This restaurant exceeded my expectations! Everything was perfect. Some of the best food I ate all year… truly amazing & so flavorful. You must order the Trottole pasta dish with the short rib. Absolutely insane flavor. The service was also fantastic, warm, & welcoming! The vibe is hip & trendy. Overall incredible dining experience. Can’t wait to go back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Gray
Had dinner last night, hi-top table of 4 of us. Place is small and cute with funny decor in a good way. servers were friendly and funny and went along with our behavior lol. Expected good food, expensive and leaving hungry (small portions)...gotta say. the food was REALLY REALLY GREAT and we left stuffed. we had mutz/prosiutto app, buffalo app, the truffle foccia, some martinis and dinners we had (2) of the Trottle Pasta which was freakin amazing, chicken caesar milanese which was HUGE and tasty and the chicken/sausage Milanese which was HUGE and so outside the box tasty and unique. dessert we got the rainbow cake sorbet and the butter cake and they were crazy good. If I can get a table again, we will def go back...was really awesome. MG
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan Friedman Gorga
Excellent !!!!
The food was fabulous !!!
Service was incredible !!!
Spectacular atmosphere !!!
Highly recommend !!!!
DB DB
My wedge salad was full of water from lettuce washing. Should turn the lettuce heads over and drain/dry before serving. It was like biting into a soaked sponge. Another person had the Caesar salad, and he spent time picking out lots of brown lettuce.
The fresh pasta dishes are quite small. I don't get it...it's pasta. I know you don't want people sharing which impacts the check, but there should be a little more give here, especially for $30+ per pasta dish (which are not posted online). And $10 for bread...that was a first for me.
very attentive staff and nice decor.
For what was approx 25% capacity, it took too long to get our food.
Food: 1
sarakp923 r
Bartenders Brian and Rodrigo were the most professional and outstanding bartenders. They were so accommodating and educated on all of the drinks. I would recommend this place to anyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luke Petaccia
Bartender/server Devin was awesome. He was attentive, gave good recommendations, and cared about the customer experience. Good place to celebrate special occasions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Carlos Soto
Im trying to figure out why they advertise a single dish every other post on instagram and Tik Tok yet it is only available 2 days out of the week??
Daniel Couri
Food is decent. The spicy rig was not spicy in the slightest and the hot honey mozz sticks were not spicy either so not sure what’s up with that.
Their pepperoncini martini was awful and I’m convinced there was no vodka in it.
Overall, food and drinks are not worth the price. I was flabbergasted when I saw our bill. You can get much better food elsewhere for cheaper. This just felt very boojie and over the top.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Niki Avianto
Service is amazing especially from Max who’s usually at the bar. And also the other bartender (I forget his name but it might be Anthony??). The drinks are amazing. You can tell they worked in NYC before by the service. Vibe and music is so fun. Food is great too. The one time we didn’t love a dish, Max noticed and took it off our bill without us even having to mention it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brooke Klinger
I had a wonderful date night here with my husband. Everything was delicious, but the stand outs were definitely the Trottle and the Butter Cake! I appreciate them asking about allergies and answering all of our questions. The knowledge of the food and what makes each ingredient special was clear from the team at deck tonight.
The whole team there were lovely and we especially had great interactions with the food runner Kyle and our server Devin. We are happy to see this restaurant join the neighborhood and can't wait to come back again!
Bar Mutz is a great dining experience for sure. Not great for people who don't like loud places. The spicy rig isn't worth the $ But the short rib Trattole is worth every penny. I crave it all the time. The prosciutto and mozz all was like $19-24 range and cake with 3 slices of mozz which was disappointing. Should've just gotten the mozz no meat. Still loved it and would come back to try some other stuff I didn't get around to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Mark Espino
Service was excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
E. M.
Dinner last night was disappointing at Bar Mutz. The decor overall felt cheap and had a cafeteria vibe while the food was incredibly expensive. I get that they’re trying to go for a hip vibe, but it comes across as cheap yet comes with food prices of fine dining establishments. A flavorless small plate of pasta was $32. Not sure how they have the nerve to charge the same prices as truly fine dining establishments, ex. Nougatine, a Jean George restaurant in NYC on Columbus Circle overlooking Central Park. Drinks were super small and over priced. I think the worst part was that $115 DI STEFANO LA FIGLIATA PER LA TAVOLA. What a rip off! Not sure who this Stefano guy is but his cheese board sucks! The spicy rigatoni was seriously lacking; if you want a great one, go to 130 Club instead. On the plus side, desserts were pretty good, but honestly, so disappointing overall, save your money and go to an authentic Italian restaurant in NYC for the same prices.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Daniela Whitman
Immaculate vibes, immaculate food, immaculate drinks. I haven’t had an appetizer, dish, or drink from here that didn’t exceed my expectations. The trottole is not only the best pasta, or the best dish at a restaurant, but the best FOOD I have ever eaten. 10/5, don’t do yourself the disservice of skipping this spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amber Mcdowell
LOVE!!! We went here for the first time this past Sunday. If you love a cool vibe and great food this is your place. Best mozzarella w/ prosciutto we’ve ever had. Idk what kind of Olive oil they use but 🤌🏼💋 Of course we had to get the Mozzarella Sticks. Love the Honey! We also got the Spicy Burrata & Chicken/ Sausage. New favorite place! Cocktails taste amazing as well🤎
This restaurant exceeded my expectations! Everything was perfect. Some of the best food I ate all year… truly amazing & so flavorful. You must order the Trottole pasta dish with the short rib. Absolutely insane flavor. The service was also fantastic, warm, & welcoming! The vibe is hip & trendy. Overall incredible dining experience. Can’t wait to go back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had dinner last night, hi-top table of 4 of us. Place is small and cute with funny decor in a good way. servers were friendly and funny and went along with our behavior lol. Expected good food, expensive and leaving hungry (small portions)...gotta say. the food was REALLY REALLY GREAT and we left stuffed. we had mutz/prosiutto app, buffalo app, the truffle foccia, some martinis and dinners we had (2) of the Trottle Pasta which was freakin amazing, chicken caesar milanese which was HUGE and tasty and the chicken/sausage Milanese which was HUGE and so outside the box tasty and unique. dessert we got the rainbow cake sorbet and the butter cake and they were crazy good. If I can get a table again, we will def go back...was really awesome. MG
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent !!!! The food was fabulous !!! Service was incredible !!! Spectacular atmosphere !!! Highly recommend !!!!
My wedge salad was full of water from lettuce washing. Should turn the lettuce heads over and drain/dry before serving. It was like biting into a soaked sponge. Another person had the Caesar salad, and he spent time picking out lots of brown lettuce.
The fresh pasta dishes are quite small. I don't get it...it's pasta. I know you don't want people sharing which impacts the check, but there should be a little more give here, especially for $30+ per pasta dish (which are not posted online). And $10 for bread...that was a first for me.
very attentive staff and nice decor.
For what was approx 25% capacity, it took too long to get our food.
Food: 1
Bartenders Brian and Rodrigo were the most professional and outstanding bartenders. They were so accommodating and educated on all of the drinks. I would recommend this place to anyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bartender/server Devin was awesome. He was attentive, gave good recommendations, and cared about the customer experience. Good place to celebrate special occasions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Im trying to figure out why they advertise a single dish every other post on instagram and Tik Tok yet it is only available 2 days out of the week??
Food is decent. The spicy rig was not spicy in the slightest and the hot honey mozz sticks were not spicy either so not sure what’s up with that.
Their pepperoncini martini was awful and I’m convinced there was no vodka in it.
Overall, food and drinks are not worth the price. I was flabbergasted when I saw our bill. You can get much better food elsewhere for cheaper. This just felt very boojie and over the top.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Service is amazing especially from Max who’s usually at the bar. And also the other bartender (I forget his name but it might be Anthony??). The drinks are amazing. You can tell they worked in NYC before by the service. Vibe and music is so fun. Food is great too. The one time we didn’t love a dish, Max noticed and took it off our bill without us even having to mention it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had a wonderful date night here with my husband. Everything was delicious, but the stand outs were definitely the Trottle and the Butter Cake! I appreciate them asking about allergies and answering all of our questions. The knowledge of the food and what makes each ingredient special was clear from the team at deck tonight.
The whole team there were lovely and we especially had great interactions with the food runner Kyle and our server Devin. We are happy to see this restaurant join the neighborhood and can't wait to come back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Bar Mutz is a great dining experience for sure. Not great for people who don't like loud places. The spicy rig isn't worth the $ But the short rib Trattole is worth every penny. I crave it all the time. The prosciutto and mozz all was like $19-24 range and cake with 3 slices of mozz which was disappointing. Should've just gotten the mozz no meat. Still loved it and would come back to try some other stuff I didn't get around to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Service was excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dinner last night was disappointing at Bar Mutz. The decor overall felt cheap and had a cafeteria vibe while the food was incredibly expensive. I get that they’re trying to go for a hip vibe, but it comes across as cheap yet comes with food prices of fine dining establishments. A flavorless small plate of pasta was $32. Not sure how they have the nerve to charge the same prices as truly fine dining establishments, ex. Nougatine, a Jean George restaurant in NYC on Columbus Circle overlooking Central Park. Drinks were super small and over priced. I think the worst part was that $115 DI STEFANO LA FIGLIATA PER LA TAVOLA. What a rip off! Not sure who this Stefano guy is but his cheese board sucks! The spicy rigatoni was seriously lacking; if you want a great one, go to 130 Club instead. On the plus side, desserts were pretty good, but honestly, so disappointing overall, save your money and go to an authentic Italian restaurant in NYC for the same prices.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Immaculate vibes, immaculate food, immaculate drinks. I haven’t had an appetizer, dish, or drink from here that didn’t exceed my expectations. The trottole is not only the best pasta, or the best dish at a restaurant, but the best FOOD I have ever eaten. 10/5, don’t do yourself the disservice of skipping this spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
LOVE!!! We went here for the first time this past Sunday. If you love a cool vibe and great food this is your place. Best mozzarella w/ prosciutto we’ve ever had. Idk what kind of Olive oil they use but 🤌🏼💋 Of course we had to get the Mozzarella Sticks. Love the Honey! We also got the Spicy Burrata & Chicken/ Sausage. New favorite place! Cocktails taste amazing as well🤎
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...