Buttercrust Pizza

CLOSED
$ •

2015 U.S. Rte 66 Suite 6, Moriarty

About Buttercrust Pizza

Buttercrust Pizza offers a welcoming atmosphere, especially thanks to the efforts of the new owners. The staff is friendly and accommodating, even during busy times. They are quick to remake a pizza piece without cheese if needed, and they handled a 45-minute wait without issue. The Chicago Beef Calzone is highly praised. This family-friendly, wheelchair-accessible pizzeria provides ample parking and is a popular choice for parties, with many customers noting their great customer service, good prices, and delicious food. The pizza is known for its perfect crust and flavorful sauce, with high-quality toppings like Italian sausage, onions, garlic, and green pepper. Customers also enjoy the Canoli, which is tasty and sweet. While some reviews mention that the pizza can be a bit light on toppings, overall, many find it better than chains like Pizza Hut and Domino’s. Visitors often recommend Buttercrust Pizza for both casual dining and special occasions.