Sugar Mama's

60 Elizabeth Ave, St. John's
(709) 579-2253

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Strawberry Cheesecake
Slice of Cheesecake
Cheesecakes
Cupcakes

Everyday menu
Half dozen cupcakes
6 cupcakes. You can request specific flavours or even if you prefer a buttercream or cream cheese selection and we'll do our best. Substitutions may be necessary to fill orders. Daily flavors include say cheese, drizzle, red velvet, oreo, 1/2 baked, carrot, vanilla, b&w, black white and cheese, sweet Georgia brown, mama drama, chocolate coconut, and vanilla coconut.
Slice of Cheesecake
Everyday Sugar Mamas has several flavors of cheesecake available in both no-bake and New York styles. Best sellers include blueberry, cherry, coconut cream, chocolate, creamsicle, oreo, caramel, apple crumble, and as well as the boyfriend cheesecake. Please specify your preferred flavour and we'll do our best to accommodate.
Cake Pop
Rolled cake on a stick and dipped in white or milk chocolate. Popular flavors include chocolate, cookie dough, vanilla, red velvet, and Oreo. Please request preference.
Dozen cupcakes
Assorted dozen cupcakes, combination of buttercream and cream cheese frosted flavours. Please specify when ordering if you have any requests!
Brownie
Fresh made chocolate brownie! Please specify if you'd like vanilla buttercream, chocolate buttercream or our most popular cream cheese with chocolate and caramel drizzle!
Single cupcake
Single cupcake, choose your favourite daily flavour. We're doing our best to get the list made available here!
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Vegan Cupcake
Sugar Mamas has a selection of vegan cupcakes available daily. Our most popular flavors include chocolate, chocolate Oreo, regular Oreo, vanilla, vanilla coconut, the boyfriend, chocolate coconut, and black and white.
Gluten-Free Cupcake
Gluten-free cupcakes. Sugar Mama's is not a gluten-free bakery, however, we take every precaution when baking and decorating our gluten-free cupcakes using the best quality gluten-free ingredients. Popular flavors include chocolate, say cheese, vanilla, chocolate, or vanilla coconut, as well as dulce de leche.
Meringues
Bag of sweet and light meringue cookies
Sponge Toffee
Bag of chocolate dipped sponge toffee

Beverages
Bottled Water
Sugar Mama's brand of spring water.
Milk
Central Dairies single serving milk
Chocolate Milk
Central Dairies single serving chocolate milk

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+21 photos
Photo credit: google
+20 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This place was so lovely! We’re visiting and needed gluten-free cupcakes for my daughter’s birthday so was recommended to Sugar Mamas. The options did not disappoint. We grabbed some chocolate and vanilla cupcakes beautifully decorated. The staff that helped us was very nice and patient while my daughters each picked out their desired cupcake. Would definitely return!
September 2025
The cupcakes are good, but when ordering several different specialty ones, like gluten-free and vegan, along with regular, they fail to label them and we are left wondering which ones are which. Not good for people with extreme food sensitivity. Things need to be labeled.
November 2024
Saw the sign from across the way and couldn't resist. I had an oreo cheese cakes and grabbed a peice of icecream cake for later. Both were very good, neat little store, friendly staff and a dang decent amount of selection!
August 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Piatto Pizzeria + Enoteca - 60 Elizabeth Ave
Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian
Desi Meal Restaurant - 27 Elizabeth Ave
Indian
Jumping Bean Cafe - Elizabeth Avenue - 37 Elizabeth Ave
Coffee, Cafe

Sugar Mama's

60 Elizabeth Ave, St. John's, NL A1A 1W4
(709) 579-2253