. My hubby is definitely a pizza connoisseur and we heard from someone the Grandma Pie was supposed to be decent, we definitely should have stuck with our go too. We normally have our staples: Anyhony Franco's & Neil's for Grandma & Donnas for Sicilian. It s hard to explain: cheap cheese, a drizzle of what might have been Pesto ( why) and brunt crust ( THE WHOLE BOTTOM OF THE PIE). Normally we have a slice or 2 each and always freeze the rest, this went right in the garbage. And the cold Antipasto, overall everything was just way off I hope they were just having a bad night, just wish it wasn't on our $$. FYI: my husband is insisting when we first moved here in 2018 he grabbed a slice and it was awesome.....
ordered delivery with the slice app, got Buffalo chicken slice and chicken bacon ranch slice. both were normal cheese slices (with marinara sauce) with the other toppings and sauces on top. marinara on a Buffalo chicken and a chicken bacon ranch pizza. no go.
This is the best pizza in the area. Both the regular pie and the Grandma pie are not only good, they are great. The sandwich and dinner options are also great. Large, tasty portions at reasonable prices, even lower than you might expect. We order from Nicky G's once or twice a week and everything is excellent.
Ordered wraps and spaghetti w/meatballs. Delicious and special directions followed completely. Excellent♥️