Cafe Amici
CLOSED$$ •
315 Franklin Ave #2096, Wyckoff
About Cafe Amici
Cafe Amici Reviews
Even after a previous bad experience I went back to Cafe Amici in Wycoff New jersey. I ordered the pasta special for the day at $40 which was to be a shrimp and lobster scampi - wee I got a super slimmy and oily mess with 4 medium shrimp. Ate the shrimp - poorly cooked - ate a little of the pasta. When I complained they offer me a dessert on them - $4.00 dessert!! Really! So left without the dessert paid the bill! I will never return and will do my best to spread the word!
Ratings
Menu
People in Wyckoff Also Viewed
Cafe Amici is a restaurant that offers a varied and delicious menu, with both Italian and Mediterranean influences. Customers have had a mixed experience, with some praising the "top-notch" food and "hidden gem" status, while others have encountered issues like cold potatoes, burnt omelets, and undercooked eggs on a Benedict. The French toast, in particular, has been singled out as a standout menu item. The service is generally described as "super friendly and attentive," and the atmosphere as "nicely decorated and inviting." However, some customers have found the lack of complimentary bread and free refills on beverages to be disappointing, despite the overall quality of the meal. Overall, Cafe Amici seems to provide a good dining experience, with a few areas that could use improvement.