NYP Slice House Pizza

Best pizza in LC period.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: New York-Style Pizza, New Yorker Pizza, White Pie

Delicious pizza, had a great meal! Don’t miss it ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time in here and we loved it. Highly recommend Josie as a server very kind. Polite and amazing person who is always asking if anyone needs anything

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We are originally from El Paso, so every time we go to Las Cruces, we make sure we stop at NYP for those XL pizzas. The family loves coming here, and yesterday was no disappointment! We ordered 1 XL Mediterranean, 1 XL pepperoni pizzas and 1 order of green chili cheese sticks. The food was delicious and the service by our server was on point! Always checking on us and asking if we needed anything! Thank you guys for making our dinning experience a positive one!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mediterranean Pizza, New York-Style Pizza

The food was ok. It didn’t taste fresh. The worst part though was when we ordered one slice of pepperoni, New Mexican, New Yorker, and Veggie, but they didn’t give us a New Mexican and they gave us another New Yorker. Normally this is just a mistake but no, the server said she ordered it by accident but then she said she should’ve double checked (meaning she knew she messed up) and then asked if we wanted another slice. It was very annoying. The pizza tasted frozen! Dion’s is better!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Pizza is my all-time favorite food!! I travel for work so I’m always looking for good pizza wherever I go.

I love that they have the New Mexican pizza with the green chili. I highly recommend it.

Jodie and Ana took great care of me when I went! Make sure to ask for them!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delicious pizza every time.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: New Yorker Pizza

I’m not sure why this place is never consistent? Sometimes you get an amazing pizza, then most of the time it’s terrible. Why? I guess I have to order a XXL pizza just so it is good? Any other time, it’s not. Tonight, instead of them cooking and sending me the pizza I ordered, they sent me an old pizza that had been sitting there all night. I’m not even sure if you want to consider it a pizza, or rather, a hard crust with burnt cheese on top. It was so overcooked from sitting there all day, that there wasn’t even sauce on it. Since the pizza was hard as a rock, we weren’t able to eat it.Hopefully, they will do the right thing and make us another pizza when I return it tomorrow.

I want to add, I REALLY hope there wasn’t a manager or Owner there when this pizza went out….
It’s another reason I didn’t want to eat it, because I could only imagine how many hands were on it trying to “piece together” a pizza. ??‍♀️

I also ordered garlic knots and they were still doughy/undercooked, which I actually don’t mind because I like them that way. I’d rather them be under baked , than over baked. I just had to put them in the oven for a little while.

Btw, I thought I would mention that the “large” pizza cost over $20.

I did attach a picture of what was expected. ☹️

Food: 1

Place has gone through some changes in the last couple years. Pizza was super good!! Will be going back more often

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Pizzas are good but too expensive. A large pizza here is basically a medium pizza at other places but for more money.
Everything time I come here I’m always thinking I should have just gone to Dion’s that’s like 10 minutes away.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Get the artichoke joe pizza.

I went for pick up and was given wrong slice, which wasn’t discovered until I got home- check your order!

Vegetarian options: Artichoke joe pizza is a must

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Artichoke Joe Pizza

Paid way too much for a cheese pizza that was little ceasars quality

Food was amazing as always. It was NOT busy at all on this Friday afternoon. Maybe four table has people sitting down. Our waitress must have thought she was the best ever because she doesn't write anything down for an order for four people, forgot our appetizer, had to constantly be reminded to bring us sauces, and then realized she never put it our appetizer order AFTER we finished our food. She gave us half off, and then brought out our appetizer in a to go box which we requested, and immediately sent it back because she didn't put in the order for the right appetizer. So now I waited an extra 15 minutes for my correct appetizer to be brought out so I could take it home as requested by my wife.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 2

Only one person working to serve, so unfortunately service and checkout was a bit slow..

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 3

This was our first and last time here! As soon as we walked in we weren’t greeted or seated I had to go ask a server in order to get seated. We proceeded to wait for about 40 min in order to never get attended to as we watched the server take phone and walk in orders. After watching countless customers get attended to we walked out never again thanks for the waste of time!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1