Starlite Italian Restaurant & Bar

993 Pleasant Valley Way, West Orange
(973) 736-9440

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maisie Davey

Okay seriously the food and view were truly wonderful, a definite must if your in Seattle. The staff here is so amazing and the drinks were right on point. Can't wait to go again!

Eliyahu Kheel

Overseasoned, underbaked (despite asking for it well done), flavorless pale crust....this was one of the weirdest and worst pizzas I've had in the area.

Joanne O'Dea

First night out -- alfresco dining -- after being couped up in the house for three months due to the pandemic. It was sooo nice to eat outdoors, patio style!We ordered two types of Manhattans. Both were mixed well, strong, and delicious. The restaurant put a sampler on the table with an italian pasta salad, to knosh of while we sipped cocktails. A nice surprise and very tasty.For a starter we ordered the mozzarella caprese salad -- pictured here. The dish was well presented, the mozzarella was moist, and flavorful. Set alongside ripe tomatoes and topped with roasted peppers, it was among the best I've had.We paired the mozzarella with their garlic knots. The dish came with a thick Italian sauce, the perfect consistency for dipping. The knots were very tasty and lots of garlic. Mmmmnnnn!! Good!!For our entrees, we ordered a spaghetti with meatballs and a pasta and eggplant parm. I love eggplant and this was the best! The meatballs were also delicious.We chose to have a second drink instead of having dessert -- we were too stuffed to eat anything more!This was a wonderful evening -- everything you would have expected after being in isolation for so long. The only thing, in my opinion, which would have enriched the experience: a little mood music piped in.Glad that Starlite is back! We will definitely return!

Ata Tavaly

The best manicotti!! Also, the house salad dressing is the best!! I wish Patty would bottle it and sell it.

donna kurtzer

Best pizza. Love the sauce, the thin crust and the cheese is perfect. This is what pizza should be.

Donna Sandberg Kurtzer

Best Pizza around. I love Starlite. Food is great too.

Phudit Jirapraphanan

Great pizza, great service. I’ve been coming here for years. The best pizza in west orange!

Jack Dripper

Nice people...Great Pizza Great ingredients ?⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

David Dailey

I eat here a lot since I work in the area. I must say the customer service is always fantastic and they keep the spot well kept consistently. Pricing is convenient and they serve sizeable portions.

David Branson

Great pizza with personable and hospitable staff!!

Jim K

Delicious thin crust 'za, best in town imho.

Tyrone Mitchell

Yummy!! ???

Ferchii Jumper

I am seeing a tv show about rescuing restaurants, is rescued? Or still dirty? hehe greetings from Argentina

Jordan Kooper

The pizza was really good

The Critical J

PROS: When I entered the place it had a nice Italian vibe to it. It had a full bar, a nice size menu, good prices, and the pizza (which is what they're known for) tasted great!

Loading...