Pizza Stop
52 N Angel Fire Rd #1, Angel Fire
(575) 377-6340
Customers' Favorites
Meat Mountain Pizza
Battered Mushrooms
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Chicken Wings
Garlic Rolls
Veggie Pizza
Elk Chips
Menu
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I haven’t even picked up my pizza, but just the customer service alone compared to the other local pizza place is really no comparison at all. The lady that took our order over the phone called me buttercup! I mean, come on! Love it!
Even though they have a few tables, as of 7/31/2025, they are offering only takeout, which is what we wanted anyway. I called in the order, which was hot and ready when promised. The salad and pepperoni pizza were good and a decent value, but not outstanding IMHO.
Their pizza is hands down the best anywhere around northern New Mexico, so if you are really into authentic Italian pizza that tastes like something out of New York, then go here. If you are cheap, then don’t go here. They take pride in crafting a delicious pie, so don’t expect to pay fast food prices.
You May Also Like
Pub and Grub - 52 N Angel Fire Rd
![]()
Gastropubs, American, Pubs, Vegetarian
Legends Grill - 10 Miller Ln
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Bar, Pubs
The Lift Café - 10 Miller Ln
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee