Little Nicky's Pizza

1610 Boardwalk, Wildwood
(609) 854-7037

Recent Reviews

G Santayana

This places is great on the beach or for dinner.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Nanci C.

Love their pizza. Best on the boardwalk. Definitely recommend. Pizza is excellent. Pizza is great.

Luke Hofmann

I ordered food here and the person working at the cashier pressed the tip $3 button thinking that I couldn’t see his side of the screen. This is 100% theft and then he gave me a receipt that only displayed the price and not the actual items I ordered. When I asked for the receipt he said it was too late. This was by far the most scummy thing I have encountered eating somewhere. I definitely do not recommend this place and the food was mid and very pricey. There are so many better options on the boardwalk.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Luke's side

Very disappointed. I ordered 3 slices to go. I walked 3 minutes back to our hotel and open the box, all of the cheese was melted and stuck on the wax paper. As a result, 2 of the 3 slices had no cheese on them. Not sure what the issue was.. maybe they need different wax paper or another technique. ?Pizza had a good flavor and the staff was friendly. I'll have to try again to give a higher rating.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Lidia Drybushar

Ordered from them for delivery on uber eats… like a $80 order and they forgot like 70% of it. my uber eats driver even told me that she asked them about it and they were like “no that’s it” that’s ridiculous. crabby fries are so bland, there were like 3 chicken tenders included in the order (for like $13) and the mozzarella sticks were cold. feel free to order from here if you like disappointment and want the rest of your day to be ruined

Food: 1

Catherine T.

Good place to grab pizza and a quick bite while on the boardwalk ! We stopped by quickly as a family of four with two little toddler boys ! We were quickly greeted and they even gave my little boys a free drink . Pizza was delicious !

John F.

It was $70 for 4 basic cheese steaks. Absolutely nothing special. I could have gotten 4 legit philly cheese steaks made right for $25

Iris P.

This was the worst place. I ordered 3 pies. I spent $85.00 and All of them where terrible. Over cooked no sauce. The little girl who answered the phone was rude. I asked her what was on a broccoli pie and she said duh broccoli. I would not recommend this place to feed my dogs. Never again worst pizza place on the boardwalk.save your money go to anywhere but here

Rebecca Callahan

Ordered a chicken parm sub & all 3 workers were prepping the food with their bare hands...no gloves on anyone!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Rebecca Burns

Ordered a chicken parm sub & all 3 workers were prepping the food with their bare hands...no gloves on anyone!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

K

Delicious Mushroom pizza!!! The chef was wonderful! Love the later hours!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

heather huff

Ordered 3 pizzas and 2 fries $96. Seriously? ?‍♀️ then we get home and basically ate nothing but crust. Couldn’t even add some garlic to the white pizza?? Oregano to the red pizza?? Very disappointed as this was our go to spot for 30 years. Never again!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Samantha Peacock

The owner was extremely nice. The food was cooked just the way I asked.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, French Fries

Daniel V

Pizza was acceptable, not too greasy. Better than other places on the boardwalk, would definitely come back.

Matt Dunleavy

Little Nicky’s is the most underrated shop on the boardwalk. They’re the real deal and I’ve driven hours from Philly just to eat there. I’m tired of hearing about Sam’s and Mack’s.

Load More