I bought every cookie here as they are a cookie store and I figured these cookies would be good as i heard good things. These were the worst cookies i ever had. I guess its all a money grab these days. Thumbs down for sure what a waste of 45$
Mike Julian
We saw everyone walking around with rainbow boxes so we had to find out where they were coming from. Craig’s Cookies is an awesome spot. Happy vibes inside, and amazing cookies! You literally can’t go wrong with any flavour. And I don’t know if it was Craig serving us or not, but the gentleman working was a pleasure to deal with!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danyka Boulay
I liked the vibe as soon as I came in. It was about 9h30 on a Saturday night and it was busy. A lot of people coming in and out. I bought the classic and the lemon meringue. Omg they were both delicious. Tasted fresh. I will go back before leaving st. Johns. The employee was very friendly too. He gave me some stickers😁
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dank
great location and great service. unfortunately the cookies don't hold up. they're salty and dry, and i was unable to make it through even just one of them.the astronomical price for one of these is really not worth it whatsoever.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Marley Langman
Definitely worth popping in! The chai and apple pie cookies were our favourites that we tried.
Sheldon Manning
When they’re fresh they’re so good. Just ask what’s freshest out of the oven. Classic is always the best. But some good ones are Twinkie, Reid and caramilk. 6 cookies for 18 bucks. Best kind.
Susie E
As a baker myself of over 10 years, they were dry. Very dry.
I bought one for my brother in the hospital and he said he couldn’t finish it because he knew they aren’t supposed to be that tough.
I also could tell when I tasted a bit of it that they do not replace the cookies throughout the day or at least put them in something so they don’t dry out.
This was in 2023 so it may have changed but my experience wasn’t great. At least not for a 5-6$ cookie. Save yourself the money and buy a block of butter by
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Elena Elizabeth
I normally don't buy cookies, as it's always been something I've felt that I could make better myself, but these are the best cookies I've ever had in my life and I'm absolutely devastated that I won't be able to eat them again after I fly home from my trip. I got the peanut butter cup and s'mores cookies, they were both delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brett Paulitsch
The cookies are to die for. I got 3 with the intention of having just one and the other two later, but I crushed all 3. Irresistible.
Who doesn't like milk and cookies? You can go away. Everyone else: you have to stop in here. The cookies were delicious and the price was so reasonable (for someone who lives in Vancouver). Service was friendly. They have shots of milk. Shots. Of. Milk. They have full size as well in both regular and chocolate. All they sell is milk and cookies! I'm not a fan of stuffed cookies which are so popular right now. These are just normal cookies in fun flavors. I liked the Skor ones most.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob Vanelslander
Delicious
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Liz
Everytime I’m here for work, I make the incredibly difficult walk from my hotel room at the Sheraton to obtain a delicious Gluten free cookie. The staff is always super friendly and the cookies are 10/10. Love the classic, jersey milk , Skor and mini egg cookies. I sincerely appreciate that you always have GF and Vegan options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chloe Rachel
Our first time at a Craig's Cookies. The shop had a wide assortment of flavours. The staff at the counter was very friendly and helpful. Ended up leaving with a White Lotus and Gimme A Break. The White Lotus was on the crunchy side with a pasty lotus on the inside. Not your usual cookie shape! The Gimme A Break was moist with gooey chocolate chips. Great afternoon snack or treat! Side note, but we loved the colourful and creative labels advertising the flavours in the display case!
Danielle Francuz Rose
My husband picked up some cookies on the way back to our hotel, and we were super impressed. We got the carrot cake, peanut butter brownie, Kinder, and Skor cookies, and they were all delicious!
Cookies, what's more to say.
Except the flavor combinations were very good. I've tried a couple more than I should have. They were all good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ferrero Rocher Cookie, Oreo Cookie, Ice Cream Sandwich, Classic Cookie
I bought every cookie here as they are a cookie store and I figured these cookies would be good as i heard good things. These were the worst cookies i ever had. I guess its all a money grab these days. Thumbs down for sure what a waste of 45$
We saw everyone walking around with rainbow boxes so we had to find out where they were coming from. Craig’s Cookies is an awesome spot. Happy vibes inside, and amazing cookies! You literally can’t go wrong with any flavour. And I don’t know if it was Craig serving us or not, but the gentleman working was a pleasure to deal with!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I liked the vibe as soon as I came in. It was about 9h30 on a Saturday night and it was busy. A lot of people coming in and out. I bought the classic and the lemon meringue. Omg they were both delicious. Tasted fresh. I will go back before leaving st. Johns. The employee was very friendly too. He gave me some stickers😁
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
great location and great service. unfortunately the cookies don't hold up. they're salty and dry, and i was unable to make it through even just one of them.the astronomical price for one of these is really not worth it whatsoever.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Definitely worth popping in! The chai and apple pie cookies were our favourites that we tried.
When they’re fresh they’re so good. Just ask what’s freshest out of the oven. Classic is always the best. But some good ones are Twinkie, Reid and caramilk. 6 cookies for 18 bucks. Best kind.
As a baker myself of over 10 years, they were dry. Very dry.
I bought one for my brother in the hospital and he said he couldn’t finish it because he knew they aren’t supposed to be that tough.
I also could tell when I tasted a bit of it that they do not replace the cookies throughout the day or at least put them in something so they don’t dry out.
This was in 2023 so it may have changed but my experience wasn’t great. At least not for a 5-6$ cookie. Save yourself the money and buy a block of butter by
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
I normally don't buy cookies, as it's always been something I've felt that I could make better myself, but these are the best cookies I've ever had in my life and I'm absolutely devastated that I won't be able to eat them again after I fly home from my trip. I got the peanut butter cup and s'mores cookies, they were both delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cookies are to die for. I got 3 with the intention of having just one and the other two later, but I crushed all 3. Irresistible.
Restaurantji Recommends
Who doesn't like milk and cookies? You can go away. Everyone else: you have to stop in here. The cookies were delicious and the price was so reasonable (for someone who lives in Vancouver). Service was friendly. They have shots of milk. Shots. Of. Milk. They have full size as well in both regular and chocolate. All they sell is milk and cookies! I'm not a fan of stuffed cookies which are so popular right now. These are just normal cookies in fun flavors. I liked the Skor ones most.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Everytime I’m here for work, I make the incredibly difficult walk from my hotel room at the Sheraton to obtain a delicious Gluten free cookie. The staff is always super friendly and the cookies are 10/10. Love the classic, jersey milk , Skor and mini egg cookies.
I sincerely appreciate that you always have GF and Vegan options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our first time at a Craig's Cookies. The shop had a wide assortment of flavours. The staff at the counter was very friendly and helpful. Ended up leaving with a White Lotus and Gimme A Break. The White Lotus was on the crunchy side with a pasty lotus on the inside. Not your usual cookie shape! The Gimme A Break was moist with gooey chocolate chips. Great afternoon snack or treat! Side note, but we loved the colourful and creative labels advertising the flavours in the display case!
My husband picked up some cookies on the way back to our hotel, and we were super impressed. We got the carrot cake, peanut butter brownie, Kinder, and Skor cookies, and they were all delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...