Supreme Bakery
40 Main St, West Orange
(973) 736-1732
Customers' Favorites
Triple Chocolate Cake
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Brownie
Black and White
Tres Leches Cake
Chocolate Mousse
S'Mores Cookie
Salted Caramel
Tiramisu Slice
Menu
Photos
+45 photos
+44 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Their version of Tres Leche is so wonderful. We had a group of 15 people and everyone absolutely adored it! So glad I called to see if they make this as it was our guest of honor’s request. Very accommodating on the phone with my 1/4 sheet cake order. Convenient parking too.
Supreme Bakery has served me throughout my lifetime and they did'nt miss this year. I loved the cake and personalized home feel quality. Always a 10 out of 10. PSA: They have the best cannolis on the planet!
I ordered cupcakes from Supreme Bakery for my church’s youth choir annual day celebration. The cupcakes were beautifully decorated, fresh, and absolutely delicious. They added a special touch to the event and were enjoyed by both the youth choir members and all our guests.
The ordering process was easy and when I needed to make changes, the staff was able to accommodate my needs. We received many compliments on the cupcakes and would gladly recommend...
The ordering process was easy and when I needed to make changes, the staff was able to accommodate my needs. We received many compliments on the cupcakes and would gladly recommend...
You May Also Like
Johnny's Pizzeria - 34 Main St
![]()
Italian, Pizza
Subway - 32 Main St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Benji's Taqueria Mexican Grill - 14 Main St #5301
![]()
Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian